NPR

Landmark Coal Mine Safety Enforcement Case Settled

Massey Energy decided to close its Freedom Mine in Kentucky after it was targeted by federal regulators for the toughest enforcement action ever. (NPR)

The Labor Department's first-ever use of its toughest enforcement tool has resulted in a court-supervised settlement with coal mine giant Massey Energy.

The agreement involves Massey's Freedom Mine #1 in Pike County, Ky., which is described in court documents as a mine so dangerous it requires court supervision. Freedom was singled out for an unprecedented federal court injunction owing to a persistent "pattern of violations" of mine safety law, which "constitutes a continuing hazard to the health or safety of miners."

Massey Energy denies "the existence of any pattern of violations" but agrees that a U.S. District Court has jurisdiction over Freedom and can apply sanctions, including contempt of court citations, if the company fails to follow a prescribed safety plan.

May 4 An MSHA inspector cites Freedom Mine for excessive coal dust again, noting the mine "has been cited over this condition 285 times in the past two years."

June 14 -- In reference to the Freedom Mine, federal coal mine safety chief Kevin Stricklin writes in an internal e-mail: "We need to use this mine as a test case for injunctive action."

Sep. 11 -- Two Freedom miners escape serious injury or death from a rockfall with debris 8 feet thick because a power outage had kept them from their work area.

Oct. 19 -- Federal inspectors cite Freedom for six safety violations, including coal dust and ventilation.

Nov. 3 --The Department of Labor files for a first-ever federal injunction against a coal mine -- Freedom Energy -- nearly five months and more than 200 federal safety violations after MSHA's Stricklin identifies the mine as a test case.

Dec. 1 -- Massey Energy decides to shut down Freedom Energy Mine #1, even though it insists it is safe.

Dec. 17 -- At a federal court hearing, U.S. District Court Judge Amul Thaper does not give Massey Energy the dismissal it sought from the Labor Department's federal injunction. (On Dec. 23, the judge formally rejects the motion to dismiss.)

Massey Energy tells NPR the company "is pleased to have resolved the matter."

"We felt the best course of action was to cooperate with MSHA and jointly develop a plan for our coal miners to safely close the Freedom Energy mine," says Shane Harvey, Massey's vice president and general counsel.  "We appreciate MSHA's input and cooperation on the plan" that is outlined in the settlement.

"I think that the settlement agreement is everything that the government could have hoped to achieve through the court action," says Ed Clair, a retired lawyer for the federal Mine Safety and Health Administration who reviewed the settlement for NPR. "It gives them incredible enforcement powers that they didn't have prior to this agreement."

Under the agreement, the mine's most senior managers must be directly involved in safety procedures and are personally responsible for violations. Miners continue to have paychecks and jobs if all or parts of the mine are shut down while safety problems are fixed. And shutdowns and fixes are immediate when unsafe conditions are spotted.

"Almost all of the provisions in this order impose requirements upon Massey that are above and beyond the normal requirements of the law," says Patricia Smith, the solicitor of the Labor Department. "We got really serious requirements that we wouldn't have had under an administrative proceeding and really nothing less than we would have asked the court for."

The settlement prevents a three-day hearing that was scheduled to begin today. The hearing was expected to include internal Massey documents and former Massey mineworkers and officials. The documents and testimony would have focused on production pressure at the company as the mine amassed hundreds of safety violations, citations and fines.

Massey has been under intense public and regulatory scrutiny since an explosion at its Upper Big Branch coal mine in West Virginia last April. Twenty-nine miners died in the blast, which is still the subject of criminal and civil investigations.

The Labor Department dusted off the never-used, 33-year-old "injunctive relief" section of federal mining law as part of the Obama administration's promised "get-tough" response to the Upper Big Branch disaster. Freedom was selected as a first test case.

When the agency filed the case in November, Massey announced it would close the mine anyway, citing ongoing challenges in operating a mine as large and old as Freedom. Federal Judge Amul Thapar refused to dismiss the case, ruling that about 60 mineworkers could still be exposed to dangerous conditions underground during the several months it would take to dismantle and remove equipment from the mine.

The settlement details safety precautions Massey must take to protect those workers. The mine is susceptible to dangerous rockfalls and explosive concentrations of methane gas. If new safety violations force closure of all or part of the mine the company must continue to pay workers, or find them other jobs within 60 miles, until the mine is considered safe.

Labor Department officials have repeatedly promised to seek federal court injunctions against other coal mines, but the agency has yet to file another case. Smith said today that several potential cases were resolved in other ways but court action is still being considered for mines she declined to name.

Mine safety advocate Wes Addington of the Appalachian Citizens Law Center says the Labor Department should continue to go to federal court. The Freedom case has "shown now that they're entitled to go into federal court and seek immediate relief for miners that are in immediate danger," Addington says. "They should use it going forward to protect miners in a more immediate way."

At the National Mining Association, spokeswoman Carol Raulston called the agreement "uncharted territory" for the mining industry. But she noted that "the court does stipulate this agreement applies only to this operation."

Still, mining companies are on notice that the Labor Department is prepared to go to court and can get into court, adds Ellen Smith, publisher of Mine Safety and Health News. "It's the big stick that MSHA is holding over mine operators, and mine operators are taking this threat extremely seriously," Smith says. "They have said that to me. They are worried about it."

That's exactly what federal mine safety officials want. Assistant Labor Secretary Joe Main says the Freedom case and settlement "surely points out our willingness to use this standard to protect miners."

Copyright 2014 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

More Photos
Transcript

MICHELE NORRIS, host:

It's ALL THINGS CONSIDERED from NPR News. I'm Michele Norris.

There's a settlement in a landmark legal case involving the Labor Department and the coal mine giant Massey Energy. The case�involves Massey's Freedom Mine number one in Pike County, Kentucky. The Labor Department considers the mine too dangerous to operate without federal court supervision and it sought a federal court injunction against the mine. But today, Massey Energy agreed to unprecedented oversight.

And our correspondent, Howard Berkes, has been following the case as part of an ongoing NPR News investigation.

HOWARD BERKES: The Freedom mine amassed hundreds of safety violations, citations and fines for dangerous rock falls, for too much explosive coal dust, for failure to conduct safety inspections. It's a long list. Massey Energy continued to claim it put safety first at Freedom and its other mines, even after an April explosion killed 29 Massey miners at the Upper Big Branch Mine in West Virginia.

That disaster prompted the Labor Department to do something it had never done before - drag a coal mine company into federal court to force attention to safety. Freedom was the test case.

Mr. ED CLAIR (Retired Lawyer, Federal Mine Safety and Health Administration): I think that the settlement agreement is everything that the government could have hoped to achieve through the court action.

BERKES: Ed Clair is a retired lawyer for the federal Mine Safety and Health Administration and he finds the settlement remarkable.

Mr. CLAIR: It gives them incredible enforcement powers that they didn't have prior to this agreement.

BERKES: That includes federal court jurisdiction over the mine with contempt citations possible if Massey Energy fails to make the mines safe. The mine's most senior managers must be directly involved in safety procedures and are personally responsible for violations. Miners continue to have paychecks and jobs if all or parts of the mine are shut down while safety problems are fixed. And shutdowns and fixes are immediate when unsafe conditions are spotted.

Patricia Smith is the solicitor of the Labor Department.

Ms. PATRICIA SMITH (Solicitor, Labor Department): Almost all of the provisions in this order impose requirements upon Massey that are above and beyond the normal requirements of the law. We got really serious requirements that we wouldn't have had under an administrative proceeding and really nothing less than we would've asked the court for.

BERKES: Massey Energy may have agreed to all that because it is already in the process of closing the mine for good. The settlement is supposed to protect the 60 or so mine workers who will spend the next several months dismantling and removing equipment.

Massey officials did not agree to be interviewed, but said in a written statement that they're pleased to have the matter resolved and felt the best course of action was to cooperate with the government. Mine safety advocates say the settlement shows that going to court works.

Wes Addington directs the Appalachian Citizens' Law Center in Whitesburg, Kentucky.

Mr. WES ADDINGTON (Director, Appalachian Citizens' Law Center): It's shown now that they're entitled to go into federal court and seek immediate relief for miners that are in immediate danger, and they should use this. They should use it going forward to protect miners in a more immediate way.

BERKES: Labor Department solicitor Smith said today more cases are possible. The settlement came just as the Freedom mine trial was set to begin. Court documents indicate Massey's production practices would've been on trial and compared with the company's persistent claims about safety. But mine safety advocates say that day is coming, given the ongoing investigations into the Upper Big Branch disaster and problematic safety records at some of Massey's other mines.

Howard Berkes, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Most Popular