The Associated Press

Mass. Towns Struggle With Debate Over Immigrant Services

Christian Gonzalez, 9, of Lynn, Mass., displays a placard during a rally, Tuesday, July 22, 2014, on the steps of City Hall, in Lynn, held to protest what organizers describe as the scapegoating of immigrants for problems in the city. The mayor of Lynn and education officials complain their schools are being overwhelmed by young Guatemalans who speak neither English or Spanish as their first language. Gonzalez, a U.S. citizen, was born in Boston. (AP)

Christian Gonzalez, 9, of Lynn, Mass., displays a placard during a rally, Tuesday, July 22, 2014, on the steps of City Hall, in Lynn, held to protest what organizers describe as the scapegoating of immigrants for problems in the city. The mayor of Lynn and education officials complain their schools are being overwhelmed by young Guatemalans who speak neither English or Spanish as their first language. Gonzalez, a U.S. citizen, was born in Boston. (AP)

LYNN, Mass. — The national debate over an unprecedented wave of Central American young people entering the country illegally is more of a practical challenge in places like Lynn, a former industrial city outside Boston that’s thousands of miles from the U.S.-Mexico border.

There, city officials complain newly arriving Guatemalan children are straining classroom resources, and the mayor and school superintendent have faced criticism for suggesting adult immigrants are posing as teens to attend school.

The surge of unaccompanied minors crossing the border illegally has breathed new life into what has been a long-simmering controversy in Lynn, and the debate is happening in communities around the country as residents and local officials are faced with providing services for the children.

In Michigan, a social service organization’s plan to house child immigrants from Central America in the town of Vassar has prompted multiple demonstrations, which have extracted a toll on the community of about 2,600 about 70 miles northwest of Detroit, said Vassar City Manager Brad Barrett. For example, police have had to add staff on duty during public meetings.

“Everybody has the right to assemble, but it takes additional time and resources,” he said.

In Massachusetts, Lynn Mayor Judith Flanagan Kennedy said the new students have been entering her city’s school system in large numbers for at least two years – 65 from Guatemala in 2012 and another 130 last year – and stretch district resources because they require special attention to address their limited education and English.

“I don’t want to give the impression that we in Lynn are anti-immigrant,” the mayor said in an interview. “This is strictly an issue of economics. … Our budget and our community are going to implode.”

She also has suggested that some of the students look older than they say and shouldn’t be allowed in the public school system, a charge that has drawn national media attention to the city of over 90,000 residents.

The claims are baseless, said immigrant advocates, dozens of whom rallied Tuesday in front of Lynn City Hall to denounce the administration.

The mayor continues to point to an “isolated incident” to support claims that many of the new students are older than their records suggest, said Juan Gonzalez, a local Guatemalan community leader and pastor. “They’re still talking about these two kids from two years ago,” he said.

Lynn Public Schools Superintendent Catherine Latham promised to provide proof of the apparently overage students last week, but then declined Monday on advice of legal counsel.

Kennedy maintained the issue is still prevalent, even as she acknowledged she’s never seen the students in question firsthand.

“This is very much a real problem for me as it is for the people in the border states,” said Kennedy.

Immigrant advocates, though, complain the mayor has been more interested in finding a scapegoat for the city’s budget challenges than real solutions to the district’s growing student population, which also includes resettled refugees and immigrants from other continents.

“These are the sorts of rumors and fear-mongering that, unfortunately, happen up here,” said Jay McManus, director of the Children’s Law Center of Massachusetts. “These kids don’t have anybody defending them. It’s a cheap way to score political points.”

Lynn high school students also disputed the mayor’s assertions. They said the new arrivals are largely isolated from the rest of the school body and, occasionally, subject to teasing.

Lorena Lopez, an 18-year-old junior at Lynn English High School, said she drew on experience to help some of them adjust. Lopez herself crossed the border without her family almost four years ago and has reunited with her mother, an immigrant who has been living for years in Massachusetts illegally.

“The first day in school, I was scared. I didn’t speak any English. The teacher spoke to me and I didn’t understand anything,” Lopez said recently. “It’s a barrier. But it’s not something that can stop you from achieving what you want.”

Besides Lynn, immigrant advocates in New Bedford in southern Massachusetts and Chelsea, another Boston-area city, have reported a steady stream of school-age immigrants from Central America. Precise figures were unavailable, but federal authorities say 773 – the majority from Guatemala, El Salvador and Honduras – had been discharged to family, friends or sponsors in Massachusetts as of June 30.

Gov. Deval Patrick has offered two possible sites to house young people after they are caught crossing the border illegally.

Those children are supposed to remain in holding facilities while they are being processed for deportation, reunification with family or asylum under federal law. But they can also be placed with family or other sponsors elsewhere in the country, pending the outcome of their immigration proceedings.

Please follow our community rules when engaging in comment discussion on wbur.org.
  • Steve Turcotte

    If we didn’t have the highest rate of poverty of industrialized country’s I would be all about open immigration to the worlds poor, but the reality is we can’t take care of poor children, family’s, veterans and the elderly. This will only strain nonexistent resources more. It’s a matter of economics, that has to be fixed before anyone will benefit.

    How can we help them when we can’t take care of those already here, it will compound the problem.

    Fast Facts About Homelessness and Poverty

    Families comprise nearly 40% of all who are homeless.
    According to the 2010 US Conference of Mayors report, Family homelessness increased by 9%.
    68% of the cities reporting in the 2010 Mayor’s Report, had to turn away homeless families with children because of a lack of available shelter beds.
    Among families who are homeless with children, the majority cited loss of a job as the cause, followed by the lack of affordable housing, poverty, low-paying jobs and domestic violence.
    42% of homeless children are under the age of 6.
    A child is born into poverty every 33 seconds.
    Families with children comprise one of the fastest-growing segments of the homeless population today.
    More than 15% of Americans live in poverty, including one in five children (22%), the highest rate in the industrialized world.
    Almost 60% of Americans will spend at least one year below the poverty line at some point between ages 25 and 75.
    There is no city or county anywhere in the United States where a worker making the minimum wage can afford a fair market rate one-bedroom apartment.
    The cost of rent and utilities for a typical two-bedroom apartment increased 41% from 2000 to 2009.
    2 million additional American children will fall victim to the foreclosure crisis over the next two years.

Most Popular