NPR

Face-Off Over 'Fracking': Water Battle Brews On Hill

Environmentalists and the natural gas industry are getting ready for a battle in Congress over something known as "hydraulic fracturing."

"Fracking," as the industry calls it, involves injecting a million gallons or more of water and chemicals deep underground to pry out gas that's locked away in tight spaces.

Environmentalists want the federal government to regulate the practice because, in some cases, fracking may be harming nearby water wells. The industry says regulation should be left up to the states.

Hydraulic fracturing allows drillers to dramatically increase production. The chemicals pumped underground with the water help drillers bore through the hard rock. The pressure used is tremendous — about 300 times a typical garden hose. That creates small cracks in the rock that allow gas to escape.

Steve Harris believes that pressure also ruined his well. He lives on 14 acres south of Dallas. Shortly after a driller fracked a nearby well, he and his neighbors noticed a change in water pressure.

"When you'd flush the toilet — in the back where the bowl is — water would shoot out the top of the bowl," says Harris.

When he took a shower, there was a foul odor, and the water left rashes on his grandson's skin. His horses stopped drinking from their trough, and there was an oily film on top of the water.

Similar stories are popping up around the country. In Ohio, a couple's house blew up when gas from their water well filled their basement. A woman in Colorado blames her health problems on the chemicals used for fracking.

For the most part, people nearby don't even know what chemicals are being injected into the ground — companies don't have to report that.

Theo Colborn, who founded The Endocrine Disruption Exchange, based in Paonia, Colo., has spent years trying to figure out what chemicals the industry is using, with some success. She says removing the exemption fracking has been given from the Safe Drinking Water Act would bring some much-needed light to the industry.

"Believe me, we have a lot of good people within our federal agencies that would love to be working on this issue and addressing it. And they can't — it's hands-off right now," says Colborn.

Generally, the Environmental Protection Agency regulates anything that could affect underground drinking water supplies. But in 2005, the industry successfully lobbied for the exemption for fracking from the Safe Drinking Water Act. That leaves regulation up to the states, which don't have the kind of resources the EPA does.

"We have no evidence that hydraulic fracturing is causing problems," says Lee Fuller, vice president of government relations for the Independent Petroleum Association of America. Without evidence of problems, he says there's no reason to pile on more regulation.

"I think people need to have more faith in the regulatory agencies that are watching it very closely and their ability to respond to issues if they arise," says Fuller.

But environmental groups are lobbying Congress to get that exemption overturned as hydraulic fracturing becomes increasingly common. Halliburton, which pioneered hydraulic fracturing, says about 35,000 wells are fracked each year.

Gwen Lachelt of the Oil and Gas Accountability Project says that politically, now is the time for those on her side of this issue to move.

"We have a different presidential administration. We have new regions of the country that are now experiencing oil and gas development," says Lachelt. "New York City is a case in point. ... Companies are wanting to drill natural gas wells in New York City's drinking watershed."

Several City Council members have expressed concern over that idea, and there's been talk of finding a way to ban drilling in that region.

But the natural gas industry argues that more regulation will push up prices. To be sure, hydraulic fracturing is, in part, responsible for the low natural gas prices consumers are paying now.

Colorado School of Mines professor Geoffrey Thyne understands that. Still, he wants the industry to start encouraging more scientific research on fracking.

"Let's prove to everybody what we're saying — that's there's absolutely no danger — but let's do it in a rigorous way we can defend," says Thyne.

Thyne says the industry also could agree to stop using harmful chemicals in the process. Already, several of the largest drillers have agreed to stop using diesel, which can poison groundwater with benzene.

Copyright 2014 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

DAVID GREENE, host:

It's MORNING EDITION from NPR News. I'm David Greene.

STEVE INSKEEP, host:

And I'm Steve Inskeep.

Next, for a report on news allegedly fracking with the water supply. Before you complain to the FCC, that word was fracking, which is a common term of the energy industry. It's shorthand for a process called hydraulic fracturing. And that is what an energy company may do when it injects huge amounts of water and chemicals deep underground.

They want to create pressure the helps to force natural gas to the surface. The trouble is that some say fracking affects the underground water supply and harms nearby wells. Now, the question is whether Congress should step in.

Here's NPR's Jeff Brady.

JEFF BRADY: Hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, as the industry calls it, is all about pressure. Millions of gallons of water and chemicals are pumped underground. The pressure can reach more than 300 times a garden hose. That forces small cracks in the rock that allow gas to escape to the surface.

Steve Harris believes that pressure also ruined his water supply. He lives on 14 acres south of Dallas. Shortly after a driller fracked a nearby gas well, he noticed the change in water pressure.

Mr. STEVE HARRIS: When you'd flush the toilet — in the back where the bowl is — water would shoot out the top of the bowl. And it blew some lines off of underneath my sink and in my bathroom under the sink.

BRADY: When he took a shower, there was a foul odor, and the water left rashes on his grandson's skin. Outside, his horses stopped drinking from their trough. There was an oily film on top of the water.

Harris says he asked the drilling company and the state of Texas for help, but nothing's been done so far.

Mr. HARRIS: Basically you get to the point where you think maybe everybody's working with the gas people and against the little guy. And, you know, the heck with them.

BRADY: Similar stories are popping up around the country. There's a couple in Ohio whose house blew up when gas from their water well filled their basement. And a woman in Colorado blames her health problems on the chemicals used for fracking.

For the most part, people nearby don't even know what chemicals are being injected into the ground — the companies don't have to report that. Despite all this, the industry maintains the practice is totally safe.

Mr. LEE FULLER (Independent Petroleum Association of America): We have no evidence that hydraulic fracturing is causing problems.

BRADY: That's Lee Fuller, a lobbyist with the Independent Petroleum Association of America. Generally, the Environmental Protection Agency regulates anything that could affect underground drinking water supplies. But in 2005, the industry successfully lobbied for an exemption for fracking from the Safe Drinking Water Act. That leaves regulation up to the states, which don't have the kind of resources the EPA does. But Fuller believes the states are going a good job.

Mr. FULLER: I think people need to have more faith in the regulatory agencies that are watching it very closely and their ability to respond to issues if they arise.

BRADY: Environmental groups are lobbying Congress to get that exemption overturned. About 35,000 wells are fracked each year. And that number is increasing.

Gwen Lachelt with the Oil & Gas Accountability Project says now is a good time to push for more regulation.

Ms. GWEN LACHELT (Director and Cofounder, Oil & Gas Accountability Project): We have a different presidential administration. We have new regions of the country that are now experiencing oil and gas development.

BRADY: The natural gas industry argues that more regulation will push up prices. To be sure, hydraulic fracturing is, in part, responsible for the low natural gas prices consumers are paying now.

Colorado School of Mines professor Geoffrey Thyne understands that. Still, he wants the industry to start encouraging more scientific research on fracking.

Professor GEOFFREY THYNE (Colorado School of Mines): Let's prove to everybody what we're saying — that's there's absolutely no danger — but let's do it in a rigorous way we can defend. Not back into it with, well, we haven't seen a proven problem yet so there's no problem. That's a pretty weak defense.

BRADY: Meantime, Congresswoman Diana DeGette, a Democrat from Colorado, recently said she's preparing legislation to remove the fracking exemption from the Safe Drinking Water Act and expects to introduce it soon.

Jeff Brady, NPR News, Denver. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Most Popular