NPR

Obama's Reaction To Ferguson Raises Questions About President's Role

Attorney General Eric Holder talks with Ferguson, Mo., residents Angela Whitman (left) and Jill Richards on Wednesday at Drake's Place Restaurant about issues surrounding the shooting of Michael Brown. (MCT/Landov)

Ferguson, Mo., has seen nearly two weeks of protests after an unarmed 18-year-old African-American man was shot and killed by Darren Wilson, a white police officer. This week, a black leader stepped in to help defuse tensions. But it wasn't a civil rights spokesman or the first African-American president. It was Attorney General Eric Holder.

Some political observers are asking why Obama can't seem to speak for himself on race. Many observers argue that Holder often talks frankly about race when the president can't or won't.

Speaking at a Thursday press conference, Holder said, "This has engendered a conversation that I think we ought to have, but we can't stop at that conversation."

Earlier in the week, Holder became the highest-ranking administration official to visit Ferguson. He met with Brown's parents, community leaders and regular citizens. At a local diner, he explained to residents why he came to their troubled town.

"We want to help as best we can. We also want to listen," Holder said. "That's the main part of this trip. We want to hear about issues you all are dealing with and see if there are ways in which we can help."

Many black political thinkers say President Obama himself needs help connecting on this issue and that his Monday remarks on Ferguson fell flat. They say this is the moment that he needs to be "the black president," not just a president who happens to be black.

Mary C. Curtis, a contributor to The Washington Post's "She The People" column, wants Obama to speak more personally about how law enforcement treats African-Americans.

"When he talks about black men being profiled, when he talks about a situation of unrest, he is a person who is president of the United States who has also been profiled," Curtis says.

In Ferguson, Holder shared his own stories of being profiled, explaining to young black people at a community college that he understands their uneasy relationship with police. While that event was closed to the press, in the past, an open mic hasn't stopped Holder from speaking boldly on race.

"In things racial we have always been and, I believe we continue to be, essentially, a nation of cowards," Holder said in February 2009. He offered those remarks at a Justice Department black history month event, just days after he took office.

That kind of blunt talk is what some of the president's black supporters wish Obama would try more often.

But can he?

Comedians Keegan-Michael Key and Jordan Peele built a now famous series of skits around Obama's reserve. The president is played by Peele, and Key serves as his official Anger Translator, Luther. At the heart of each piece is Luther's willingness to say what Obama won't.

Some observers suggest that Holder is Obama's real-life Luther. But also that Ferguson presents a unique challenge to the president.

Andra Gillespie, a professor of political science at Emory University, says that conflicting narratives about Brown's killing — and what happened in the streets afterward — make it tough for Obama to take a stand.

"The facts of the case have come out in a trickle," says Gillespie. "And as the facts have come out, sometimes, they have been met with a very, very tense response in Ferguson. And since the facts of the case have not been 100 percent clear, I think President Obama has been a little reticent to speak out."

Others say that's just an excuse.

"America did not vote for Eric Holder, OK? America voted for Barack Obama," says Jason Johnson, a political science professor at Ohio's Hiram College. He traveled to Ferguson to observe the protests and says having Holder appear there was good, but not enough.

"When it comes to gravitas, power and symbolism, there is no substitute for the president of the United States speaking," says Johnson.

When there were riots after the acquittal of the Los Angeles police who beat Rodney King, Johnson says, people wanted to hear from President George H.W. Bush. They wanted to hear not just about the facts but about his feelings. And they did.

"What you saw, what I saw on the TV videotape was revolting," Bush said. "I felt anger, I felt pain. I thought, 'How can I explain this to my grandchildren?' "

Johnson believes Ferguson represents a similar crisis and that some presidential anger is appropriate. And, he insists, that's not a job Obama should delegate to the attorney general.

Copyright 2014 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:

For the Obama administration, it was Attorney General Eric Holder who took center stage in Ferguson, Missouri, not the president. And the last time he weighed in was Monday. After the killing of Trayvon Martin in 2012 President Obama spoke about how he was personally touched. But critics say, he's been too quiet now in the aftermath of Michael Brown's shooting. Karen Grigsby Bates of NPR's Code Switch Team reports.

KAREN GRIGSBY BATES, BYLINE: Many observers argue that Attorney General Eric Holder often speaks frankly about race when the president can't or won't.

(SOUNDBITE OF PRESS CONFERENCE)

ERIC HOLDER: This has engendered a conversation that I think we ought to have. But we can't stop at that conversation.

BATES: That was Holder speaking at a Thursday press conference. Earlier in the week, Holder became the highest-ranking administration official to visit Ferguson. At a local diner he explained to residents why he came to their troubled town.

(SOUNDBITE OF PRESS CONFERENCE)

HOLDER: We want to listen. That's the main part of this trip. We want to listen to hear about the issues that you all are dealing with. And see are there ways in which we can help?

BATES: Many black, political thinkers say, President Obama himself needs help connecting on this issue. That his Monday remarks on Ferguson fell flat. They say, this is the moment that he needs to be the black president, not just a president who happens to be black. Mary C. Curtis is a contributor to the Washington Post's "She The People" column. She wants Obama to speak more personally about how law enforcement treats African-Americans.

MARY C. CURTIS: And when he talks about black men being profiled, he is a person who is the President of the United States who has also been profiled.

BATES: In Ferguson, Holder shared his stories of being profiled. Explaining to young, black people at a community college that he understands their uneasy relationship with the police. While that event was closed to the press, in the past and open mic hasn't stopped Holder from speaking boldly on race.

(SOUNDBITE OF PRESS CONFERENCE)

HOLDER: In things racial we have always been and we - I believe - continue to be in too many ways essentially a nation of cowards.

BATES: That was Holder in February of 2009. He offered those remarks at a Justice Department Black History Month event just days after he took office. That kind of blunt talk is what some of the President's black supporters wish Obama would try more often. But can he? Comedians Keegan-Michael Key and Jordan Peele built a now famous series of skits around Obama's reserve. With the President played by Peele and Key serving as his official anger-translator Luther.

(SOUNDBITE OF COMEDY SKETCH)

JORDAN PEELE: (As President Obama) I just want to say to my critics, I hear your voices and I'm aware of your concerns.

KEEGAN-MICHAEL KEY: (As Luther) So maybe if you could chill the hell out for, like, a second then maybe I can focus on some [bleep], you know?

PEELE: (As President Obama) That goes for everybody.

BATES: Some observers suggest that Holder is Obama's real-life Luther, but also that Ferguson presents a unique challenge to the president. Andra Gillespie is a professor of political science at Emory University. She says, the conflicting narratives about Michael Brown's killing and what happened in the streets afterward make it tough for Obama to take a stand.

ANDRA GILLESPIE: So since the facts of the case have not been 100 percent clear I think President Obama has been a little reticent to speak out.

BATES: Others say, that's just an excuse.

JASON JOHNSON: America did not vote for Eric Holder, OK? America voted for Barack Obama.

BATES: Jason Johnson is a political science professor at Ohio's Hiram College. He spoke on a cell phone from Ferguson where he traveled to observe the protests.

JOHNSON: When it comes to gravitas and power and symbolism, there is no substitute for the President of the United States speaking.

BATES: When there were riots after the acquittal of the Los Angeles police who beat Rodney King, Johnson says, people wanted to hear from President George H. W. Bush. Not just the facts, but his feelings. And they did.

(SOUNDBITE OF PRESS CONFERENCE)

PRESIDENT GEORGE H. W. BUSH: What you saw and what I saw on the TV video was revolting. I felt anger. I felt pain. I thought how can I explain this to my grandchildren?

BATES: Johnson believes Ferguson represents a similar crisis and that some presidential anger is appropriate. And, he insists, that's not a job Obama should delegate to the Attorney General. Karen Grigsby Bates, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Most Popular