Decision Day For Health Care In The House
WASHINGTON — President Barack Obama’s landmark health care overhaul moved toward a vote in the House Saturday after anti-abortion lawmakers won a chance to knock out language that would let federally subsidized health care plans cover abortions.
Democratic leaders were hopeful they could pass the bill, giving Obama his biggest victory since last November’s historic election, no matter how the abortion issue is decided. Obama planned a rare Saturday visit to Capitol Hill in an effort to cement a majority to pass legislation that is certain to be seen as a test of his presidency.
The bill would cost more than $1 trillion over the next decade. It would provide health coverage to tens of millions of Americans who don’t have it now, require most employers to offer it to their workers and prohibit insurance companies from denying coverage based on a person’s medical history.
“The status quo is unaffordable and unsustainable. Health care reform benefits all of us,” said Rep. Allyson Schwartz, D-Pa., as debate opened on the House floor.
Republicans were united in their opposition to the bill.
“The American people need to understand this is about a government takeover of the whole health care system,” said Rep. Paul Broun, R-Ga.
The most contentious issue in the 10-year, $1.2 trillion House bill is a new government-run insurance plan that would be offered alongside private coverage within new purchasing marketplaces, or “exchanges,” where individuals and small businesses could shop for and compare options.
The abortion agreement was reached at midnight Friday after hours of intense negotiations brokered by House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif. Democratic Reps. Bart Stupak of Michigan, Brad Ellsworth of Indiana and other abortion opponents fought for and won an opportunity to insert tougher restrictions into the legislation during debate, despite fervent opposition from pro-choice liberals who are a driving force behind the overall bill.
“We wish to maintain current law, which says no public funding for abortion,” Stupak said.
Federal law currently prohibits the use of federal funds to pay for abortions except in cases of rape, incest or situations in which the life of the mother is in danger. Left unresolved is whether individuals would be permitted to use their own funds to buy insurance coverage for the procedure in the federally backed insurance exchange envisioned under the legislation.
The Planned Parenthood Federation of America contended his amendment would actually go further and bar access for many women to a legal medical procedure.
“As a health care provider, Planned Parenthood would very much like to see health care reform passed,” said Cecile Richards, the group’s president. But the abortion language “would put women’s health in jeopardy and undermine real health reform,” she said.
The leadership’s hope is that no matter how the vote on the abortion measure turns out, Democrats on both sides of the abortion divide will then unite to give the health care bill a majority over unanimous Republican opposition.
With Democrats’ command of the necessary votes looking tenuous, Obama threw the weight of his administration behind the effort to round up support. He and top administration officials worked the phones to pressure wavering lawmakers.
Rep. Jason Altmire, D-Pa., said he heard from Obama, White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel, Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius and Education Secretary Arne Duncan.
Their message: “This is a historic moment. You don’t want to end up with nothing,” said Altmire, who remained undecided.
Democratic leaders hoped to hold the vote Saturday evening, but Majority Leader Steny Hoyer of Maryland said it could be delayed.
Democrats hold 258 seats in the House and can afford 40 defections and still wind up with 218, a majority if all lawmakers vote. But all 177 Republicans were expected to vote “no,” and Democratic leaders faced a series of complications trying to win the needed votes for their complex and controversial legislation that would affect one-sixth of the economy and touch the lives of countless Americans.
In the GOP’s weekly radio address, Mississippi Gov. Haley Barbour said Democrats should scrap their ambitious legislation and concentrate on modest health care changes that could find bipartisan support.
“The House Democrats’ health care bill should be withdrawn and reworked,” he said.
Last Tuesday’s elections – in which Democrats lost two governors’ races – sent a message that voters care about jobs, not growing the size of government, Barbour said.
- Beacon Hill »
- Mass. House Orders Staff, Not Member, Furloughs
- Mass. Artists, Lawmakers Meet To Discuss Creative Economy
- Patrick Rebuffed In Request For Education Bill Action
- Commentary »
- Soccer Championship Has Star Power On Its Side
- At 45, Caught Between Mammograms
- The Everlasting Allure Of The World Series
- Crime & Justice »
- 5th Arrest Announced In Mont Vernon Case
- Attorney: Mehanna Arrested After Refusing To Be FBI Informant
- Review: Police Not Responsible For Celtic Fan’s Death
- Energy »
- Evergreen To China Shows It’s Not So Easy To Be Green In Mass.
- Mass. Commission Ruling Means Delay For Cape Wind
- Harvard To Buy Power From Maine Wind Farm
- Environment »
- Evergreen To China Shows It’s Not So Easy To Be Green In Mass.
- Senate Democrats Advance Climate Bill Without GOP
- Harvard To Buy Power From Maine Wind Farm
- Ethics »
- DiMasi, Co-Defendants Plead Not Guilty To Corruption
- Former Speaker DiMasi To Also Face Extortion Charge
- Amid Confusion, State Lawmakers Postpone Tougher Lobbying Law
- Religion »
- Jesuit Educator Thomas O’Malley Dies In Boston
- Vatican Creates New Structure For Anglicans
- Remembering A Different Boston, 30 Years After Pope’s Historic Visit
- Sprint To The Senate »
- Friday Morning Roundup
- Pagliuca Tries To Capitalize On Apparent Health Care Rift
- Pagliuca Tries To Set Himself Apart On Health Care
- H1N1 Swine Flu »
- FAQ: Swine Flu Facts And Figures
- Flu Now At Historic High in Mass.
- ‘Free Shevaun’: The Challenges Of Controlling Swine Flu On College Campuses
- Flu Now At Historic High in Mass.
- Picking Locks For Sport, Not Sabotage
- FAQ: Swine Flu Facts And Figures
- Sen. Kerry’s Daughter Arrested On DUI Charge
- Boston Unveils Five-Year School Restructuring Plan
- Boston Man Dies From Swine Flu
- Mass. Unemployment Fund Running Out Of Money
- Does Boston Have Room For More Ice Cream?
- Study: No Cost Savings With Electronic Medical Records
- Boston Unveils School Restructuring Plan
- Study: No Cost Savings With Electronic Medical Records
- Flu Now At Historic High in Mass.
- Mass. Unemployment Fund Running Out Of Money
- Picking Locks For Sport, Not Sabotage
- Joshua Kosman, Predicting The Next Credit Crisis
- Sounds During Sleep May Help You Remember
- Boston Unveils Five-Year School Restructuring Plan
- Go Pink: Stamberg And Reichl Make Cranberry Relish
- Boston Unveils School Restructuring Plan
- Does Boston Have Room For More Ice Cream?
- At 45, Caught Between Mammograms
- Picking Locks For Sport, Not Sabotage
- Exclusive First Listen: Norah Jones
- 'The Onion': Mocking All Who Deserve It Since 1988
- Boston Unveils Five-Year School Restructuring Plan
- Joshua Kosman, Predicting The Next Credit Crisis
- Sacha Baron Cohen And Larry Charles Talk 'Bruno'
- FAQ: Swine Flu Facts And Figures
- Mass. Unemployment Fund Running Out Of Money
- A Son's Premonition, And A Final Baseball Game
- @NoOneYouKnow I wanted to hear that NPR mashup but was stuck in the next room! Do you know where I could find it? @nprscottsimon @wbur
- @nprscottsimon loved hearing your kids this morning, but that darn "NPR" mashup song is stuck in my brain! Cc: @wbur @kengeorge
- @WGBHLab Thanks. How about tweetUp @wgbh2boston? I'd help like did @wbur w @kengeorge. Cc: @frankdasilva @flickthistv @totalfilm @videostah
- at @wbur benefit screening of "yes men" at mahawie in GB; another #berkshires evening of awesome (no jokes this is cool)
-
Belmont World Film Family Festival
November 21, 2009
At Belmont Studio Cinema -
Boston Ballet at the Faneuil Hall Tree Lighting
November 21, 2009
At Faneuil Hall Marketplace -
Racing to the Top: Modern Leadership and the question of character-President Obama and leadership in the context of contemporary race relations.
November 21, 2009
At Boston University-George Sherman Union -
Esperanza Rising
November 21, 2009
At Cutler Majestic Theatre






Democrats who defect on this version are selling out to special interests (Planned Parenthood and others who want political clout out of this). Whatever passes now will have to be further changed in subsequent reconciliations in Congress, and get an Obama signature. If this bill doesn’t pass now, the risk is great there will be no momentum and no bill this year or in the foreseeable future. Those who support abortion rights will not be served in any way by such failure of Democrats worried about their political support. If they don’t pass legislation this year, they should all be voted out of office by people who will. The Republicans won’t be to blame if the Democrats don’t support their own bill.