WBURBoston Pops’ Keith Lockhart Conducts July Fourth Concert For 17th Year

Keith Lockhart conducts the Boston Pops July Fourth concert rehearsal at the Hatch Shell on the Esplanade in Boston on Sunday. (AP)

Keith Lockhart conducts the Boston Pops July Fourth concert rehearsal at the Hatch Shell on the Esplanade in Boston on Sunday. (AP)

BOSTON — Since the pre-dawn hours thousands have been gathering at the Charles River Esplanade for Monday’s Fourth of July Boston Pops Fireworks Spectacular, Boston’s traditional way of celebrating Independence Day.

Debbie Shinker, from Stowe, Ohio, was among the first in line, making sure she and her family will get a spot up front.

“There is no better place to be on the Fourth,” Shinker said. “The spirit of the city and the history just literally seeping out of the ground here is like none other.”

A military color guard stands ready for the playing of the National Anthem during the Boston Pops July Fourth concert rehearsal on Sunday. (AP)

A military color guard stands ready for the playing of the National Anthem during the Boston Pops July Fourth concert rehearsal on Sunday. (AP)

Monday’s concert gets underway at 8:30 p.m. and features country singer Martina McBride, who stepped in at the last minute when headliner Lionel Richie backed out because of strained vocal chords.

For the 17th year, Boston Pops conductor Keith Lockhart will be wielding the baton at the Hatch Shell. I caught up with him Monday morning on the very stage where the Pops will be performing before a national TV audience of millions.

I asked him what goes through his mind when he steps on the stage for the show to begin.

Keith Lockhart: I still remember the very first one, and walking out here, and seeing this immense sea of people and knowing there were so many people there to be part of this event who were far beyond what I could see. And it kind of gave me an idea of the impact of the Boston Pops all in a heartbeat. It’s kind of an amazing feeling and it makes you, of course, as a performer, want to do something really great for them.

Steve Brown: When you get up here, does anything out in the crowd catch your eye?

Well, people try really hard to catch your eye, you know, and that sort of thing. Yes, but you know you really can’t let your focus get drawn by that. You’re not here really performing just for the one guy in the big Uncle Sam hat. You’re performing for all the people beyond them, and some people always ask, they say, “What’s it like to perform for a half-million people?” and I say it’s sort of like performing for 50,000 people, because you can’t see past the first 50,000 people.

What goes into putting together a show like the one you’ll be putting on tonight?

Well, lots of logistics, I mean immense hours of logistics, thousands of man hours of work, a lot of which is of course is not our department, which is good, we’re responsible for the concert. We start planning the process right on July 5 — we’ll be thinking about what’s going to be happening differently next year. But even as you know this year, with the cancellation 48 hours before of our headline artist, all the planning in the world doesn’t solve those things. And we have a lot of talented people who work really fast to make sure that we have a great concert by the time these people rush onto the Esplanade.

You mention the last-minute change, 48 hours before. What does that do to you, and to the orchestra? You have to change gears in a hurry?

Well, the biggest thing, actually is music preparation, with the orchestra. We don’t actually rehearse with the artist until July 3 anyway. But to find out on July 1 meant that we had to create new orchestral arrangements for Martina McBride’s material because she didn’t have them. They were just for her and her band. And people don’t really think about that, they think, “Well, the orchestra just gets there and plays a song.” No, somebody has to write a score out that shows what every instrument is playing, and make something that’s cogent and works with the artist. Fortunately we have a great stable of arrangers who work for us, and we farmed it out, one per person so they’d have time to get it done. And these days, in the miracle of electronic file sharing, and things like that, all that stuff ends up being transmitted electronically back to our library who hastily throws music on stands.

We’re standing on, I guess, hallowed ground here. This is the Hatch Shell, for many years now, this is the 38th year there has been a Fourth of July Pops concert. How is this as an outdoor venue for you?

Well, I think it’s a great venue mostly because of its location, what it means and the history here. And of course, the 38 years of Fourth of July concerts, but a history of free concerts for the people of Boston with the Boston Pops that dates back to 1929. July Fourth used to just be an off day in that process. And it’s kind of a difficult space to do TV in, because it wasn’t invented for that purpose. That having been said, I don’t think it would never mean the same. I remember a few years ago, they were talking about closing down this area because of work on Storrow Drive, and we were talking about alternative venues and none of them made any sense because people wanted to be here on the Fourth.

Let’s talk about tonight’s show. What can folks expect?

Well, Martina McBride, of course, who has joined us hastily and sounds wonderful, looks amazing. And really, if last night’s [dress rehearsal] is any indication, people are in for a treat. The U.S. Army Field Band and Soldier’s Chorus, the musical ambassadors of the army are joining us for a lot of our patriotic moments in the concert. Broadway vocalist Norm Lewis, who will be starring at the A.R.T.’s production of “Porgy and Bess” this fall, will be joining us to sing a song. We have a new emcee, Michael Chiklis. The first time I’m told that a local boy has ever come back to be master of ceremonies for this. He’s from Lowell, and went to Boston University and of course has gone on to big things on Broadway and on television and in the movies. He’s a great guy, and on top of that, I think he’s the first singing emcee we’ve ever had, he actually will be performing with the orchestra.

He’s not known for singing?

No, but he was trained that way, actually. He was trained and did a lot of music theater when he was at BU. And he’s a very talented, crossover kind of guy, but people who know him from his role on “The Shield” will find it hard to see him bursting into song, I suppose.

I know in theater, you don’t wish anybody “good luck,” and I don’t want to wish you to “break a leg,” so have fun.

Thanks, we’ll do that. Happy Fourth.

WBUR Topics · Arts & Culture · Boston
Please follow our community rules when engaging in comment discussion on wbur.org.
  • Sjomjo

    I always looked forward to watching the Boston Pops on A&E on the 4th of July, especially the 1812 Overture. Now it is nothing but a commercial piece of junk on CBS. All it is is the “stars” of the show and the fireworks. I can see fireworks in a dozen cities where I live. I want the Pops back on a station where I can see the whole show. They have the Capital 4th on PBS, what about the Pops!

    • Sherrillfitzpatric

      I agree. The 1812 overture is missed as part of 4th of July program. The program that the Boston Pops presents now is boring. Arthur Fiedler must be turning in his grave.

      An Old Fashioned Fan

      • ChandlerDonna

        Agree with both of you… so disappointed…  it was a cheap version of the Macy’s New York show… and it always used to be so special with the Boston Pops as the centerpiece.   

  • Wlandon

    Here we are watching the celebration–the patriotic music, the honoring of our troops…then the beautiful fireworks began  and we were left waiting for the accompanying patriotic music, for the 1812 Overture…what a disappointment.  I will probably watch something else next year.

  • pmh

    The Boston Pops show had to be ammended due to the last notice of Lionel Ritchey had to pull out because of his vocals. The planning had to be scraped on July 1st and do the best for Martina McBride. Everything went well however not the best of the Boston Pops like in the past. The firreworks are the BEST! Missed the 1812 Overture though

    • 16FelinePaws

      Wrong – only his part had to be altered – not the whole program.

  • Jeannine McMahel

    Does anyone know who the recording of the National Anthem at the end was sung by?

    • KSM

      Sandi Patty, according to the website for the show

    • http://www.thestreet.com Jason Notte

      Unfortunately, it was Sandi Patty.

      • Sweetie Py

        Why “unfortunately”?   She is a great singer and did a fantastic job with that song! 

        • http://www.thestreet.com Jason Notte

          Completely disagree. Marvin Gaye did a fantastic job with that song. Rene Rancourt does a fantastic job with that song. Francis Scott Key did a fantastic job writing that song. Sandi Patty did something with that song, but “fantastic job” wouldn’t be the words I’d use to describe it.

      • Yadayadabain

        Get out of the bitter barn and play in the hay! Scroll thru these comments–u are definitely in the minority about Sandi Patty’s performance…

        • http://www.thestreet.com Jason Notte

          If that’s what the majority’s into, I’m perfectly comfortable right here in the minority where people aren’t trying to sell me “Hymns of Faith, Songs of Inspiration” downloads. I’m glad Keith Lockhart and the Pops were able to shine through as always despite the clouds of dreck CBS routinely puts around them. No worthwhile headliner since Neil Diamond, no decent anthem singer in this place since James Taylor at Fenway in ’04 and no great “patriotic music” here since Donna Summer followed up James with “God Bless America” that same night.

          • Will

            Dude, you’re funny! I wasn’t try to sell YOU or ANYONE  anything. I am a school teacher in NYC–I have nothing to gain by iTune purchases–I wish I did!   I was simply telling people where there could get it her version if they were so inclined.  You are right, a lot of people have sung great versions of the song.  I love Hendrix and U2′s versions as well as Sandi’s–that’s what makes the world go around! As far as you being hung up on doing Francis Scott Key’s version–there are 3 other verses…so NOBODY is doing his version as it was written if you are gonna get technical about it.  Her added verse was written especially for the re-dedication of the Statute of Liberty in 1986.

      • Jimandemma

        I think you have made your point, “““take a hike
        Jim F

        • http://www.thestreet.com Jason Notte

          I’d rather Sandi did.

          • Mike S.

            Wow Jason, you are a really pleasant person.  I bet you have a ton of friends!  Seriously, the lady sang what many consider to be a great rendition of the song.  Sandi has a very large following and a career that spans over 20 years.  I can appreciate that you don’t like her voice – where there is an audience that appreciates multiple modulations and climatic endings there is also an audience that it annoys.  Clearly you were annoyed.  That said – Sandi has not done anything to you personally and I don’t understand why you feel the need to respond negatively to every post about Sandi.  Rather odd. 

          • http://www.thestreet.com Jason Notte

            I responded to one person with the sentence “unfortunately, it was Sandy Patti.” The members of the Sandi Patty fan club then questioned that reaction and suggested I go screw myself. I declined and expanded on my opinion. I didn’t go looking for a fight, it came to me. That said, I think there’s been some confusion among the commenters: The Sandi Patty fan club page is over here http://www.facebook.com/group.php?v=wall&gid=2209483822 . This is a WBUR page about an event that happened almost three days ago and that is open to opinions other that those voiced by people who prostrate themselves at the feet of a bad anthem singer.

          • classically-trained

            Could you please tell us your credentials to qualify this singer as a ‘bad’ anthem singer? Other than your ears? If that were all, then clearly the majority here would win, thus classifying her as a ‘good’ anthem singer. Perhaps, however, you have more experience that you could share? I am a trained classical vocalist who has performed at Carnegie…I’m not giving an opinion on this…yet. I just want to see how people come up with their opinions…

          • http://www.thestreet.com Jason Notte

            Isn’t that the measure of quality in a consumer marketplace: The consumer’s taste? Chuck Klosterman once argued that since a greater majority of Americans purchased Mariah Carey’s music over Bob Dylan’s, Carey is the superior artist. The listener’s ear is the most important variable in the individual assessment of “bad” vs. “good.” Some listeners find Yo Yo Ma to be a standard of excellence while dismissing Stevie Wonder’s value as a musician altogether. Others find Lang Lang an interminable bore and would rather listen to an old Richard Hell album.

            To either group, your classical training and performance at Carnegie are little other than resume items. They do not establish your worth as a vocalist as a universal truth, nor do they necessarily mean that fans of Edith Piaf, Rufus Wainwright or even the Beatles would find your work particularly pleasant.

            In the case of the anthem, your vocal range and delivery may be well suited for La Traviata but a poor fit for the Star-Spangled Banner. Myriad accomplished singers have attempted the anthem and failed miserably. It is no reflection on the value of their careers to that point, but only on their ability to perform a very difficult piece.

            Sandi Patty has added her name to that list. As evidenced by the popularity of music game shows featuring contestants enamored of playing with pitch and often unable to simply sing, the American public’s definition of what constitutes a “good” and “bad” singer varies widely. In my view — and only my view — Patty’s fluctuating tone, use of questionable source material for the second verse and ham-fisted conclusion make her a bad choice for the Star-Spangled Banner.

          • classically-trained

            That’s basically what I thought; you have no basis of fact; you have not considered the singer’s depth, range, agility, facility, grasp of pitch, etc. I refrain from giving my own opinion on this singer’s ability.

            Classical training and two performances at Carnegie Hall are far more than resume items. They back up what an artist claims that he or she can do, both in terms of musical ability and popularity with the general public. I’m sure that the immense cadre of musicians from every genre would vehemently disagree with your dismissal of these worthy attainments.

            ‘Worth’ as a vocalist does not address ability. Worth simply implies what the untrained ear is willing to pay for the privilege of listening to, in many cases, pablum.

            The anthem is not a ‘very difficult piece’, especially for the trained voice. In actuality, it’s quite a simple piece both in complexity and level of skill required to perform it well.

          • http://www.thestreet.com Jason Notte

            For the benefit of those who still believe the road map to Carnegie Hall is still paved with the words “practice, practice practice,” here’s a little insight: There are music students who will never perform again that can claim two appearances at Carnegie Hall. It says little about their musical ability, even less about their popularity with the general public and doesn’t make them any more qualified to weigh in on one’s musical taste than Biz Markie, mostly because the “immense cadre” of music fans of every genre don’t listen with what you consider a “trained ear.” It does, however, speak a great deal to their availability when Carnegie Hall lays out its season schedule and picks from the scraps that Lincoln Center leaves behind.

            The singer’s “depth, range, agility, facility, grasp of pitch, etc.” aren’t items to be laid out on a spreadsheet. They are qualities that, together, yield an artist’s musical output. These elements on their own are of no consequence when their immediate sum is below par. 

            To address your point about the anthem, it requires just the “depth, range, agility” you prize. Even performers with each of those traits fail at the anthem however. The best example is Anita Baker. Like yourself, Ms. Baker has performed at Carnegie Hall. Unlike yourself, she is roundly considered one of the best in her field and an artist whose vocals are beyond reproach. That changed in 2008, when she performed the Star-Spangled Banner during Game 4 of the NBA Finals in Boston. Baker’s ensuing, disastrous performance resulted in her being jeered out of TD Garden. Her value as a vocalist to that point was immeasurable. Her value during that performance was measured quite easily by those in attendance.

            The same qualities that offended the ears of those in attendance that night similarly offended mine when Ms. Patty sang her revisionist anthem on Monday night.

    • Yadayadabain

      Sandi Patty

  • james e. hestand

    every year I watch the July 4th concert of the Boston Pops and enjoy it. Every year (as a tradition) I expect to the the 1812 overture!!!!Believe me when I tell you this, The July the 4th concert is not complete, repeat, is not complete without the 1812 overture! now I shall have to listen to it on my sound system and wait until next year!!!!!

  • Johnson5000

    This used to be the greatest show, and I have watched faithfully every year.  This year it seemed like a commercial interspersed with a little music.  Was the 1812 NOT played at the concert this year or was it cut out to cram in more commercials.  Wretched!!

  • Mardy Weikel

    What happened to the 1812 Overture at the end.  We didn’t tune into until 9 CST, so missed first 30 min…but it’s always at the end with the cannons……it was missing!!!!  All of the rest was just as good as always, if not better!  We watched your first one, Keith Lockhart and haven’t missed many since.  You were so nervous, we recall…but tonight…you’re the best.

  • 16FelinePaws

    I agree wtih Wlandon, Sjomjo, Sherrillfitzpatric.  I am so disappointed in the lack of patriotic music to accompany the fireworks.  I looked forward to this and had even suggested several others join in watching this year.  And CBS has robbed us of the entire show.  Sad.  Bring back the patriotic music.  We can hear the “stars” and their junk any time.  Give us back the 4th of July!

  • Old Fashioned Listener

    So disappointed! Where was the patriotic music to match the timing of the fireworks??? 1812 Overture was greatly missed!!! Please bring back the music that this holiday deserves!

  • Old Fashioned Girl

    Wow – I guess they did play the 1812 overture. just it was at the beginning of the televised show – almost like a add on so the Pops could play it but it really wasn’t a featured part of the show. What, does CBS think we don’t want to see and hear this timeless tradition for Boston and the Pops on the Fourth! Crazy!!!

  • lokalemom

    I don’t know about “missing” songs, but the Boston Pops fireworks presentation was the best one on tv.  The Star Spangled Banner finale was amazing!

    • 16FelinePaws

       I do agree the Star Spangled Banner finale was awesome.  However the fireworks at our nation’s capital was pretty awe inspiring – especially with the patriotic music accompanying.

  • Showtune

    Where can I find the playlist for the fireworks part of the show?

  • Jnuch1

    the best singing of the national anthem ever

  • ChandlerDonna

    Love the Boston Pops, but this CBS special was terrible…. no one tunes into the Boston Pops 4th to hear recorded music for the fireworks!!  We WANT to hear the 1812… yes, it’s old.  We actually LIKE that!   So, so disappointed…  

  • Nan300z

    Absolultely the most beautiful singing of the Star Spangled Banner I have ever heard. What is her name? Wow, what a voice!!

  • Timduerr1

    Sandi Patty’s National Anthem is AMAZING!!!!!!  What a VOICE!

    • http://www.thestreet.com Jason Notte

      Meh. Maybe she should stick to Francis Scott Key’s rendition.

      • Really?

        Jason, rendition implies FSK also sung the national anthem. I’ve never heard him sing, is he better? Considering he didn’t set out to write a national anthem nor a song and simply wrote a poem I would say it is an incomplete comparison. How about you give Sandi Patty a break?

  • Linda4usa

    This show was in shambles.
    Get rid of the commercial interuptions.
    Get rid of  Mr. Chiklis (nice man but completely out of his comfort zone) and show us a great concert without  delays . Keith Lockhart is a fine musical director and can carry the show himself.  Especially if it’s commercial free!
    Don’t include canned music during the fire works show.  If there was a live person singing, they should have been given credit.  Even the canned music should have been identified.
    Give credit where credit is due.  There were no thanks for the military choir, band(s)m who were also on stage…..
    Who sang the Star Spangled Banner?  She was amazing!  I saw no introduction for her or screen credit after the fact.  What a shame!
    We have the ability to do much better and I hope that we do starting next year.

    • Eixom66

      Linda: turn the TV sound down and listen to the broadcast on WCRB 99.5! Commercial-free, and they carried ALL the music played by the Pops!

    • Yadayadabain

      The amazing Sandi Patty sang the national anthem. You get get that on iTunes off of her “Hymns of Faith, Songs of Inspiration” project. Also, look for her Broadway tribute album recorded w/ the Prague Symphony coming out this fall on Stylos Records. No, I don’t work for her…just a longtime fan. :)

  • Clabonte5

    One CBS station carried the Concert part of the show from 8:00 pm until 10:00 pm…They played the 1812 Overture just after 9:30pm.  Then another CBS station came on at 10:00pm and it was national.  If you were not able to get the Boston CBS channel then you did miss the 1812 Overture….

  • MamMama

    We are in South Carolina and have watched the Boston Pops for years.  At 10:00pm, we see just the last of the show…and then lots of commercials…  I started counting after awhile, and, while short clips, had 13 + !    Of course, enjoyed the Boston Pops, love Keith Lockhart….but with the commercials and the abbreviated time, we see very little.   We want to continue the tradition of enjoying the Pops…let’s have more music and not commercials! Go with PBS!  

  • cheekygirl

    All the hard work you all did showed and really paid off in the wonderful show!  It was absolutely amazing
    and so well done!  Thank you to Keith Lockhart and all the Boston Pops and all the behind the scenes un-sung heros of the day!! What a great 4th it was !! We loved it all–we came down from Wenham and Andover and took the T and had a great time in the city–but the concert and fireworks topped it all!!

  • Simonorsimon

    I looked and looked for who sang “National Anthem” Thought it was Sandy Patty. Finally saw credit in a comment. Best part of show and not Credited?

  • Rwenzel_rocketman

    The show was fantastic.  Michael Chiklis was a good host and the music was spectacular.  A great celebration of the country,s birthday

  • bigguy1

    Even though someone on here is entitled to his opinion of the national anthem, my opinion is he should screw himself. But, the CBS direction/production of the fireworks was horrendous. The network live show was lame. Overall, it was a bust. The Pops should have had more air time.

    • http://www.thestreet.com Jason Notte

      Right back at you, “bigguy1.” I love the anthem, but had little patience for Sandi Patty’s rendition of it featuring a superfluous verse that wasn’t “added” until 1986. Give me Rene Rancourt any day.

      • grayson1

        Thanks for identifying the singer for me.  I thought it was the best job I’ve ever heard done with it.  In this day and age when everyone has their own idea of how it should be sung it was fabulous hearing someone sing it correctly!

        • http://www.thestreet.com Jason Notte

          Now when you say “sing it correctly,” what exactly do you mean? As I mentioned earlier, she sang a verse that was in no way part of the anthem and written in 1986 just for her version. By the standard definition of “incorrect,” I’d say Ms. Patty’s version was just that.

  • Breese210

    The 1812 Overture has not been telecast the couple of years. Will it be added back into the concert at some time? It’s my FAVORITE part. Boston Pops on the 4th is on my Bucket List and if there is no 1812, I may reconsider. If it has been eliminated, please let me know why.
    Who sang the Star Spangled Banner at the end of the program. That was SPECTACULAR!!!
    To get to see the concert, is it just a matter of getting there early (pre-dawn) and waiting in line?

  • Ruthgilfillan

    I used to love the 4th with the Boston Pops, that was when they were on PBS!!!! Now we the viewers see nothing of the Boston Pops and Keith Lockhart beautiful music and talent. CBS has done a terrible job in giving us the show that PBS did such a wonderful job covering!!! All the music that was on the show last night was recorded and we were only given very little by the “Headliner” The Boston Pops Orchestra!!! The 4th is just not the same without the 1812 overture, Stars & Stripes Forever and just being able to enjoy the talent musicians in the orchestra. Please return the program to what it was!!!!

  • kathleen m peterson

    Sorry I missed the Boston Pops Monday night ,my favorite thing to watch on the 4th,any chance of repeating it om tv?

  • Cibarker

    I enjoyed the live music and the fireworks, but was very disturbed by the continual flyover by a helicopter with powerful searchlights playing on the crowd.  It felt as though we were in a police state.  Were we being watched by CBS or security people?  In either case, it detracted enormously. 

  • Bill

    The lady who sang the National Anthem was fantastic!! They should play a tape of her singing it at all athletic events.

  • Dlz1970

    Hey CBS! What happened to the 1812 Overture? I know I  won’t be watching again unless you put back in the program! 

More stories in 'Arts & Culture'
UNDERWRITING
Most Popular
Shop Now
Amazon.com
SUPPORT
This site is best viewed with: Firefox | Internet Explorer 9 | Chrome | Safari