Listen LIVE button
All Things Considered

NPRPast Decade A Roller Coaster Ride On Wall Street

December 31, 2009 11:35 AM

As the world celebrated the start of a new millennium 10 years ago, Wall Street too had plenty of reasons to party: The dot-com boom had driven technology stocks to phenomenal highs, and the rest of the market wasn’t doing so badly, either. All in all, the future looked bright.

What a difference a decade makes.

Since 2000, the United States has endured two wars, two recessions and a series of economic shocks that would greatly test investors' faith in the markets. Consider these events:

The Dot-Com Bust

Intel, Yahoo and Amazon were still young technology companies a decade ago, but they were also components in an amazing machine that had been churning out money with abandon. The tech-heavy NASDAQ composite index had risen by 80 percent in 1999.

But the tech boom would collapse with the 2000-01 recession, and a lot of the more tenuous dot-com companies would follow, proving that things like revenue and profits really did matter after all.

The tech sector would recover soon enough, but a lot of investors had to watch the mirage of illusory stock gains fade away.

A Black Day For The Financial District

The Sept. 11, 2001, attacks were a personal tragedy for a lot of Wall Street firms — companies like American Express, Merrill Lynch and Morgan Stanley had offices in or near the World Trade Center — but they were also intended to strike a blow at one of the symbolic centers of the U.S. financial industry.

In the aftermath of the attacks, the New York Stock Exchange remained closed for nearly a week, and stocks would fall sharply, but they would gradually rebound.

Corporate Scandal

With the decline in stock prices, a lot of companies that had relied on accounting tricks to make their books look good were suddenly exposed as frauds.

The first to go was the once-lionized Houston energy-trading firm Enron; it would be followed by WorldCom, Adelphia Communications, Global Crossing and others.

The scandals dealt a big blow to the credibility of Wall Street. Analysts and rating agencies that had lavished praise on these companies turned out to be as much in the dark as anyone else about what was happening. Congress would pass laws forcing publicly traded companies to be much more transparent about their dealing.

But once again, Wall Street would prove its resilience.

“It was an extraordinary event in the sense that so much was forgotten so soon. The speculative fervor intensified as we went through this past decade,” says economist Henry Kaufman.

A New Boom And Bust

To keep the economy going, the Federal Reserve kept interest rates at historically low levels. At the same time, financial deregulation had freed large financial institutions to borrow recklessly and experiment with new kinds of investments, Kaufman says.

What followed was a remarkable era of loose credit. Suddenly it was ridiculously easy to get a credit card, refinance a mortgage or even build a shopping center. In the economic boom that followed, unemployment fell, the price of oil and other commodities soared, and real estate frenzy gripped states like Florida, Nevada and Arizona. By October 2007, the Dow Jones industrial average hit an all-time high of 14,164.

But as housing prices started to fall again, banks and hedge funds that had invested in mortgages took a huge hit. In September 2008, financial giants like AIG, Lehman Brothers and Merrill Lynch were either seized by the federal government or shut down altogether. Credit dried up, dealing a blow to the global economy that the world is still recovering from. By last March, the Dow Jones industrial average had lost more than half its value.

A New Day

The Fed and the Treasury Department responded with a series of highly controversial taxpayer-funded bailouts of some of the firms that were hardest hit by the downturn, including Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, General Motors and major banks like Citigroup and Bank of America. Today, the markets have stabilized, and stock prices have enjoyed one of their best years in a long time.

But the wild swings of the past few years have left a lot of investors chastened and have given them a new sense of just how risky the markets can be.

Once, it was conventional wisdom that the markets would always go up over time, and that stocks represented the best investment, if you could only ride out the downturns. The notion of buy-and-hold investing has been discredited somewhat, says Bernie McSherry, senior vice president of strategic initiatives at Cuttone & Co.

But the markets have traditionally bounced between fear and greed, and as stocks recover, so too will people’s faith in the markets, McSherry says.

“Now that the markets … are starting to move back up, people are going to see the potential for profit, and that greed part of the equation does come into play,” he says. “People will start to step back into the markets. It’s been going on for hundreds of years, and it’s in the nature of markets.” Copyright 2010 National Public Radio. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Related Links

+
-
View Transcript

ROBERT SIEGEL, host:

As bad as 2009 was for the economy, believe it or not, it will likely be remembered as the year the stock market bounced back. From its low point in March, the Dow rallied more than 60 percent. While it may have been a good year for investors, it was not a good decade. In fact, by some measures it was the worst decade since the 1940s.

NPR's Jim Zarroli has this look back.

JIM ZARROLI: In the days right after 9/11, President Bush could still boast about the health of the U.S. economy. The country may have been attacked, he said, but�

Pres. BUSH: The American economy is fundamentally strong. We have the best educated, most productive workforce in the world. Our factories produce more goods and a broader variety of goods than any county in the world.

ZARROLI: Until then, stocks had been on a tear. It was conventional wisdom that they represented the best long-term investment you could make. But the years that followed would challenge that assumption. Showcase companies like Enron and WorldCom were revealed to be accounting frauds and the analysts and rating agencies that had lavished praise on these companies were as much in the dark as anyone else. Once lionized figures, like Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan, saw their reputations take a hit. But the markets would quickly recover says economist Henry Kaufman.

Professor HENRY KAUFMAN (Economist): It was an extraordinary event in the sense that so much was forgotten so soon. The speculative fervor intensified as we went through this past decade.

ZARROLI: For a time, the Fed kept interest rates low. Then too, Kaufman says, deregulation had freed large financial institutions to borrow recklessly and experiment with new kinds of investments. What followed was a remarkable era of loose credit. Suddenly it was extraordinarily easy to get a credit card, refinance a mortgage or even build a shopping center. By October, 2007, the Dow hit an all-time high of 14,164. What happened next is now a depressingly familiar story as housing prices started to fall, investment banks and hedge funds that had invested in mortgages took a huge hit, credit dried up. Bernie McSherry of Cuttone & Company viewed the carnage from his perch at the New York Stock Exchange.

Mr. BERNIE MCSHERRY (Senuior Vice President, Cuttone & Co): For a number of days last autumn, it felt like the entire edifice was going to crumble and that we'd all wake up in the morning and our ATM's would not have any money in it and nothing is going to work. And there were a lot of bad jokes made about buying guns and ammunition around here and stocking up on canned goods. And that was just reflective of the fact that people were very, very fearful and I've never seen that before.

ZARROLI: In the ensuing recession, the Dow lost half its value. For investors this decade will go down as one of the worst in Wall Street history. And McSherry says something else has been lost as well. He says the public's belief in buy-and-hold investing, the notion that the market will go up over time if you're patient and willing to ride out the downturns, has been weakened. Take Kristin Gabral(ph), a stay-at-home mom from Virginia who was visiting New York recently. Before the recession, she and her husband put much of their retirement savings into stocks. That's changed.

Ms. KRISTIN KARBAU: We're not going to put as much in stocks as we once did, because we took such a hard hit.

ZARROLI: Since March, stock prices have already regained a good bit of the ground they lost, and Bernie McSherry says it's only a matter of time before people's faith in the markets will follow. McSherry says the financial markets have always bounced between fear and greed.

Mr. MCSHERRY: Now that the markets are stabilized and are starting to move back up, people are going to start seeing the potential of profit and that greed part of the equation does come into play. And people will start to step back into the market. It's been going on for hundreds of years and it is the nature of markets.

ZARROLI: On the other hand, there's no question that the wild swings in the market this decade have chastened a lot of people and given them a sense of just how risky stocks can be.

Jim Zarroli, NPR News, New York. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright National Public Radio.

Source: NPR
WBUR Topics
Most Popular
This site is best viewed with: Firefox | Explorer 8 | Chrome | Safari | Weather data provided by Yahoo!