Listen LIVE button

WBURStudy: Uninsured Trauma Victims More Likely To Die Of Injuries

Published November 16, 2009  Updated November 17

BOSTON — A new Harvard study (PDF) finds that people admitted to the hospital for trauma are more likely to die from their injuries if they don’t have health insurance than if they do.

The researchers analyzed medical data for almost 700,000 adults nationwide who’d been hospitalized with traumatic injuries. Overall, people without health insurance were 25 percent more likely to die from their trauma than those who do have coverage.

There could be a range of reasons for this disparity, said study co-author Heather Rosen, a research fellow at Harvard Medical School and Children’s Hospital Boston.

For example, if doctors know they’re treating someone without insurance, there might be subtle differences in how they care for that patient, such as doing fewer tests or less follow-up.

But many hospitals don’t know who’s insured and who isn’t when a patient arrives at an emergency room after, say, a car crash.

In those cases, uninsured patients could be faring differently because they’ve gone to a hospital that has fewer resources and, as a result, provides subpar care.

Or some patients without insurance might be delaying treatment for traumatic injuries such as fractures, which could increase their risk of death.

They might also have a lower rate of so-called health literacy, meaning that they may not explain their symptoms clearly to doctors, which can lead to inadequate care.

According to the study, which appears in the journal Archives of Surgery, the higher mortality rate among uninsured trauma victims results in an additional 18,000 deaths per year.

WBUR Topics: Boston   Health & Science   Health Care  
Your Comments
Comments RSS
  • Abb, Jason, the study clearly notes that critical care personnel don’t know an unstable ER patient’s insurance status. Can you read? And don’t tell me clinicians are unaware of insurance status after triage and stabilization — when I went to the ER (for chest pains) after being seen and admitted my insurance information was printed on my wrist band.

    Posted by Dave on November 21, 2009, at 10:10 PM
  • [...] likely to die from their injuries if they don’t have health insurance than if they do. In this WBUR report, Rosen offers some possible explanations for the alarming [...]

    Posted by Uninsured trauma victims more likely to die of their injuries on November 17, 2009, at 1:38 PM
  • Has this researcher ever heard of EMTALA? It is against federal law to even ask for insurance information in an ED prior to triaging and stabilizing the patient.

    Posted by abb on November 17, 2009, at 12:33 PM
  • Irresponsible to imply that clinicians know who has insurance and who does not. We never know this information. Another piece of irresponsible reporting put out there for the uninformed public to fool them into supporting socialized medicine. You should be ashamed of yourselves.

    Posted by Jason, RN on November 17, 2009, at 11:28 AM
  • oh like this is a big surprise? Funny how they refer to car crash victims and not the gang related gunshots, overdoses, and fights. Not to worry, all the prisoners get all the care they need at our expense though.

    Posted by Tom on November 16, 2009, at 4:05 PM
Have something to say?
Please stay on topic, be civil, and be brief. These comments are moderated by WBUR, but you are solely responsible for the content of your comments. By commenting, you agree to our Community Discussion Rules.

WBUR Topics
Most Popular
This site is best viewed with: Firefox 3.5 | Explorer 8 | Chrome 2 | Safari 4 | Weather provided by Yahoo!