WBURHaitian Earthquake Victims Struggle To Survive In Greater Boston

Marie Honore Milice and her children are homeless after coming to the Boston area following Haiti’s devastating Jan. 12 earthquake. The family is staying at a hotel in Woburn. (Bianca Vazquez Toness/WBUR)

WOBURN, Mass. — Most people affected by Haiti’s January earthquake aren’t eligible to come to the United States. But one group — Haitian mothers with small children here on short-term tourist visas — has managed to come to Boston, making social service providers worried.


Alide Honore stands knee high and wears her hair in little puff balls sprouting from her head.

The two-year-old follows her somewhat anxious mother around the room, gazing up at her with big brown eyes. This baby seems helpless, but she holds a powerful trump card — an American passport.

“The American Embassy called looking for her,” says Marie Honore, 37, in Haitian Creole.

The U.S. Marines offered to transport Alide to the United States. It was just days after the earthquake, and very difficult to leave Haiti. Problem was, little Alide can barely walk, much less travel alone. So, according to Honore, U.S. officials offered her a six-month tourist visa to accompany her daughter. But she had to leave her Haitian-born son behind.

Once in Boston, the family stayed at a friend’s house, where mother and baby slept on cardboard lining the floor.

“I was afraid that my child would get sick because of the condition in which I was living,” Honore says.

That friend eventually asked them to leave, saying it was just too uncomfortable cramming so many people in the apartment. So, Marie and her baby hopped around homeless shelters, until they were moved to a Holiday Inn in Woburn.

Alide, left, and Florel Honore (Bianca Vazquez Toness/WBUR)

Here, homeless women with babies share a meeting room strewn with toys. Alide sits quietly on a couch while a woman on the other side of the room yells at her son, “Be quiet! Fix your face! Fix your face!”

The Massachusetts Department of Housing and Community Development is paying for the Honores to stay here. And it’s just in time.

Florel, Honore’s Haitian-born son, joined her last week. The seven-year-old boy entered with a pre-existing tourist visa, accompanied by a family friend, traveling through the Dominican Republic.

Honore has no money or authorization to work. Her only income is $200 in food stamps and $239 in cash assistance each month. That’s all thanks to her American-born daughter.

Even though she’s broke, Honore says this is still better than being in Haiti.

“Everything that I had was destroyed, and I still do not know if my husband is alive,” Honore says.

So far, social service agencies have counted more than 100 adults in Boston like Honore. Marjean Perhot heads immigrant and refugee services for Catholic Charities of the Archdiocese of Boston. Perhot says most are women with very young children, and they are staying with family. She worries about the strain this will put on their hosts, since these visitors can’t pay rent.

Roseline St. Pierre knows what that’s like. She and her American-born daughter are staying with St. Pierre’s brother — seven people in a three-bedroom apartment. St. Pierre complains about the cold, and wears a down coat even when she’s inside. Before the earthquake, she ran a small grocery store in Port-au-Prince. Now she spends her days in Cambridge doing nothing.

“Back in Haiti, I was an empowered woman. But now I have to rely on other people,” St. Pierre says.

As frustrated as she is, St. Pierre says she’s hoping to renew her visa when it expires in July.

That worries Mark Krikorian. He runs the Center for Immigration Studies, a Washington think-tank that favors stricter controls on immigration.

“There’s no reason that these women can be given or should be given permanent long-term status just because they had a kid here,” Krikorian says. “That really does create a powerful incentive to sneak into the United State or lie in a visa interview.”

But Marie Honore and Roseline St. Pierre say they don’t want to stay here permanently, just until it’s safe to go back home.

Now that commercial flights are flying to Haiti again, state officials say they expect more desperate women and children will be on their way here and needing help.

WBUR Topics · Boston
Please follow our community rules when engaging in comment discussion on wbur.org.
  • Kristina Campbell

    We would love to help this family in some way. We don’t have a lot of money or a home for them but perhaps we could gather things they need?

  • Peter Petraitis

    You can’t adopt the world! She needs to go back to her country and help them rebuild. Haiti was a huge mess before the quake. The people have allowed dictatorships and abuse for centuries. There is something very wrong with that place.

  • Doreen Walsh

    I agree with Peter, although it is devastating, she needs to go back and help build her own country. Our country and citizens have our own problems to solve. Why aren’t the americans living in shelters featured in the news? Maybe it is because there are too many to mention. Help NEEDS to go to Americans, then once they are helped, we can help other countries.

  • jemimah

    It would maybe do Doreen some good to hear what “real” Americans said about her ancestors who came here trying to escape the Potato Famine, or for Peter to remember what a mess Lithunia was–and in some ways still is–under Soviet rule. Ah, the wonders of perspective!

  • Jodi Hopkins

    thank you for this wonderful story. it’s nice to be able to follow the plight of these families in need and not forget them. It will take Haiti a long time to build, and one can’t rebuild without having a solid foundation first. Perhaps this will give her the chance to do that. I agree with Kristina. Let’s spread our wings.

  • Laurie Winters

    Is it possible for the Diocese to set up a fund to support these families while they are here, with money for food, clothing, school supplies and toys for the kids? Or for any of the other organizations involved to publicize the need for help for these folks? We are willing to contribute, and I know others would feel similarly.

  • Stephanie

    To Peter and Doreen – You both cleary do not know the history of Haiti. Most importantly, you both REALLY do not know the history between the US (France) and Haiti. read and learn a little before making cruel and idiotic comments.

  • katrina monsees

    I’m with Kristina, is there a way to contact this family and the others at the holiday inn in woburn, to find out what they may need?

  • Peter Petraitis

    I see you all watch a lot of Oprah.

  • Barbara Teittinen

    I agree with Stephanie. Read more about the history of Haiti and how the people of Haiti have lived under different dictators and suffered. They have not ALLOWED this to happen, they are the victims and are powerless under such conditions. Probably the poorest country in the world, no infrastructure, education, medical care except for PIH and a few other organizations. If Catholic Charities or another organization would be willing to help with these refugees I would offer my own help in any way I can. Now the world is aware of the plight of Haitians when Paul Farmer and Partners in Health were always there trying to get out the word that Haiti needs
    our help.

  • K Smith

    It’s sad that Haiti is in such trouble but the US doesn’t need to import more poverty. It would be much cheaper to support these unfortunates in their own country or in the Dominican Republic. The VOLAGs who do resettlement of refugees, like Catholic Charities, are paid MORE to resettle people in the US instead of their home region. This is exactly what’s happening here. People are brought to the US and then dumped here, regardless of whether the local population are willing or whether jobs are available. Do you think that Lewiston, ME was asked about the Somali refugees? The whole immigration/asylum/refugee Industry is just as large as the Welfare State and relies heavily on taxpayer monies. The US has 15 million AMERICANS unemployed, many who are homeless themselves. Where is your charity for them?

  • scrambled-eggs

    The willingness of the people on this page to reach out is commendable, and I am not knocking it. I know many of you will view my opinion as cold and heartless, but….

    I heard the piece on the radio. Could you do a follow up with a different fundamental perspective ? How is it these mother’s, who are not U.S. citizens, can come to the US and have their babies, thereby conferring citizenship upon their offspring? Are the fathers all US citizens? If not, how does this happen? As a MA taxpayer, why am I obligated to pay towards the welfare of these mothers, keeping them here on visitor visas?

    Things are tough here in MA. Look at Lawrence, Fall River, unemployment on Cape Cod exceeds 30%. The time of Emma Lazarus ‘ “Give me your tired, your poor…” is surely behind us.

  • http://n/a Anonymous Conservative

    I just would like to clarify that Mark Krikorian sounded like he made an incorrect comment and I would like it retracted on the air if this is the case. He said something to the point that Haitian women who have child born here (i.e. US citizen children) gives these women an “automatic right to citizenship”. I dont believe that’s correct. Based on my sources, the US still will deport undocument parents regardless if they have children that are US citizens. I think comments like these (especially from people who are portrayed as authoirities on the subject) cause Americans to be prejudice against immigrants.

  • XXXXXXX

    It should be clarified, in response to the statement by the restrictionist CIS, that having a US citizen child confers no immigration benefits on an undocumented parent at all. A child cannot petition for his or her parent until the child turns 21. This means that there is no incentive to “sneak across the border to have babies,” as the CIS would dramatically suggest.

    That the US sought to protect its citizen children in Haiti is both surprising and heartening. That they would renew a temporary visa for this mother to stay with her child until Haiti is safe to return to is just common sense, like the granting of TPS to Haitians for what is, by definition, a temporary period of time.

    I’m disappointed that NPR would a story quoting only one side of the immigration debate. If you’re going to quote CIS, you should at least present an expert from the other side, too.

  • http://Mineralareacollege.com Brooke

    I wanted to let you know were all praying for you, all I can say is your in gods hands now

  • Pamela Browne

    Clearly this wasn’t a temporary visa, it is May 2011 and she is still here in this country…driving on a MA drivers license.

More stories in 'Boston'
UNDERWRITING
Most Popular
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
This site is best viewed with: Firefox | Internet Explorer 9 | Chrome | Safari