
 |
 |
| Every search and purchase you make
from here supports WBUR |
|
|
 |
At its best, an opera about the death of Spanish writer Federico Garcia Lorca is a tour-de-force.
"Ainadamar." An opera by Osvaldo Golijov (Deutsche Grammophon)
by James Marcus
 |
 |
 |
Cover detail of Deutsche Grammophon's release of Osvaldo Golijov's "Ainadamar." |
BOSTON, Mass. - June 27, 2006 -
For most composers, geography is destiny. Even Schoenberg--whose innovations were supposed to release music not only from its tonal prison
but from the local idiom of late Romanticism--always sounds, well, German. Still,
no living composer has demonstrated this truth as emphatically as Osvaldo
Golijov.
Born in La Plata, Argentina in 1960, he was weaned on a distinctive musical
diet: part Bach, part Astor Piazzolla. Yet his parents were both Eastern
European Jews, and Golijov's curiosity about his bifurcated heritage brought
him to Jerusalem in 1982. Later he moved to the United States to study with
George Crumb, whose dissonant procedures are still audible in an early piece
like the "Yiddishbbuk" (1992) for string quartet. What characterizes
his mature sound, however, is a freewheeling fusion of Latin rhythms and Sephardic
cantillation, plus a kitchen-sink approach to technique. If it works, he embraces
it--and this hearty pragmatism extends to the laptop computer, which Golijov
has called "a folkloric instrument of our time."
He has also shown a killer instinct for vocal music, producing an exquisite
song cycle ("Ayre") for Dawn Upshaw and the roof-raising liturgy of "La
Pasion Segun San Marcos." So it was no surprise when Golijov unveiled his
first opera, "Ainadamar," in 2003. Since then it has been heavily
revised and performed in both Santa Fe and New York. Yet the
new Deutsche Grammophon recording offers the first opportunity to linger over the details, and to consider
the music on its own terms.
This may be an advantage, since "Ainadamar" boasts
a rather clunky dramatic structure. To a great extent the opera is about the
death of Spanish poet and playwright Federico Garcia Lorca, who was murdered
by fascist thugs in 1936. Yet these events are refracted through the memory
of Margarita Xirgu, a Catalan actress who collaborated with Lorca during the
1930s and was lucky enough to survive the murderous whirlpool of Falangist Spain.
Despite
its skittish cutting between the present (meaning 1969) and the past, "Ainadamar" is
really Margarita's story. In fact, Golijov
originally planned to omit his putative
subject from the opera altogether. What inspired him to bring Lorca back into
the picture was the physical resemblance of mezzo-soprano Kelley O'Connor to
the martyred poet.
Strange, isn't it? So is the oddity of having a woman play
a guy. What keeps your ears glued to the speakers, however, is the glorious
ingenuity of Golijov's score. The very first thing you hear is a deep, ominous
pedal point. Then comes the sound of gurgling water (which reminds us that 'ainadamar'
means "fountain
of tears" in Arabic), followed by offstage trumpet fanfares, hoofbeats,
and a weird salvo of processed percussion. This last touch is especially brilliant.
The chattering rhythms suggest flamenco dancing, a manual typewriter, and gunshots--which
is to say, a sonic snapshot of Lorca himself.
Yet the pleasures here are hardly
limited to musique concrete. "Mariana,
tus ojos" begins with a simple bass vamp, which is soon reinforced by percussion,
clarinet, and plunger-muted brass straight out of Duke Ellington. Atop this
increasingly seductive rumba, Dawn Upshaw's Margarita weaves in and out of a
young female chorus--which happens to be singing the opening ballad from Lorca's "Mariana
Pineda." There's nothing showy about this compositional juggling act.
It
makes perfect sense in an opera about the simultaneity of past and present,
where the antipodes of beauty and horror keep colliding. So we accept the flamenco
fire of "Bar
Albor de Madrid" and the stately ornamentation of Kelley
O'Connor's first big aria, "Desde
mi ventana." And we accept, with
fear and fascination, the amplified hoofbeats and ululating cries that come
next, as the poet is summoned to his death by a Falangist hood. (Just imagine
the Commendatore from "Don Giovanni" with jackboots and a revolver.)
There
are moments, to be sure, when Golijov's postmodern vocabulary falters. A piece
like "Quiero
cantar entre las explosiones" can sound generic,
not quite transformed by the composer's harmonic mojo or timbral tinkering.
I had the same problem with "Crepusculo
delirante," which apparently
accompanies a sound-and-light interlude. It's very pretty, very Iberian, but
to these jaded ears it could have been a throwaway by Rodrigo or Falla.
When Golijov
thoroughly digests his influences, though, he's hard to top. The entire sequence
of Lorca's arrest and execution is a tour-de-force: as the poet is led away,
the fountain (represented by a hushed chorus) begins to weep. Upshaw sings
arching, agonized phrases that keep curving upward, like jets of water, while
the chorus descends and descends.
Next comes "Confesion," where
the poet is urged to beg for absolution before his captors put a bullet in his
brain. Golijov adds a marimba, anxious glissandi from the strings, and a field
recording of indigenous Mexicans praying to the Virgin of Guadeloupe (obviously
a favorite, since he used the same sample in a different composition five years
ago.) The effect is impossible to describe. We no longer know exactly what we're
hearing, yet the dread and tenderness and resignation have a kind of holographic
clarity. What comes next, alas, is very easy to identify: an interlude of gunshots,
complete with the tinkle of brass cartridges hitting the ground.
There's only one problem.
The opera isn't over yet. Dramatically speaking, there's no reason "Ainadamar" has
to end with Lorca's assassination: logic, in fact, dictates that we return to
1969 and let Margarita wrap things up. But after the preceding sublimity, a
whiff of anticlimax hangs in the air. It's effectively banished only during
the final trio, when the dying actress is subsumed into the voices of her pupils--in
other words, into human memory and eternity. As death scenes go, this one is
notably more cheerful than Lorca's, and it slides straight into an oceanic finale.
Still, deprived of any visual spectacle, it feels a little limp. Perhaps, as
the saying goes, you had to be there.

 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |


|
 |


 |
Singer at 100 An exclusive online special explores the controversial work and life of Yiddish writer Isaac Bashevis Singer. |
 |
 |
 |
Gauguin's Tahiti Paintings Take a multimedia tour of Paul Gauguin's Tahiti paintings, including the famous painting, "Where Are We From." |
 |
 |
 |
Hawthorne at 200 View a multimedia celebration of Nathaniel Hawthorne's 200th birthday. |
 |
 |
|
 |
|
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
 |