Support the news

Littlefield: Revoking Medals

This article is more than 11 years old.

When is an Olympic gold medalist not an Olympic gold medalist? When it turns out that athlete has used a banned substance...or when a teammate has done so.

At least if the athletes in question are in a relay team. Unless a court of arbitration rules otherwise. Confused? WBUR'S sports commentator Bill Littlefield explains.


Kristine Lilly, the world's most durable soccer player and perhaps the most accomplished as well, once dreamed about being an Olympic gymnast. She grew out of it.

"I couldn't imagine competing in an individual sport," she said some years ago. "I use my teammates so much. I'm amazed at what the individual athletes can do. If things go wrong, they have to fix it themselves."

On the other hand, pro golfers and tennis players sometimes say they chose their sports precisely because they didn't want anybody else determining their athletic fates.

The former relay teammates of Marion Jones may be thinking more like gymnasts, tennis players and golfers than like soccer players. Jearl-Miles Clark, Monique Hennagan, LaTasha Colander-Richardson, and Andrea Anderson learned that the International Olympics Committee had voted strip them of the gold medals they received as part of the winning sixteen hundred meter relay team that included Jones, who acknowledged in October that she had used steroids during 2000 and 2001.

Jones's former teammates have hired an attorney to make their case before the Swiss-based Court of Arbitration for Sport.

Given that most people in this country only pay attention to track and field during the Olympics, the resolution of this dispute may seem inconsequential.

But if Clark, Hennagan, Colander-Richardson, and Anderson are compelled to return their medals because their teammate cheated, the theoretical implications for sports to which U.S. fans do pay attention could be interesting.

What if a baseball team including a player who tested positive for steroids, human growth hormone, or amphetamines was required to forfeit the games involving that player?

It may seem a stretch, but aren't the members of the Cardinals or the Yankees as dependent upon each other as the members of relay team who run around a track? Doesn't each group consist of teammates?

What if each time an NFL or NBA player got caught using a banned substance, the wins to which he had contributed got erased?

It won't happen, but it's kind of fun to imagine how the conversations in the locker room might go if it could.

This program aired on April 21, 2008. The audio for this program is not available.

Bill Littlefield Twitter Host, Only A Game
Bill Littlefield was the host of Only A Game from 1993 until 2018.


+Join the discussion

Support the news