When Your Boss Wants Your DNA
Last month, Matt Williams, an adjunct professor at the University of Akron, opened an e-mail from his bosses about the school's new rules for hiring and was "absolutely blown away," he says, "when I saw the reference to collecting DNA samples."
The university was saying it could ask new workers for a DNA sample — to run background checks. But Williams knew his DNA could also be used to discover the most private of information about his health — like his genetic risk for cancer, heart disease or mental illness.
To Williams, who taught in the School of Communications, it was one more insult in the hard life of an adjunct professor. (He's an officer in a national organization, New Faculty Majority, that advocates for adjunct professors.) He says adjuncts at the University of Akron sign new contracts from year to year, so he expected to be counted as a new worker the next time his contract came up.
So he quit.
"I don't want to say necessarily that the university had any mal-intent per se," he says. "The problem is, if the university is maintaining this sort of information on its employees, the temptation to use that information is simply far too great in the future."
A spokeswoman for the University of Akron says the policy was appropriate but that it's now under review.
The Law
The school's policy seems to violate the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (GINA), says Susannah Baruch of the Genetics and Public Policy Center at Johns Hopkins University.
"Most generally," she says, "GINA prohibits health insurers and employers from using your genetic information against you." The law went fully into effect Nov. 21, and it prevents health insurers from collecting genetic information to make decisions about the insurance people get or how much it costs. The law also says an employer can't use it to make decisions about hiring, firing or job promotions.
There are a few exceptions. The law doesn't apply to employers with fewer than 15 workers. And while it covers health insurance, it doesn't apply to life or long-term care insurance.
The Science
It took over a decade to get GINA through Congress. Since then, genetic medicine has gone from an imagined frontier to scientific reality, Baruch says.
"Genetic medicine is expanding dramatically. So, for example, there are genetic tests available that can give you an idea of your increased likelihood of developing cancer. And once you have that information, you can do things to minimize your risk. You can pursue more preventive or early detection kind of care and really increase the chances that the cancer won't affect you."
For some medicines, there is testing to see whether they'll even work for an individual, whether the medication will cause side effects and what dose is the most effective.
But until now, Baruch says, people passed up genetic testing that could have helped them. They kept information hidden, even from their own doctors, because they had reason to fear that genetic information would be used against them. "Alleviating the fear was one of the primary purposes of GINA, so that we would all benefit from these advances in genetic medicine, rather than having to hide from them," Baruch says.
Now, she says, patients need to be educated about these benefits, and employers have to learn that they can't gather genetic information or family history of their workers.
Related Links
- Personal Genome Project Posts DNA Info Online
- Family Struggles With Ambiguity Of Genetic Testing
- Expert Weighs Questions On Genetic Testing
- Gene May Determine How Much Sleep You Need
- Rare Disease Treated Using Gene Therapy
- What's In The Law? From The Genetics and Public Policy Center Johns Hopkins University
RENEE MONTAGNE, host:
And as we mentioned earlier, there's a new law protecting your genetic information that has just gone into effect. Health insurers are prohibited from using that information to make decisions about the insurance you get or how much it cost you, and your employer can't collect your genetic profile or your family medical history to make decisions about hiring, firing or job promotions.
NPR's Joseph Shapiro reports.
JOSEPH SHAPIRO: Last month, Matt Williams, an adjunct professor at the University of Akron, opened an email from his bosses about the school's new rules for hiring.
Professor MATT WILLIAMS (University of Akron): I clicked on the link to the room and was absolutely blown away when I saw the reference to collecting DNA samples.
SHAPIRO: The university was saying it could ask new workers for a DNA sample, to run background checks. But Williams knew his DNA could also be used to discover the most private of information about his health, like his genetic risk for cancer, heart disease or mental illness.
Prof. WILLIAMS: I don't want to say necessarily that the university had any mal-intent per se. The problem is, if the university is maintaining this sort of information on its employees, the temptation to use that information is simply far too great in the future.
SHAPIRO: To Williams, it was one more insult in the hard life of an adjunct professor. So he quit.
A spokeswoman for the University of Akron says the policy was proper but that it's now under review.
Susannah Baruch of the Genetics and Public Policy Center at Johns Hopkins University says the school's policy seems to violate the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act or GINA.
Ms. SUSANNAH BARUCH (Law and Policy Director, Genetics and Public Policy Center at Johns Hopkins University): Most generally, GINA prohibits health insurers and employers from using your genetic information against you, to discriminate against you in providing health insurance or in making hiring decisions and firing decisions and all the other things that employers do.
SHAPIRO: There are a few exceptions. The law doesn't apply to employers with fewer than 15 workers. And while it covers health insurance, it doesn't apply to life or long-term care insurance.
It took over a decade to get GINA through Congress. Baruch says since then, genetic medicine has gone from an imagined frontier to scientific reality.
Ms. BARUCH: Genetic medicine is expanding dramatically. So, for example, there are genetic tests available that can give you an idea of your increased likelihood of developing cancer. And once you have that information, you can do things to minimize your risk. You can pursue more preventive or early detection kind of care and really increase the chances that the cancer won't affect you.
SHAPIRO: For some medicines, there's also testing to see if the drug will even work for an individual, if it will cause side effects and what amount is the most effective.
But until now, Baruch says, people passed up genetic testing that could have helped them. They kept information hidden, even from their own doctors, because they had reason to fear that genetic information would be used against them.
Ms. BARUCH: Alleviating the fear was one of the primary purposes of GINA, so that we would all benefit from these advances in genetic medicine, rather than having to hide from them.
SHAPIRO: Now, says Baruch, patients and employers need to be educated about these benefits and about the new law.
Joseph Shapiro, NPR News.
(Soundbite of music)
MONTAGNE: And you can find out what the Genetic Nondiscrimination Act does and doesn't cover at our Web site, npr.org.
(Soundbite of music)
MONTAGNE: This is MORNING EDITION from NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright National Public Radio.
- Beacon Hill »
- Mayor Controversy Throws Lawrence Bailout Into Jeopardy
- DeLeo Bets On The Colts And Re-Election
- Casino Supporters, Opponents Make Their Case On Beacon Hill
- Commentary »
- Advocacy Is In The Eye Of The Beholder
- The Richest Girls Basketball Coach In The World
- McGwire’s Record Breaking Tarnished? Sounds Like A Broken Record
- Crime & Justice »
- Death Of Kerrigan’s Father Is Ruled A Homicide
- Mass. Court: Sexual E-Messages To Minors Legal
- Shot Street Worker Gets His Day At City Hall
- Energy »
- As Battle Nears End, Cape Wind Still Divides
- The Art Of Going Green In The Museum
- Salazar Meets With Mashpee Wampanoag Over Cape Wind Concerns
- Environment »
- As Battle Nears End, Cape Wind Still Divides
- Invasive Plants Spreading As Climate Warms, Study Says
- The Art Of Going Green In The Museum
- Ethics »
- Galluccio Resigns From Senate After Being Jailed
- After Sentencing, Fate Of Galluccio’s Senate Seat Remains Unknown
- DiMasi, Co-Defendants Plead Not Guilty To Corruption
- Religion »
- Brown, And His Church, Don’t Wear Religion On The Sleeve
- Boston Archdiocese Releases More Information On Abusive Priests
- Archdiocese: Abusive Priests With Ireland Ties Worked In Boston
- Sprint To The Senate »
- How He Did It: Behind The Scott Brown Win
- Scott Brown, The New Hero Of The GOP
- Tea Party Credited With Giving Brown A Winning Boost
- H1N1 Swine Flu »
- FAQ: Swine Flu Vaccine Availability
- Mass. Lifts Swine Flu Vaccine Restrictions
- Study: Swine Flu Is Relatively Mild Virus After All
- Tea Party Activists Unite In Nashville To Protest Obama Leadership
- Why Does Time Fly By As You Get Older?
- Cyclists Race Through A ‘Canyon Of Beer’
- Teen Suicide Sheds Light On New Era Of Bullying
- The ‘Car Talk’ Spin On Toyota Recalls
- Brown’s Staff Shapes Up As Coalition Of The Eager
- Teacher Suspended After Party Photos Posted Online
- We Know Better, But We Text While Driving Anyway
- 'How's That Hopey, Changey Stuff?' Palin Asks
- Brown, And His Church, Don’t Wear Religion On The Sleeve
- Cyclists Race Through A ‘Canyon Of Beer’
- Teen Suicide Sheds Light On New Era Of Bullying
- We Know Better, But We Text While Driving Anyway
- Mass. Requests Federal Credit To Cover Unemployment Benefits
- Why Does Time Fly By As You Get Older?
- The ‘Car Talk’ Spin On Toyota Recalls
- Math Professor Helps Uncover Art Fakes
- DeLeo Bets On The Colts And Re-Election
- Teacher Suspended After Party Photos Posted Online
- Where You Live, Not Just Lifestyle, May Contribute To Diabetes
- WBUR Changes Weekend Program Lineup (90)
- Share Your Voting Experiences Today (84)
- Edward Kennedy, The Senate's Last Lion, Is Dead At 77 (64)
- Dems Question Why Brown Is Gaining On Coakley (64)
- Seeking Your Ideas For WBUR iPhone App (47)
- Brown Hits Back After Negative Coakley Ad (46)
- Obama Accepts Nobel Peace Prize As 'Call To Action' (45)
- Hollywood East's Less-Than Red Carpet Arrival (45)
- 'Absolutely' Wrong To Call Coakley-Brown Race A Statistical Tie (43)
- Blogging The U.S. Senate Debate (39)
- Tea Party Activists Unite In Nashville To Protest Obama Leadership
- Why Does Time Fly By As You Get Older?
- 'How's That Hopey, Changey Stuff?' Palin Asks
- Brautigan's Surreal Story: 'Trout Fishing In America'
- Teen Suicide Sheds Light On New Era Of Bullying
- As Battle Nears End, Cape Wind Still Divides
- We Know Better, But We Text While Driving Anyway
- Haitian Orphans' Fate In Limbo Amid Post-Disaster Confusion
- Teacher Suspended After Party Photos Posted Online
- Cyclists Race Through A ‘Canyon Of Beer’
-
Learning from Performers presents: soprano RENÉE FLEMING
February 9, 2010
At John Knowles Paine Concert Hall -
February Evening Lecture-- Some Recent Shipwreck Investigations in Northern Massachusetts Bay
February 9, 2010
At Northeastern University's Marine Science Center -
Salem History Society: When the Tall Ships Sailed Away
February 9, 2010
At Cornerstone Books -
Boston University's Distinguished Creative Writing Faculty to Perform Annual Reading
February 9, 2010
At Boston University School of Management




