WBUR

‘Whitey’ The Prisoner: A Master Manipulator

Second in a two-part series

When prosecutors set 19 murders before the jurors at James “Whitey” Bulger’s coming trial, they will be going back some 40 years. But newly obtained FBI and prison records take us back almost 60 years.

The records show that Bulger began informing against his criminal associates far earlier than previously thought. There are other surprises too, including the young Whitey’s blue chip political connections and how they may have helped him in prison.

Prison Letters Reveal A Different Side Of Bulger

BOSTON — Convicted bank robber James “Whitey” Bulger entered the Atlanta Federal Penitentiary in July 1956. By the end of October he was in the psychiatric ward. He addressed a letter back to Boston. The message was simple: Get me outta here:

Click the image for a full transcription of Bulger's 1956 letter to then-Dean of Boston College Law School Father Robert Drinan. (Obtained by David Boeri)

I then saw the Psych Dr. and explained that I couldn’t stand the 8-man cell and if only one of them bothered me any more I wasn’t going to hold back anything. Then my nerves were all shot and I kept myself out of trouble by hoping they would help me out of there.

Writer Dick Lehr, who obtained a copy of the letter along with other prison files and documents that have never been reported before, is writing a biography of Bulger with his fellow former Boston Globe reporter Gerry O’Neill.

“He was put in an eight-man cell and it’s driving him crazy,” Lehr said. “This is a man, then and now, who was a control freak who liked to be able to control his environment.”

An excerpt from the letter underlines the point:

I have asked for a little quietness and could see it made for hard feelings. If I complain it would only end up in a fight… I tried to put up with it and said nothing and kept holding everything in… till every little thing started bothering me.

A prison newbie complaining he can’t take it anymore. On the ladder of tough guys, there’s no rung lower than that. Compared to the mythic “Whitey,” this version makes a poor match. Yet in that first intake photo of the 26-year inmate at the Atlanta Federal Penitentiary, you can see the trace of fear and vulnerability.

“It’s really a cry for help; it’s a call for help,” Lehr said.

And Bulger is reaching high above his own family back on Logan Way in Southie to get it. He is writing it to an influential priest at Boston College.

The letter continues:

Would you please see if I have any legal right to a Penit. transfer, any legal rights at all. This is my first time in any prison. Please explain to my brother Bill for me and in turn he can explain to the family and my girl.

I show a copy of the letter to Kevin Weeks, the right-hand man who got left out on the secret his boss was an FBI informant. Though he still feels betrayed, Weeks holds Bulger in a certain awe.

Click the image for a larger version of this 1956 report, which details that Bulger was admitted to the psychiatric ward. (Courtesy of David Boeri)

“He’s very manipulative,” Weeks said. “He’s very Machiavellian. Everything he writes or says or does is to his advantage.”

Weeks sees the letter as the work of a master. He points to the passage where Bulger tries to win the priest’s sympathy by attacking the inmates’ vices:

Most of these men are just killing time and there is a continual idle chatter on sex, cars, money etc. To go with this is a continual game of cards, dominoes or checkers.

“It’s almost as if some young altar boy has been kidnapped and dumped into a federal penitentiary and it’s, ‘Oh my gosh, what a terrible situation to be in,’ ” Lehr said.

In a proclamation of his own piety, Bulger writes to the priest, “Every Sunday I have gone to Chapel and have done my best to make a good record for myself.”

Then comes what Lehr calls the key line:

I am no angel, but… I know if I don’t help myself and put this to good use I will have no future.

Therein starts the theme of Whitey as “the good-bad guy,” Lehr said. “And it’s picked up through the decades so that Whitey Bulger, in the myth of South Boston as it plays out in the ’50s, ’60s, ’70s, ’80s and ’90s, he is the good-bad guy.”

As opposed to the bad-bad guys.

Bulger’s letter never got to its intended recipient. The prison disapproved of its contents, so the letter was consigned to the prison’s central files. Otherwise, we wouldn’t know about it. And we wouldn’t know that it was addressed to Father Robert Drinan, dean of the Boston College Law School and future congressman of international reputation.

Father Robert Drinan’s Bulger Association

It’s a name that jumps off the page of Whitey’s federal prison records. But it’s only the first one that jumps off the page; an even bigger name would follow.

Father Robert F. Drinan, a Jesuit priest who was dean of the Boston College Law School, knew Whitey's brother, William, who was one of his favorite law school students. (AP)

When Bulger put Drinan on his list of correspondents as a “close” friend, the Bureau of Prisons asked Boston Police to do a background check. And the Boston Police replied that Drinan indicated he had known the family for a long time and would be happy to correspond with Bulger.

How in the world would Drinan be connected to the “habitual criminal?” Most likely through a certain Boston College undergraduate, who may have been one of Drinan’s favorite students. The student was William Bulger, Whitey’s younger brother, and he would soon attend BC’s Law School, where Drinan was dean.

“The inference is that it’s through Bill Bulger there’s established a beachhead with Robert Drinan,” Lehr said.

From early on in Whitey’s prison term, Father Drinan was listed as the person who would be Bulger’s parole adviser upon his release. The only correspondence Lehr has seen is the one letter the prison held onto.

Father Drinan died in 2007. His papers and a recent Drinan biography contain no reference to either of the Bulger brothers. And when I talked to Drinan’s former congressional aides, his former chief of staff and his closest political advisers, they were stunned at the link to Whitey.

Click the image for a larger version of the 1959 letter Whitey’s brother, William, wrote to the warden of the Atlanta Federal Penitentiary. (Courtesy of David Boeri)

A typical response came from Jerome Grossman, who became one of Drinan’s best friends after recruiting him to run for Congress as a progressive, anti-war candidate in 1970.

“It’s a complete surprise,” Grossman said.

Then again, those who knew Drinan say the priest kept his priestly duties and corporal acts of mercy — like visiting or writing to prisoners — a private matter and apart from public duties.

The letter to Drinan closes with the tone of an order being directed to a future subordinate:

Well, Father Drinan, that’s about it and it’s the true story seen through my eyes… Write me as soon as possible. James J. Bulger 77607

Seeing the same letter, former Boston Police Detective Eddie Walsh smiled. The 90-year-old figures he’s seen just about everything. He first saw Bulger in 1955.

“Bulger’s very devious and would try anything he could do to get out of there, you know,” and reach as high as he could to do it, Walsh said.

I ask him about Whitey checking into the psychiatric ward.

“What’s this tell you?” I asked Walsh about Bulger’s nervous breakdown letter.

“It tells you he’s full of baloney,” Walsh replied.

Blue Chip Connections

Father Drinan wasn’t Bulger’s biggest blue chip connection. You want to know how big that connection was? His biggest blue chip swore in Vice President Hubert Humphrey in 1964.

Former Southie Rep. John McCormack was a neighbor of the Bulger family. (Courtesy of the Lyndon B. Johnson Library)

By 1964, and before Whitey’s third attempt to win early parole from a 20-year prison sentence, John McCormack was speaker of the U.S. House. In a totally implausible and fortuitous electoral coincidence, McCormack happened to be the congressman for South Boston and a neighbor of the Bulger family. For the Bulgers, this gave new meaning to “luck of the Irish.”

“They are fortunate to have access to John McCormack, who has easy access to the director of the entire Federal Prison System,” Lehr said.

In 1956, the year Bulger first went to prison, McCormack was still House majority leader, No. 2 in the line of succession, when young college student William Bulger, on behalf of his family, asked the congressman for help. To the normal congressman it would have fallen into the normal everyday requests for constituent services. Except McCormack wasn’t your normal congressman, as Lehr pointed out.

“He’s got the director of the Bureau of Prisons practically jumping up and down to check on James ‘Whitey’ Bulger’s status in prison,” Lehr said.

The letters from the Bureau of Prisons to McCormack are cordial and they come quickly. But they also explain diplomatically that McCormack’s constituent is a bad ass.

“I regret that I have to report that he has had some difficulty at Atlanta,” wrote the director to McCormack in February 1959.

Click the image for a larger version of the Federal Bureau Of Prisons director's 1961 letter to John McCormack. (Courtesy of David Boeri)

The so-called “difficulty” was an attempted prison escape. In fact, Bulger’s conduct at the Atlanta Penitentiary got him sent to the notorious prison on a rock, Alcatraz. And no prisoner qualifies for early parole out of Alcatraz.

For Bulger, the payoff from his connection to McCormack would be down the road, Lehr said, but “what gets established is John McCormack has an interest in this inmate.”

There’s no suggestion or any evidence at all of any arm-twisting by McCormack. He’s simply doing constituent services for the Bulger family in his own hometown. But how many inmates hold the interest of a congressman who presides over the House of Representatives?

After an inquiry from McCormack in 1961, the director of the Bureau of Prisons wrote the warden of Alcatraz asking when he thought Bulger would be considered for transfer.

“My dear Mr. Speaker,” the Bureau of Prisons director wrote back to McCormack. “I have asked the institutional people to keep him [Bulger] in mind and bring the case again to my attention in the not-distant future.”

John F. Kennedy was president when Bulger was moved out of Alcatraz to the penitentiary in Leavenworth, Kan., and then applied for early parole in 1963. Bulger was denied, but he was transferred closer to home to the penitentiary in Lewisburg, Pa. Then in March 1965, Bulger won early parole on his third attempt. He had served only nine years of a 20-year sentence for three armed bank robberies. Prison officials gave him $10 and opened the outer gate.

As for Whitey’s post-prison adjustment, Kevin Weeks might be considered an authority.

“Do you have reason to believe there might have been more bank robberies?” I asked him.

“Oh yeah,” Weeks responded. “Bulger claimed to have committed 19 bank robberies after he got out of prison.”

Before Whitey left prison, officials had decided he would not have to visit a parole adviser as a condition of release. That meant Drinan, who was named Bulger’s parole adviser at the start, was spared the assignment and, as it turns out, any future embarrassment. Otherwise, the heroic priest and progressive celebrated for the honor of being named to President Nixon’s “enemies list” might have had the dishonor of being named to Bulger’s “friends list.”

In part 1 of this two-part series, we reported on newly uncovered documents that show Bulger started snitching on fellow criminals back in the 1950s, and that his life on the run with a South Boston girlfriend back then began a pattern he would follow for decades.

Please follow our community rules when engaging in comment discussion on wbur.org.
  • Neena Malloy

    Great story. Gotta wonder what strings the Bulgers are trying to pull now to help their dear soci0pathic brother. 

  • mh2

    Just another coward trying to make money by trashing a good family. Boeri,Lehr,and the rest of these bozo fiction ‘writers’ should really get a life.

    • Tron

      A good family?  Has Whitey Bulger done anything to prove that he’s “good” as you say?  I don’t think Boeri is the delusional one here…

    • Amcmanda

      Seriously?  Should an entire family be characterized by any one member of it, good or bad?

      • Neena Malloy

        The problem is not a single member of this family has ever condemned the horrific acts of its kin, Whitey Bulger. Billy Bulger admitted to Congress he refused to help the government in its search for this killer.

    • Neena Malloy

      It’s exactly this kind of enabling that allowed the Bulger family cabal to control Boston and foment corruption for so long. Thank god Mitt Romney gave Billy boy the boot for protecting his murderer rapist of a brother.

    • John C

      Hey MH2, nice troll-job. I’m sure you’d be the one to teach them, eh?

  • Alison

    What about MK-Ultra? How come there is no mention of that?

    • badasssherry50

      Allison baby, They are hiding that, Because they are still after that poor girl and her family. They want leave them alone. Its really sad to do that to her. I hope that Whitey is brave and will save her and her family.

  • LM

    Violent crime will be around for as long as there are people to be violent towards, this is because violence is in our nature. Some people may not want to belive that but, its the truth. I love Mr. Boeri’s Bulger reporting. It’s his crown jewel, and I’m so happy he is able to finish a tale most of us in the Boston area thought was over and done with ten years ago. Maybe we shouldn’t romantize criminals, but we do. I think, personally, this is because they dare to do what most of us wouldn’t dream of. It’s fascinating, pure and unadulturated violence, lies, and fear. But its also exilerating. The way Mr. Boeri is able to paint Mr. Bulger in his pure natural state is a treat for all of us. Its a window into a life that most of us know none to very little about. Like a car crash; David is the spectator who can’t look away and we are the ones who ask him to look because for most of us it would be too hard and too disturbing. Mr. Boeri is good enough to not only never look away, but to discover why the car crashed in the first place, and where it came from to where it sits now, a rusted hulk in a field; perhaps too old and too far gone to salvage, but still has a history to tell. Thank you David. Keep up the good work and I’ll keep reading.           

  • Zelda43

    Whitey Bulger was a nothing more than a punk, thug and murderer.  To use “master”

    in any context to describe this pathetic character is an insult.  

  • badasssherry50

    I think Whitey is a good man. Leave the old man alone. If you punish him, What about the goverment officials , Are you gonna punish them and bring them out. No, Of coarse not, just blame it all on him. The do man. He is the fall guy. He is not all to blame. They should of never made him a snitch in the first place. I feel sorry for the victims, But I doubt very seriously he did it.

  • badasssherry50

    Allison baby, They are hiding that, Because they are still after that poor girl and her family. They want leave them alone. Its really sad to do that to her.

  • badasssherry50

    Whitey is a good person. Please go do research on him before you make your judgement on him.

Most Popular