All Things Considered

NPRIn Pakistan, Old Militants Create New Alliances

A Pakistani devotee looks at wreckage following a suicide bomb - A Pakistani looks at wreckage the day after a suicide bomb attack at a Sufi shrine in Lahore. Two suicide bombers blew themselves up in the Islamic shrine packed with worshipers on July 1, killing at least 37 people and wounding scores more. (Arif Ali / AFP/Getty)

In Pakistan, far from the isolated mountains of the tribal belt where the Taliban first appeared, an extremist network has taken root in the country's heartland.

The Punjab province is home not only to 80 million of Pakistan's 175 million citizens, but also to an increasingly dangerous web of Punjabi militants who have teamed up with the Pakistani Taliban, known as Tehrik-e-Taliban, and al-Qaida.

In southern Punjab province, militancy is not a new phenomenon, but it is an ever-evolving one.

We consider this training and this preparation for jihad is something good. And it is for our own protection. It is not for terrorism. It is just for our own defense.
–Mohammad Noman, 17, student at a religious school

The city of Multan is known for its Sufis and saints, and its shahids, or martyrs. So-called Martyrs Street sits among a cluster of rubble-strewn lanes housing families who have lost a male relative to jihad, or "holy war."

Fathers and sons fought in the jihad against the Soviets during their occupation of Afghanistan in the 1980s, and later against the Indians in Kashmir, the Himalayan region disputed between India and Pakistan.

Then, the Punjab's men joined the fight when Pakistan's government was promoting jihad as a state policy in the 1980s and 1990s.

At the end of the day, they end up outcasts of this society, and they got recognition when they joined the Taliban.
–Usman Anwar, police investigator

Today, a new generation in southern Punjab is being raised on a brand of Islam that has effectively declared war against the government and the people of Pakistan.

Southern Punjab Is Different

Khaled Ahmed is one of the foremost experts on Pakistan's militant groups. He says extremists have gained a foothold in southern Punjab because governance is weak and feudal landowners have run things. But the sway of landowners is being supplanted by increasingly influential Muslim clerics.

"You have to work in tandem with the big person there. And that big person is being replaced by the clergy, the clergy which is 'weaponized.' So that is why the south Punjab is such a breeding ground," Ahmed says.

A senior law enforcement official in Multan says 19 mosques and madrassas, or religious schools, are known to be patronized by activists suspected of terrorist activities. In the Multan district alone, 63 people are under strict surveillance. A dozen more are targets in ongoing anti-terrorism investigations.

Punjab is home to nearly half of Pakistan's 20,000 madrassas. Hundreds of seminaries in Multan follow the hard-line Deobandi school of Islam, not unlike the puritanical Wahhabism practiced by al-Qaida's founders.

Conspiracy Theories Blame The U.S. For Attacks

Friday sermons in Punjab are instructive. The July 1 bombing of the country's most important Sufi shrine, which killed dozens in the provincial capital, Lahore, got prominent mention at one particular Multan mosque.

While authorities suspect Islamist extremists, in his sermons, Maulana Muhammad Kafeel Bukhari was quick to blame the Americans. Bukhari said the double suicide attack that left dozens dead was the work of the security firm Blackwater, a private, U.S.-based security company now known as Xe Services.

In Pakistan, conspiracy theories that blame the West for the bloody turmoil in the country are promoted in the mass media and shared by many members of the Pakistani public.

"It's so easy to blame the Taliban in southern Punjab," Bukhari told a couple hundred of the faithful. "But I say it's been carried out by the enemies of this country: the foreign intelligence services, to create anarchy and to break Pakistan up," Bukhari said.

Asked later about the claim, Punjab's governor, Salmaan Taseer, scorned the idea that Blackwater was involved as "a load of rubbish."

Distrust Of The West

But Bukhari's sermon falls on receptive young ears. Ali Mardan, 23, says he believes the United States is supporting local terrorists to destabilize Pakistan and seize its nuclear weapons.

Mardan says Washington is "afraid that if any religious man becomes a prime minister or president or he takes over the government, he will create a lot of problems for the U.S."

Mohammad Noman, 17, says an Islamic state like Pakistan has a duty to prepare for jihad "to defend the faith." An aspiring cleric, Noman says militant groups, although banned, must continue to train.

"We consider this training and this preparation for jihad is something good. And it is for our own protection. It is not for terrorism. It is just for our own defense," Noman says.

Old Groups Create New Alliances

Usman Anwar, a senior police investigator in Punjab, says there are as many as 30 armed outfits in the province. Most are splinter groups from organizations that are now outlawed: Sipah-e-Sahaba, Lashkar-e-Jhangwi, and Jaish-e-Mohammad, the alleged recruiter of Faisal Shahzad, who sought to detonate a bomb in Times Square on May 1.

The U.S. invasion of Afghanistan, following the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, gave these groups renewed fervor.

"Al-Qaida told them, 'Jihandis, they have beaten Russia, and now it's time for the West to have a taste of its own medicine.' Now they had a greater cause. So the breeding ground was already there, and al-Qaida selected these groups," Anwar says.

Anwar says the groups attack Pakistani targets because they regard their government as a tool of the U.S. He says his many interrogations of young militants start out as debates about perceived international injustices and move to local inequities.

"They see a government which is not efficient; they see a road which is broken. They were school dropouts. And at the end of the day, they end up outcasts of this society, and they got recognition when they joined the Taliban," says Anwar.

Local analyst Haider Abbas Gardezi says a distressed place like the southern Punjab is a Petri dish for extremism.

"Militancy grows in those pockets where there are deprivations, where there is injustice, where there is lack of education. So basically it's a question of backwardness," Gardezi says.

But Ayesha Saddiqa, a Pakistani security analyst and visiting professor at Johns Hopkins University, says it's not just madrassas in underprivileged places that are providing recruits. Young, tech-savvy engineers from government-run schools are quietly being pulled into the militant network, too.

"They are co-existing with other social forces as well, and that is the trick. You don't attract attention so everyone can say, 'Oh no -- there's no Talibanization.' "

Outlawed Groups Banned In Name Only

Parliamentarian Sheikh Waqas Akram says groups may be banned, but they remain brazen. He says that in his district of Jhang, the outlawed group Sipah-e-Sahaba openly flaunts its identity with flags and gun-toting bodyguards. Akram says you wouldn't know that the group's leader is on a government watch list.

"That man is moving freely, attending funerals, going to madrassas, going to the deputy commissioner's office, going to the police chief's office. What is this?" Akram asks.

Author Khaled Ahmed says these groups thrive because it suits the ruling party of the province, the Pakistan Muslim League, led by the country's main opposition figure, Nawaz Sharif. Sharif's brother is the chief minister of Punjab. Ahmed says the Sharifs are pulled in two directions.

"They are very much joined at the hips with the clergy and have grown up like that. But they have grown up relating to outside powers like the United States, and grown up knowing that secular societies probably are more tolerant because they are not fanatics," Ahmed says.

"So there is this ideological confusion in the family," he adds.

In the aftermath of the attack on Lahore's Sufi shrine, mainstream clerics have accused the Punjab government of being soft on extremist groups, while protesters have taken to the streets of the Punjab capital decrying terrorism.

The two men most responsible for administering the province -- Gov. Salmaan Taseer and Chief Minister Shabaz Sharif -- have been at odds over how to treat the growing menace.

A spokesman for Sharif insists that he is taking a tough stance, but in March the chief minister pleaded with the militants to "spare Punjab" because his party shares their anti-Western attitude.

Taseer, who is from the ruling People's Party, called that "craven."

"If you don't take a strong stance against these people right now and nip in the bud, they'll start spreading. You can't allow them to grow. They're like a cancer virus," Taseer says.

As the debate intensifies, evidence of militant activity continues to surface. A cache of illegal arms, including 500,000 rounds of bullets, was recently uncovered outside Lahore. Detained suspects told investigators of plans to attack 18 new sites.

Copyright 2012 National Public Radio. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

ROBERT SIEGEL, host:

This is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED, from NPR News. I'm Robert Siegel.

MICHELE NORRIS, host:

And I'm Michele Norris.

And we begin this hour in Pakistan, not in the isolated mountains of the tribal belt where the Taliban first appeared, but in the country's heartland where an extremist network has taken root.

Punjab province is home to more than half of Pakistan's 175 million citizens. It's also home to an increasingly dangerous web of Punjabi militants who've teamed up with the Pakistani Taliban and al-Qaida.

NPR's Julie McCarthy has the story.

JULIE McCARTHY: Here in Multan, known as the city of Sufis and saints, this treeless unpaved lane is testament to the long legacy of militants in the Punjab. We're standing on so-called Martyrs Street in a row of rubble-strewn streets, housing families who've lost sons and fathers. They fought in the jihad against the Soviets in Afghanistan and later against the Indians in Kashmir, and they joined up when the government was promoting jihad as a state policy in the 1980s and '90s.

Today, a new generation in southern Punjab is being raised on a brand of Islam that has declared war against the government and the people of Pakistan.

Mr. KHALED AHMED (Editor, The Friday Times): South Punjab has always been very different from the rest of Punjab.

McCARTHY: Khaled Ahmed is one of the foremost experts on Pakistan's militant groups. He says extremists have gained a foothold in southern Punjab because governance is weak and feudal landowners dominate.

Mr. AHMED: They have to work in tandem with the big person there, and that big person is being replaced by the clergy, the clergy which is weaponized. So that is why south Punjab is such a breeding ground.

Unidentified Man #1: (Speaking Foreign Language)

McCARTHY: Punjab is home to nearly half of Pakistan's 20,000 madrassas. Hundreds of religious seminaries in Multan follow the hard-line Deobandi school of Islam, not unlike the puritanical Wahhabism practiced by al-Qaida's founders.

A recent Friday sermon at this mosque gave prominent mention to the July 1st bombing in the provincial capital, Lahore, at the country's most important Sufi shrine.

While authorities suspect Islamist extremists, the cleric was quick to blame the Americans. Maulana Muhammad Kafeel Bukhari said the suicide attack that left dozens dead was the work of the security firm Blackwater.

Mr. MAULANA MUHAMMAD KAFEEL BUKHARI (Imam): (Speaking Foreign Language)

McCARTHY: It's so easy to blame the Taliban in southern Punjab, Bukhari said, but I say it's been carried out by the enemies of this country, the foreign intelligence services, to create anarchy and to break Pakistan up, he says.

Punjab's governor calls the notion that Blackwater was involved rubbish, but Bukhari's sermon falls on receptive young ears. Twenty-three-year-old Ali Mardan believes the U.S. is supporting local terrorists to destabilize Pakistan and seize its nuclear weapons.

Mr. ALI MARDAN: They're afraid that if any religious man become a prime minister or a president or he takes over the government, he will create a lot of problem for U.S.

McCARTHY: Seventeen-year-old Mohammad Noman says an Islamic state like Pakistan has a duty to prepare for jihad to defend the faith. An aspiring cleric, Noman says militant groups, although banned, must continue to train.

Mr. MOHAMMAD NOMAN: (Through Translator) We consider this training and this preparation for jihad as something good, and it is for our own protection. It is not for terrorism.

McCARTHY: Senior Punjab police investigator Usman Anwar says there are as many as 30 armed outfits in the country's richest, most populous province. Most are splinter groups from organizations that are now outlawed: Sipah-e-Sahaba, Lashkar-e-Jhangwi and Jaish-e-Mohammad, the alleged recruiter of Times Square bomber Faisal Shahzad.

The 2001 U.S. invasion of Afghanistan gave these groups renewed fervor.

Mr. USMAN ANWAR (Police Chief, Sargodha, Punjab Province): Al-Qaida told them that, you know, jihadists, they have beaten Russia. Now it is time for the West to have a taste of its own medicine. Now, they had a greater cause.

McCARTHY: Anwar says they attack Pakistani targets because they regard their government as a tool of the U.S. He says his many interrogations of young militants start out as debates about perceived international injustices and move to local inequities. And there are many in a place like the southern Punjab, says local analyst Haider Gardezi.

Mr. HAIDER GARDEZI (Analyst): Militancy grows in those pockets where there is deprivations, where there is injustice, where there is lack of education. So basically, it's a question of backwardness.

McCARTHY: Ayesha Saddiqa, a visiting professor at Johns Hopkins University, says it's not just madrassas in poor places providing recruits. Young, tech-savvy engineers from government-run schools are quietly being pulled into the militant network.

Dr. AYESHA SADDIQA (Visiting Scholar, Johns Hopkins University's School of Advanced International Studies): They are coexisting with other social forces as well, and that is the trick. You don't attract attention, so everybody can say: Oh, no, no, no, there is no - but there is no Talibanization.

McCARTHY: Parliamentarian Waqas Akram says in his district, so strong is the banned Sipah-e-Sahaba that it flaunts its identity with flags and gun-toting bodyguards. Akram says you wouldn't know that the group's leader is on a government watch list.

Mr. WAQAS AKRAM (Member, National Assembly, Pakistan): That man is moving freely, attending funerals, going to madrassas, going to the deputy commissioner's office, going to the police chief's office. What is this?

McCARTHY: Author Khaled Ahmed says these groups are banned in name only and thrive because it suits the ruling party of the province, the Pakistan Muslim League, led by the country's main opposition figure, Nawaz Sharif. His brother is the chief minister of Punjab. Khaled Ahmed says the Sharifs are pulled in two directions.

Mr. AHMED: They are very much joined at the hips with the clergy in Lahore, and they have grown up like that. But they have also grown up relating to outside powers like the United States that secular societies are probably more tolerant because they are not fanatics. So there is this confusion, ideological confusion, in the family.

McCARTHY: In the aftermath of the attack on Lahore's Sufi shrine, mainstream clerics accuse the Punjab government of being soft on extremist groups.

(Soundbite of demonstration)

Unidentified Man #2: (Speaking Foreign Language)

Unidentified Group: (Speaking Foreign Language)

Unidentified Man #2: (Speaking Foreign Language)

McCARTHY: Since the bombing in Lahore, protesters have taken to the streets of the Punjabi capital decrying terrorism.

The two men most responsible for administering the province - the governor and the chief minister, Shabaz Sharif - have been at odds over how to treat the growing menace.

A spokesman for Sharif insists that he is taking a tough stance, but in March, the chief minister pleaded with the militants to spare Punjab because his party shares their anti-Western attitude.

Punjab Governor Salmaan Taseer, who is from the ruling People's Party, called that craven.

Mr. SALMAAN TASEER (Governor, Punjab Province, Pakistan): If you don't take a tough stance against these people right now and nip it in the bud, they'll start spreading, like a cancer virus.

McCARTHY: A cache of illegal arms, including half a million rounds of bullets, was recently uncovered outside Lahore. Detained suspects told investigators of plans to attack 18 new sites.

Julie McCarthy, NPR News, Lahore. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright National Public Radio.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Latest News From WBUR
UNDERWRITING
Most Popular
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
This site is best viewed with: Firefox | Internet Explorer 9 | Chrome | Safari