Following Coakley, Capuano Shifts On Health Care And Abortion

Massachusetts Attorney General Martha Coakley faces reporters in Worcester after Coakley said she would have voted against a major health care reform bill because it contained an anti-abortion amendment. (AP)
BOSTON — There’s a new twist in the tussle over health care and abortion between two of the candidates vying to succeed the late Sen. Edward M. Kennedy.
Congressman Mike Capuano, who voted in favor of the health care bill that passed the House on Saturday, now says he’d reject it in the Senate. That’s if the measure still bans using government funds for any health plan that covers abortions.
Capuano said this Tuesday, a day after criticizing Attorney General Martha Coakley for saying she’d have voted against the legislation because of the anti-abortion provision.
At first, it was Coakley who raised questions about her political savvy. She announced that she would have voted against the health care bill in the House. The bill prohibits using government money for any health care plan that funds abortions.
But then Mike Capuano made a surprise announcement. We asked him: Would he vote to kill health care reform if, in the end, it still contains the anti-abortion language?
“The answer is yes,” Capuano said, “but that’s a false and naive question, because the vote we had on Saturday night was to keep the health care debate alive and to move it to the Senate so that we can work to improve the bill over there as well.”
Coakley welcomed Capuano’s announcement that he would oppose health care reform if it prohibits abortions. “I believe that that’s the right result,” Coakley said, “and I would commend Mike for understanding that he should do that.”
“I’m not adopting her position,” Capuano said. “She said she would have voted no on Saturday, which would have ended the debate. If that’s her position, I wouldn’t even come close to adopting that.”
There’s clearly a difference in approach between the two candidates. Coakley said she could not — like Capuano– vote for something she opposes just to keep the process going.
“I think it’s always very difficult to go through a process and vote for things that you don’t really believe in with the hope or expectation that you’ll be able to change it or clean it up later,” Coakley said. “Sometimes that happens. Sometimes that doesn’t, but that’s if what he did, then that’s fine.”
“I was asked what I would have done,” she said. “I said I would have voted against, because I didn’t think that this choice was either necessary or fair and I didn’t think you had to sacrifice rights. He’s the one who attacked me for saying I didn’t understand the process.”
“The statements by Martha Coakley and now Mike Capuano have made signaling potential opposition to this health care reform legislation,” said venture capitalist Stephen Pagliuca, another Democrat running for the Senate. “It’s alarming.”
Pagliuca said he would vote for the health care bill even if it contains the anti-abortion measure. “Sen. Kennedy, as you know, fought 40 years to get this happen,” Pagliuca said, “and two candidates for his seat now are risking the greatest opportunity we’ve had to make fundamental change in health care.”
But Capuano disagrees. He predicts that the anti-abortion language will die before the legislation makes it through Congress. “I do not think that it will survive,” Capuano said. “I do not think that it’ll get through the Senate, and part of our job is to try to make sure that it doesn’t.”
Coakley doesn’t believe the anti-abortion language will survive either.
The fourth candidate in the Democratic primary race for the U.S. Senate is City Year founder Alan Khazei. He has said that he would vote for the health care legislation passed by the House. He was unable to get back to us in time for our deadline for this story.
- Beacon Hill »
- Mayor Controversy Throws Lawrence Bailout Into Jeopardy
- DeLeo Bets On The Colts And Re-Election
- Casino Supporters, Opponents Make Their Case On Beacon Hill
- Commentary »
- Advocacy Is In The Eye Of The Beholder
- The Richest Girls Basketball Coach In The World
- McGwire’s Record Breaking Tarnished? Sounds Like A Broken Record
- Crime & Justice »
- Mass. Court: Sexual E-Messages To Minors Legal
- Shot Street Worker Gets His Day At City Hall
- Boston Archdiocese Releases More Information On Abusive Priests
- Energy »
- As Battle Nears End, Cape Wind Still Divides
- The Art Of Going Green In The Museum
- Salazar Meets With Mashpee Wampanoag Over Cape Wind Concerns
- Environment »
- As Battle Nears End, Cape Wind Still Divides
- Invasive Plants Spreading As Climate Warms, Study Says
- The Art Of Going Green In The Museum
- Ethics »
- Galluccio Resigns From Senate After Being Jailed
- After Sentencing, Fate Of Galluccio’s Senate Seat Remains Unknown
- DiMasi, Co-Defendants Plead Not Guilty To Corruption
- Religion »
- Brown, And His Church, Don’t Wear Religion On The Sleeve
- Boston Archdiocese Releases More Information On Abusive Priests
- Archdiocese: Abusive Priests With Ireland Ties Worked In Boston
- Sprint To The Senate »
- How He Did It: Behind The Scott Brown Win
- Scott Brown, The New Hero Of The GOP
- Tea Party Credited With Giving Brown A Winning Boost
- H1N1 Swine Flu »
- FAQ: Swine Flu Vaccine Availability
- Mass. Lifts Swine Flu Vaccine Restrictions
- Study: Swine Flu Is Relatively Mild Virus After All
WBUR journalists present up-to-the-minute news, feature reports and analysis about the accelerated race to succeed the late Sen. Edward M. Kennedy, who served Massachusetts for 47 years.
- @EmilyMillerDC I think my entire appeal is the lack of #hotpants, frankly. Not sure what the exit polls said about that though. #masen
- RT @EricCantor: Congratulations to Senator-Elect @ScottBrownMA !!! #masen #tcot
- @andrewbreitbart Looking forward to having a look. Love your exposés. No, that's not a double entendre. #masen
- @mkhammer But, according to Obama, maybe that Haitian doesn't need that new hip. We need to control costs, *after all*. #masen
- Tea Party Activists Unite In Nashville To Protest Obama Leadership
- Why Does Time Fly By As You Get Older?
- Cyclists Race Through A ‘Canyon Of Beer’
- Teen Suicide Sheds Light On New Era Of Bullying
- The ‘Car Talk’ Spin On Toyota Recalls
- Brown’s Staff Shapes Up As Coalition Of The Eager
- Teacher Suspended After Party Photos Posted Online
- We Know Better, But We Text While Driving Anyway
- 'How's That Hopey, Changey Stuff?' Palin Asks
- Brown, And His Church, Don’t Wear Religion On The Sleeve
- Cyclists Race Through A ‘Canyon Of Beer’
- Teen Suicide Sheds Light On New Era Of Bullying
- We Know Better, But We Text While Driving Anyway
- Mass. Requests Federal Credit To Cover Unemployment Benefits
- Why Does Time Fly By As You Get Older?
- The ‘Car Talk’ Spin On Toyota Recalls
- Math Professor Helps Uncover Art Fakes
- DeLeo Bets On The Colts And Re-Election
- Teacher Suspended After Party Photos Posted Online
- Where You Live, Not Just Lifestyle, May Contribute To Diabetes
- WBUR Changes Weekend Program Lineup (90)
- Share Your Voting Experiences Today (84)
- Edward Kennedy, The Senate's Last Lion, Is Dead At 77 (64)
- Dems Question Why Brown Is Gaining On Coakley (64)
- Seeking Your Ideas For WBUR iPhone App (46)
- Brown Hits Back After Negative Coakley Ad (46)
- Obama Accepts Nobel Peace Prize As 'Call To Action' (45)
- Hollywood East's Less-Than Red Carpet Arrival (45)
- 'Absolutely' Wrong To Call Coakley-Brown Race A Statistical Tie (43)
- Blogging The U.S. Senate Debate (39)
- Tea Party Activists Unite In Nashville To Protest Obama Leadership
- Why Does Time Fly By As You Get Older?
- 'How's That Hopey, Changey Stuff?' Palin Asks
- Brautigan's Surreal Story: 'Trout Fishing In America'
- As Battle Nears End, Cape Wind Still Divides
- Teen Suicide Sheds Light On New Era Of Bullying
- We Know Better, But We Text While Driving Anyway
- Haitian Orphans' Fate In Limbo Amid Post-Disaster Confusion
- Teacher Suspended After Party Photos Posted Online
- Cyclists Race Through A ‘Canyon Of Beer’







We need universal health care, and it is my hope that legislation will include women’s rights to whatever care they need, including abortion. At long last insurance will no longer exclude people for “prior conditions”, so there is no rationale for limiting women’s rights to the services they need as their ‘prior condition’ is being female, which should be respected. Any other approach is punitive, prejudicial, and immoral, and no health bill should be enacted that limits women, with implied judgement against their sexual behavior. Please note pregnancy does require a male’s participation; it takes two. Abortion restrictions punish only one party: the woman.
[...] the political world is trying to understand why Capuano seems to have suddenly changed his mind about a key abortion provision of the bill known as the Stupak [...]
[...] For more information, also see a good article on WBUR. [...]
[...] Monday, he sharply criticized one of his opponents, Attorney General Martha Coakley, for saying she would not have voted for the bill if it had the same restrictions. Just one day later, Capuano said that if the abortion provision makes it into the final bill, he would vote it down. [...]