Senate Race Heats Up Over Abortion
- Jan. 13, 2010, 5:29 AM Updated January 15
- COMMENTS (5)
BOSTON — Here’s what a gloomy male voice says in the Massachusetts Democratic Party’s ad against Scott Brown: “Brown even favors letting hospitals deny emergency contraception to rape victims.”
In 2005, Brown proposed a measure that would have allowed medical personnel with religious objections to refuse to provide emergency contraception to anyone. His proposal never passed.
Ayla Brown, daughter of Republican candidate for the U.S. Senate Scott Brown, faces reporters with her sister Arianna Brown, right, during a news conference at a hotel in Boston on Tuesday. (AP)
By Tuesday morning, some of the allies of the Democratic candidate, Attorney General Martha Coakley, had joined the fray.
“Time and again,” said Andrea Miller, executive director of NARAL Pro-Choice Massachusetts, “Scott Brown has shown he is willing to compromise — for political gain — the health and well-being of some of the most vulnerable women in Massachusetts, and this includes victims of sexual assault.”
Scott Brown’s daughters rallied to their father’s defense with a press conference of their own. His oldest daughter, Ayla, took a jab at Coakley.
“Martha Coakley’s new negative ad represents everything that discourages young women from getting involved in politics,” Ayla said, “and as a young woman, I’m completely offended by that. Her attack on my dad is completely inaccurate and misleading.”
As interest in the race picks up, Brown is accelerating his fund-raising. He says he raised $1.3 million in 24 hours, and he is spending some of his campaign’s money airing his own ad. In the ad, Brown is standing in a kitchen.
“By now,” Brown says, “you’ve probably seen the negative ads launched by Martha Coakley and her supporters. Instead of discussing issues like health care and jobs, they’ve decided the best way to stop me is to tear me down.”
This battle over Brown’s position on abortion comes as the race is becoming surprisingly competitive. Tuesday, Sen. John Kerry sent out an email to Democrats asking for contributions to the Democratic Senate Campaign Committee. Kerry called the race between Coakley and Brown “a dead heat.”
- Beacon-hill »
- State House Roundup: The Power Lines
- State House Roundup: An Intentional Community
- State House Roundup: Milkbone Underwear
- Commentary »
- With New Sox, Manny’s Worth Watching
- New Newton North Induces An Alum’s Jealousy
- Fantasy, Football, Come True
- Crime-justice »
- Gadson Sentencing A Symbol Of Multi-Generational Crime
- Brookline Police Search For Missing Officer
- Court Nixes Hiring Of Mass. Man To Probation Dept.
- Election-2010 »
- State House Roundup: The Power Lines
- Mass. Gov. Patrick Fundraising Picks Up In August
- In Kitchen Refuge, Patrick Rules
- Energy »
- Mass. Court Rejects Challenge To Cape Wind Permit
- Reps. Have Plan To Kill LNG Terminal In Mass.
- Mass. AG: Cape Wind Power Deal In Public Interest
- Environment »
- Chelsea Gets $2M To Help Control Diesel Exhaust
- Mass. Court Rejects Challenge To Cape Wind Permit
- EPA Sued Over High Cape Cod Nitrogen Levels
- Media »
- Worcester Telegram Begins Charging For Some Online Content
- Mass. Newspaper Erects Commenter Paywall
- Remembrance: Longtime Boston TV Newsman John Henning Dies
- Religion »
- Religious Relic Stolen In Boston Recovered In Vt.
- Rise Of Independent Groups Influencing Judaism
- Boston Advocates: New Vatican Rules On Punishing Clergy Abuse Fall Short
- Swine-flu »
- FAQ: Swine Flu Vaccine Availability
- Mass. Lifts Swine Flu Vaccine Restrictions
- Study: Swine Flu Is Relatively Mild Virus After All
- Friday's Show
Questions For Carol Johnson, Chief Of Boston Public Schools
Next week, more than 56,000 Boston public-school students will walk into the classroom for the first day of school. And while classrooms may look the same, much has changed behind the scenes. We talk with Boston School District Superintendent about Race to the Top funding, turnaround schools, merit pay and the contract negotiations with the Boston Teachers Union. More... - Week In Review: Earl, Unemployment, Governor’s Race
- Hurricane Earl, On New England’s Doorstep
- How To Meet A Nice Harvard Boy
- Hurricane Earl Races Toward New England Waters
- Hurricane #Earl: Live Updates From The Newsroom
- Remembering Esther Earl
- Your Boston Weekend: September 3-6
- Forecast: Earl Likely To Pass 50 Miles Off Nantucket
- Now We Are Alone: Living On Without Our Sons
- The Bard, Picasso Make The Berkshires A Worthy Trip
- Gadson Sentencing A Symbol Of Multi-Generational Crime
- ‘Same Old Place,’ New Pizza Recipe
- In Kitchen Refuge, Patrick Rules
- 'Same Old Place,' New Pizza Recipe
- Jokes To Tell Your Parents For Rosh Hashana
- How To Meet A Nice Harvard Boy
- Harvard Student Center Beckons Non-Believers
- Can Cognitive Exercise Speed Up Dementia?
- Hurricane Earl Races Toward New England Waters
- Freelancers Fight State's Independent Contractor Law
- The Bard, Picasso Make The Berkshires A Worthy Trip
- Earl Weakens To A Category 1
- A Casual Encounter With The Week's News
- Critics Target States' Double-Dipping Pensioners
- Safer For Your Soul, But Is Kosher Healthier, Too?
- Scientist Watches Glacier Melt Beneath His Feet
- A Village Sacrificed For China's Greater Good
- In Kitchen Refuge, Patrick Rules
- Opening Panel Round
- Bluff The Listener
- Boy Howdy! You Can Deep Fry Beer
- Flying Cars? Conveyor Belts? The Future Of I-95
Sound Bites, Friday: Earl Edition
A roundup of links, tweets and other nuggets about Earl, our swirly friend. More...- Your Boston Weekend: September 3-6
- How To Meet A Nice Harvard Boy
- Friday Morning: Baker Closes In, Dems’ Donations Surge, And Yes, Earl
- Hurricane #Earl: Live Updates From The Newsroom
I am strongly pro choice, at any time, for any reason. I am also a fiscal conservative, but a social libertarian. I only voted for Coakley in the primary because she, once, stated that she would not have supported the health bill because of the abortion compromise. Where does Kennedy stand on abortion. It is a pity that I find myself constantly faced with a choice of making a one issue vote, or considering other issues. The President, seemingly seeking to move blue collar democrats from the religious right, is selling out on women’s rights issues. What is Coakley going to do.It is troubling that a two party system, with two party primaries, favors candidates who avoid the center. Does anyone else feel the IQs dropping, every time we have an election?
Amen, Anna. The problem is unwanted pregnancy – not abortion. Stop unwanted pregnancy (contraception) and you’ll stop abortion.
These abortion arguments are so disingenuous. No one ‘likes’ abortion. The fact remains though, the countries with the most restrictive abortion laws have the highest rates of abortion! Restrictive laws do NOT lower abortion rates. Legal or illegal, women who do not want to carry a pregnancy to term will have an abortion. Why are we still thinking this way? Support comprehensive sex education and contraception if you truly want to lower the rate of abortion.
I would take what Brown’s daughters said a little more to heart if they had explained what Brown does and does not believe in with regards to abortions. To just say that Coakley’s comments were wrong is not sufficient. Maybe they were. But if they were, I would like to know in what ways. Otherwise they are just tearing down Coakley for what they accuse her of doing in tearing down Brown.
This headline–as with so many buzzing around at the moment–is confusing the issue. Since the debate, I _repeatedly_ see “abortion” conflated with “contraception.” Just because a Catholic hospital might be opposed to both (once hopes, opposed proportionately to each’s perceived gravity), I think that any hospital should be required to supply emergency _contraception_ to a rape victim–and that’s the real controversy here over Brown’s earlier proposal. He waffled all over this during the debate, refusing to come out and say that yes, his proposal had indeed supported just that position, that certain hospitals could refuse to provide this treatment if they objected to it.
Surely Catholic hospitals should prefer emergency contraception, which PREVENTS pregnancy (and therefore later abortion) to abortion. But Brown wanted to let them off the hook for either procedure. That adds insult to the injury of a crime victim.
He still has yet to say that he has reversed this position, saying only that a victim of rape deserves “immediate attention.” That’s far too vague, and his is a dangerous position.