Ahead Of Debate, Health Care Battle Lines Drawn
The House of Representatives is poised Saturday to take up its health care bill. With every step this legislation takes toward becoming law, the fervor — on both sides — gets stronger.
This week, the Capitol became the stage of an intense drama, the arches and columns its proscenium. Each party in the House unveiled its final health care proposal and immediately attacked the other's.
Reading Rooms
Republicans opened a health care reading room — a long table with highlighters, pens and stacks of paper perfectly placed to appear carelessly strewn around after serious study. Republican conference chairman Mike Pence urged his colleagues to go there to read the bill.
"When they do, we believe it will become obvious that this is nothing more than a government takeover of health care," Pence said.
Not to be outdone, Democrats opened their own reading room, led by Florida's Debbie Wasserman Schultz, to criticize the Republicans' bill.
"Their collection of proposals won't even end discrimination based on pre-existing conditions," Wasserman Schultz said. "I mean, that is the bare minimum that everyone in America, essentially, agrees should be part of any health care reform proposal."
On Thursday, conservatives involved in anti-tax tea party groups called their supporters to a rally on the Capitol lawn. Minnesota's Michele Bachmann, a House Republican, called it the final hour.
"As the clock is ticking 11:59 on this health care reform, Speaker [Nancy] Pelosi is poised with her health care bill to takeover 18 percent of the American economy," she said as her supporters chanted: "Kill the bill! Kill the bill!"
Abortion As An Issue
In a House office building, anti-abortion protesters, including Diana Rocco-Grandy, gathered outside Pelosi's personal office.
"I'm dressed as Nancy Pelosi burning in hell," Rocco-Grandy said, explaining her getup. "So I have a suit on that's singed and covered in blood, and I have chains on, and I had dead babies draped from me."
Rocco-Grandy is angry that the bill doesn't explicitly ban all federal funding for abortion.
"If Nancy Pelosi doesn't repent, and we pray that she does repent, and that she removes funding for child-killing from the health care bill," she said. "But if she does not, then she would be in danger of going to hell for forcing taxpayers also to pay for the murder of children."
Also outside Pelosi's office were people from Code Pink, the liberal group led by activist Medea Benjamin.
"We have hospital gowns on, and when we turn around, you see our bare buns," Benjamin said.
Her group carried signs that said, "Chances Are Your [Rump] Isn't Covered" — except the signs didn't use the word "rump."
"With our health care system now, there are not only 47 million people who have no health insurance, but a lot of people have such inadequate health insurance that their bare butt is not covered when they need it," Benjamin said.
Supporters shouted, "Health care for all," while protesters chanted, "Kill the bill."
The result was a noisy drama, a clash of political theater building up to Saturday's floor action.
ROBERT SIEGEL, host:
It could be a tough working weekend for members of the House of Representatives. Tomorrow, lawmakers are poised to take up the Democrats' health care overhaul bill. With every step this legislation takes toward becoming law, the fervor on both sides gets stronger, as NPR's Andrea Seabrook reports.
ANDREA SEABROOK: This week, the Capitol became the stage of an intense drama, the arches and columns its proscenium. Each party in the House unveiled its final health care proposal and immediately attacked the other's. Republicans opened a health care reading room ? a long table with highlighters and pens and stacks of paper perfectly placed to appear carelessly strewn around after serious study. Republican conference chairman Mike Pence urged his colleagues to come here and read the bill.
Representative MIKE PENCE (Republican, Indiana; Chairman, House Republican Conference): And when they do, we believe it will become obvious that this is nothing more than a government takeover of health care.
SEABROOK: Not to be outdone, Democrats opened their own reading room, led by Florida's Debbie Wasserman Schultz, to criticize the Republicans' bill.
Representative DEBBIE WASSERMAN SCHULTZ (Democrat, Florida): Their collection of proposals won't even end discrimination based on pre-existing conditions. I mean, that is the bare minimum that everyone in America, essentially, agrees should be part of any health care reform proposal.
SEABROOK: And then yesterday, conservatives involved in the anti-tax tea party groups called their supporters to rally on the Capitol lawn. Minnesota's Michele Bachmann called it the final hour.
Representative MICHELE BACHMANN (Republican, Minnesota): As the clock is ticking 11:59 on this health care reform, Speaker Pelosi is poised with her health care bill to takeover 18 percent of the American economy.
(Soundbite of booing)
Unidentified Group: Kill the bill. Kill the bill. Kill the bill...
SEABROOK: Over in the House office building, anti-abortion protesters gathered outside of Pelosi's personal office. Diana Rocco-Grandy(ph) was among them.
Ms. DIANA ROCCO-GRANDY: I'm dressed as Nancy Pelosi burning in hell. So I have a suit on that's singed and covered in blood, and I have chains on, and I had dead babies draped from me.
SEABROOK: Grandy is angry that the bill doesn't explicitly ban all federal funding for abortion.
Ms. ROCCO-GRANDY: We pray that she does repent, and that she removes funding for child-killing from the health care bill. But if she does not, then she would be in danger of going to hell for forcing taxpayers also to pay for the murder of children.
SEABROOK: But also outside Pelosi's office were people from Code Pink, the liberal group led by activist Medea Benjamin.
Ms. MEDEA BENJAMIN (Leader, Code Pink): We have hospital gowns on, and when we turn around, you see our bare buns.
SEABROOK: And they carried signs that said: chances are your rump isn't covered ? except the signs didn't use the word rump.
Ms. BENJAMIN: With our health care system now, there are not only 47 million people who have no health insurance, but a lot of people have such inadequate health insurance that their bare butt is not covered when they need it.
SEABROOK: Supporters shouted: health care for all. While protesters chanted: kill the bill. And the results?
Unidentified Group: (unintelligible)
SEABROOK: A noisy drama, a clash of political theater, all building up to tomorrow's floor action.
Andrea Seabrook, NPR News, the Capitol. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright National Public Radio.
- Beacon Hill »
- Mass. House Orders Staff, Not Member, Furloughs
- Mass. Artists, Lawmakers Meet To Discuss Creative Economy
- Patrick Rebuffed In Request For Education Bill Action
- Commentary »
- Soccer Championship Has Star Power On Its Side
- At 45, Caught Between Mammograms
- The Everlasting Allure Of The World Series
- Crime & Justice »
- 5th Arrest Announced In Mont Vernon Case
- Attorney: Mehanna Arrested After Refusing To Be FBI Informant
- Review: Police Not Responsible For Celtic Fan’s Death
- Energy »
- Evergreen To China Shows It’s Not So Easy To Be Green In Mass.
- Mass. Commission Ruling Means Delay For Cape Wind
- Harvard To Buy Power From Maine Wind Farm
- Environment »
- Evergreen To China Shows It’s Not So Easy To Be Green In Mass.
- Senate Democrats Advance Climate Bill Without GOP
- Harvard To Buy Power From Maine Wind Farm
- Ethics »
- DiMasi, Co-Defendants Plead Not Guilty To Corruption
- Former Speaker DiMasi To Also Face Extortion Charge
- Amid Confusion, State Lawmakers Postpone Tougher Lobbying Law
- Religion »
- Jesuit Educator Thomas O’Malley Dies In Boston
- Vatican Creates New Structure For Anglicans
- Remembering A Different Boston, 30 Years After Pope’s Historic Visit
- Sprint To The Senate »
- Friday Morning Roundup
- Pagliuca Tries To Capitalize On Apparent Health Care Rift
- Pagliuca Tries To Set Himself Apart On Health Care
- H1N1 Swine Flu »
- FAQ: Swine Flu Facts And Figures
- Flu Now At Historic High in Mass.
- ‘Free Shevaun’: The Challenges Of Controlling Swine Flu On College Campuses
- Flu Now At Historic High in Mass.
- Picking Locks For Sport, Not Sabotage
- FAQ: Swine Flu Facts And Figures
- Sen. Kerry’s Daughter Arrested On DUI Charge
- Boston Unveils Five-Year School Restructuring Plan
- Boston Man Dies From Swine Flu
- Mass. Unemployment Fund Running Out Of Money
- Does Boston Have Room For More Ice Cream?
- Study: No Cost Savings With Electronic Medical Records
- Boston Unveils School Restructuring Plan
- Study: No Cost Savings With Electronic Medical Records
- Flu Now At Historic High in Mass.
- Mass. Unemployment Fund Running Out Of Money
- Picking Locks For Sport, Not Sabotage
- Joshua Kosman, Predicting The Next Credit Crisis
- Sounds During Sleep May Help You Remember
- Boston Unveils Five-Year School Restructuring Plan
- Boston Unveils School Restructuring Plan
- Go Pink: Stamberg And Reichl Make Cranberry Relish
- Does Boston Have Room For More Ice Cream?
- At 45, Caught Between Mammograms
- Picking Locks For Sport, Not Sabotage
- Exclusive First Listen: Norah Jones
- 'The Onion': Mocking All Who Deserve It Since 1988
- Boston Unveils Five-Year School Restructuring Plan
- Joshua Kosman, Predicting The Next Credit Crisis
- Sacha Baron Cohen And Larry Charles Talk 'Bruno'
- FAQ: Swine Flu Facts And Figures
- Mass. Unemployment Fund Running Out Of Money
- A Son's Premonition, And A Final Baseball Game
- @WGBHLab Thanks. How about tweetUp @wgbh2boston? I'd help like did @wbur w @kengeorge. Cc: @frankdasilva @flickthistv @totalfilm @videostah
- at @wbur benefit screening of "yes men" at mahawie in GB; another #berkshires evening of awesome (no jokes this is cool)
- won a laptop from @WBUR !!!
- Woo! And it's @WBUR's 2nd most viewed article. OK, OK, back to work now, just exciting :)
-
Belmont World Film Family Festival
November 21, 2009
At Belmont Studio Cinema -
Boston Ballet at the Faneuil Hall Tree Lighting
November 21, 2009
At Faneuil Hall Marketplace -
Racing to the Top: Modern Leadership and the question of character-President Obama and leadership in the context of contemporary race relations.
November 21, 2009
At Boston University-George Sherman Union -
Esperanza Rising
November 21, 2009
At Cutler Majestic Theatre





