Marathon Bombing: Investigation And Aftermath
Editor’s Note: As of 4 p.m. on April 26, 2013, we are no longer updating this blog. For complete coverage of the marathon bombing and aftermath, see more stories here.
Boston Marathon Bombing: Significant Developments:
- Monday, April 15: Bombs at the Marathon finish line kill three and injure hundreds more
- Thursday, April 18: Black hat and white hat: FBI releases photos and video of suspects
- Thursday and Friday, April 18-19: MIT police officer is killed; shootout in Watertown; one suspect dies, other escapes
- Friday, April 19: Manhunt for surviving suspect as Boston area is put on lockdown
- Friday evening, April 19: Lockdown lifted; suspect is located and captured in Watertown
- Monday, April 22: Dzhokhar Tsarnaev charged with using a weapon of mass destruction
- Wednesday, May 1: Three college friends of Dzhokhar accused of disposing of backpack
- More Coverage: Boston Marathon Bombings
The Associated Press reports:
The mother of the Boston Marathon bombing suspects was added to a federal terrorism database about 18 months before the attack, government officials said Thursday.
Two government officials said the CIA had Zubeidat Tsarnaeva’s name listed along with that of her son Tamerlan Tsarnaev after Russia contacted the agency in 2011 with concerns that the two were religious militants about to travel to Russia. The officials spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to speak publicly about the case.
Being in the classified TIDE database does not automatically mean a person is suspected by the U.S. of terrorist activity and does not automatically subject someone to surveillance, security screening or travel restrictions.
One week after the suspect in the marathon bombings was captured, members of the Massachusetts Congressional delegation will honor victims and first responders on the floor of the U.S. House of Representatives.
From 1:00-1:30 p.m. today, the “delegation along with members of Congress from neighboring states will recognize and thank law enforcement officers, medical professionals, first responders, and citizen heroes for their incredible bravery, dedication, and sacrifice,” according to the delegation’s press release.
The representatives will also honor those who lost their lives — Martin Richard, Krystle Campbell, Lu Lingzi, and MIT officer Sean Collier — as well as those injured in the attacks, now totaling over 200.
“It was a difficult time not just for Massachusetts and the Greater Boston area but for the country,” Rep. Joseph Kennedy III of Massachusetts’ 4th District told WBUR earlier today. “There has been a silver lining to it, seeing how the community has come together has certainly been inspiring for a lot of people, myself included.”
The surviving suspect in the Boston Marathon bombings has been moved to federal medical detention facility about 40 miles west of Boston.
The U.S. Marshals Service says 19-year-old Dzhokhar Tsarnaev was moved overnight from Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston to the Federal Medical Center Devens in central Massachusetts.
According to its website, the facility is an “administrative facility housing male offenders requiring specialized or long-term medical or mental health care” and also has a “satellite camp housing minimum security male inmates.”
The bombing suspects’ involvement in a robbery of a 7-Eleven. The Watertown resident’s boat not being in the police perimeter. The resident seeing blood on the boat’s tarp, which led him to find the suspect.
Over the last week, we’ve noted that these and a few other initial details from the manhunt — offered by authorities and then reported by us — have since been deemed incorrect.
In fact — and in the interest of setting the record straight on what we’ve reported — the suspects did not rob a convenience store, State Police told us later; the boat was within the sealed-off perimeter, Boston police said later; and the owner of the boat did not see blood, he told WCVB-TV. Additionally, officials told The Associated Press the suspect was unarmed in the boat when captured, which counters what Boston’s police commissioner had said earlier.
WBUR’s David Boeri and Anthony Brooks discussed these evolving details and the nature of fact-finding in a manhunt on Radio Boston. It’s worth a listen:
Boston Magazine released its May cover this morning:
The cover is of shoes worn during the marathon and the soon-out issue features stories of runners who wore the shoes. Boston Magazine’s editor explains the story behind the cover here.
In a just-completed news conference, New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg and Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly said the Tsarnaev brothers intended to set off additional explosives in the city’s Times Square.
The NYC officials said the suspected Boston Marathon bombers had a pressure cooker bomb and five pipe bombs in their possession.
The Boston Globe adds:
… Kelly said that the Tsarnaevs had initially told investigators that he and his brother had decided to go to New York to “party.” But that story changed, he said, in a subsequent investigation.
Kelly said the brothers had “decided spontaneously” on Times Square as a target, while they were driving around [Greater Boston] in a carjacked Mercedes.
A roundup of today’s (Thursday) developments:
— The Boston Globe and The New York Times report that killed bombing suspect Tamerlan Tsarnaev was placed on two separate terror watch lists — by the FBI and the CIA — after the two agencies were alerted to his suspicious activities by Russian authorities.
— Officials told The Associated Press surviving bombing suspect Dzhokhar Tsarnaev was unarmed when he was captured in a Watertown boat. The AP adds: “Boston Police Commissioner Ed Davis said earlier that shots were fired from inside the boat.”
— The suspects’ father today told reporters, including the AP, that he plans to leave Russia for the U.S. “today or tomorrow.” The father has expressed a desire to come to the U.S. to defend his younger son “and if possible bring his older son’s body back to Russia for burial,” the AP reports.
Meanwhile, in Rhode Island, Tamerlan’s widow “has not yet said whether she plans a funeral or wants to claim his body,” the AP reports.
More from The Associated Press in Washington:
U.S. officials say the Boston Marathon explosions that killed three people and wounded more than 260 were triggered by a remote-controlled detonator.
Two officials on Wednesday said the bombs were not very sophisticated. One of the officials described the detonator as “close-controlled” — meaning it had to be triggered within several blocks of the bombs.
It’s not clear what the detonation device was, the AP adds, but in the criminal complaint against him, authorities described Dzhokhar Tsarnaev as holding a cellphone before the blasts.
Citing officials, The Associated Press reports from Washington:
U.S. officials say the surviving suspect in last week’s attack on the Boston Marathon has told investigators he and his brother were angry about U.S. wars in Muslim countries.
Two officials said that Dzhokhar Tsarnaev acknowledged the anti-U.S. motive while being questioned by investigators last weekend.
One official on Wednesday said Tsarnaev cited the U.S.-led invasions of Iraq and Afghanistan as the motive for the Boston attack. The official was briefed on the investigation by the FBI.
The other official is close to the investigation. Both officials demanded anonymity to talk about the ongoing probe.
Neighbors have described Dzhokhar’s older brother, Tamerlan, as visibly angry about the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq.
The development follows a similar report from The Washington Post.
Boston Mayor Thomas M. Menino today announced that parking at meters on Boylston Street, as well as throughout the entire Back Bay, will be free today through Sunday. The City encourages all to come back to the area, go to our restaurants, go to our shops and get involved in the recovery effort.
“Boston is strong and we will support Boylston Strong all weekend long,” Mayor Menino said.
He continued, “As of today, these businesses that have been off limits since Marathon Monday are open and are looking forward to receiving and serving their customers once again. To support the efforts of our local businesses through the end of the weekend, the City of Boston is offering free parking at meters on Boylston Street and throughout the entire Back Bay.”
The meters in question are located on all Back Bay streets between Arlington Street and Massachusetts Avenue, as well as those parking meters adjacent to the Public Garden.
Less than a week after losing both her legs below the knee in the blasts at the finish line of the Boston Marathon, Celeste Corcoran sits in a hospital bed next to her daughter, 18-year-old Sydney, who suffered injuries from severe shrapnel wounds.
“I can’t do anything right now,” Celeste says.
But Gabe Martinez and Cameron West, two Marines with the nonprofit Semper Fi Fund, are there to tell her it gets better.
“Right now, yes, but I’m telling you, with all my heart, you are going to be more independent than you ever were,” Martinez says. “This is basically the start, you know, this is the new beginning for the both of you.”
According to The Boston Globe, between West and Martinez, they had lost three legs and part of a hand in separate bomb blasts in Afghanistan in 2010. The veterans visited four hospitals in a 24-hour trip to Boston.
Watch the full video, which was posted on a fundraising page for the Corcorans, here:
WBUR has reconstructed a timeline of the chaotic manhunt for the two suspects in the Boston Marathon bombings. On Thursday evening, the FBI released surveillance images of two suspects. Here’s what happened after that.
The city of Cambridge is closing various roads beginning before the Wednesday morning rush hour for the memorial service in honor of MIT police officer Sean Collier.
The following roads will be closed to vehicular traffic:
- Vassar Street — between Audrey Street and Mass Ave
- Mass Ave — from Albany Street toward Boston
- Mass Ave Bridge into Cambridge
The following roads will be closed to both vehicular traffic and pedestrian and bicycle traffic:
- Memorial Drive — between Mass Ave and the Boston University bridge
Update at 2 p.m.: Here’s the report on the now-completed memorial.
Update at 5 p.m.: Here’s WBUR’s Fred Bever on the reopening.
#CommunityAlert: As of 3:00am on 04/24/13 – Boylston Street will re-open. Parking not permitted in & around the impacted areas.
— Boston Police Dept. (@Boston_Police) April 24, 2013
The Associated Press reports:
Traffic was allowed to flow all the way down Boylston Street on Wednesday morning for the first time since two explosions on April 15 killed three spectators and sent more than 260 to the hospital.
Delivery trucks made their way down the street under a heavy police presence.
Workers at some businesses and hotels in the area were allowed to return to their jobs on Tuesday to prepare for reopening.
Some stores directly affected by the blasts are still boarded up.
The Copley subway station that had been closed since the bombings also reopened, while the main branch of the Boston Public Library was also scheduled to reopen Wednesday.
— MBTA (@mbtaGM) April 24, 2013
David Henneberry, the Watertown resident who found the surviving Marathon bombing suspect in his boat Friday evening, called himself an “incidental hero” in an interview with WCVB-TV.
The Associated Press adds these details of the interview:
Henneberry said he didn’t see blood outside his boat Friday evening, but went to check it twice because its cover was disarranged. The second time, he climbed a ladder, lifted the wrap, and saw “a good amount” of blood on the floor.
Henneberry said he saw a body inside, but didn’t see the face. He said he doesn’t remember going down the ladder to call 911, but says “I didn’t waste any time.”
You can watch the full WCVB interview here.
Donations to the One Fund Boston, benefiting victims of the Boston Marathon bombings, have surpassed $20 million, officials said today.
Fund officials will begin taking applications from victims on May 15, and people will have a month to register. The first payments are expected to be distributed June 30.
In a news conference, the fund’s administrator, attorney Kenneth Feinberg, said: “One hundred percent of funds allocated to One Fund Boston will be distributed by the Fourth of July to every eligible claimant, who have examined the claim form and have satisfied that they’re eligible.”
It’s not a lot of money when you look at the nature of injuries, the number of injuries, how you’re going to divide this money. It is a wonderful outpouring, but it won’t make people whole.
Katherine Russell, the wife of suspected Boston Marathon bomber Tamerlan Tsarnaev, says “reports of involvement by her husband and brother-in-law came as an absolute shock,” according to a statement released through her attorneys and obtained by The Boston Herald.
More from the statement, via the Herald:
As a mother, a sister, a daughter, a wife, Katie deeply mourns the pain and loss to innocent victims — students, law enforcement, families and our community. In the aftermath of this tragedy, she, her daughter and her family are trying to come to terms with these events.
The tweets from the account believed to be Tsarvaev’s are a mixture of profane, mundane, silly and sometimes ominous.
This just in from the U.S. attorney’s office in Massachusetts:
According to Beth Israel Deaconess, at noon today, Dzhokhar Tsarvaev’s condition is listed as “fair.” Releasing info at request of BIDMC.
— U.S. Attorney MA (@DMAnews1) April 23, 2013
This statement was just released from Denise and Bill Richard, parents of Martin Richard, the 8-year-old killed in last week’s bombing:
The outpouring of love and support over the last week has been tremendous. This has been the most difficult week of our lives and we appreciate that our friends and family have given us space to grieve and heal.
A private Funeral Mass was celebrated this morning with immediate family. We laid our son Martin to rest, and he is now at peace. We plan to have a public memorial service in the coming weeks to allow friends and loved ones from our community to join us for a celebration of Martin’s life.
WBUR’s Delores Handy reports on response of the family’s community:
MIT has decided to cancel classes Wednesday in order to “allow a day of reflection for the MIT community upon the loss of MIT Police Officer Sean Collier.”
MIT is hosting a memorial service in honor of Collier at noon Wednesday. The event is open to “law enforcement and members of the MIT community with MIT IDs” only. It is not open to the general public. Vice President Joe Biden is expected to attend. (More information on on the memorial here.)
The city of Cambridge has announced multiple road closures around the event, including the closure of Memorial Drive midnight Wednesday between Massachusetts Avenue and the Boston University bridge. The Massachusetts Avenue bridge will close at 7 a.m. Wednesday. (See the city of Cambridge website for more details on road closures.)
A private funeral for Collier was held on Tuesday.
Residents and business owners are returning to parts of Boylston Street this morning for the first time since the bombings.
Block-by-block, city officials are taking people from the Hynes Convention Center to Boylston Street to review their property and help identify any issues with which the city can help.
While the street remains closed to traffic and the general public from Hereford to Berkeley until further notice (see current access map), the Associated Press reports that police this morning were allowing pedestrians and traffic to cross Boylston Street on Clarendon for the first time since the bombings.
The mayor’s office says at this time it is unclear when businesses closest to the bombing sites will be allowed to reopen.
The Boston Police Department has begun the process of returning belongings people left behind while fleeing last week’s attacks. The FBI has released the items it says are not needed for evidence and they can be collected in three ways.
- Visit in person at One Schroder Plaza, Media Room — 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. beginning Tuesday, April 23 to Friday, April 26. Bring proper identification. Parking will be available on Tremont Street. Please follow direction of officers.
- Email email@example.com with name, phone number, email address and description of items lost (as detailed as possible). You will be contacted if the item is in possession of BPD.
- Call the mayor’s hotline at 617-635-4500 with a description of lost items. You will receive a follow up call from BPD.
The BPD says it will work with other police departments to deliver items to people living outside of the region.
Jack Fleming, of the Boston Athletic Association, paused at the finish line on Boylston Street between Dartmouth and Exeter streets yesterday after a ceremony in which federal investigators formally released the finish line bombing crime scene to the city of Boston:
Sean Collier, the MIT police officer authorities say was killed in a confrontation with the suspected Marathon bombers on Thursday, was memorialized in Stoneham today. It was a reminder for many locals that several of their neighbors were hurt in the original attack.
The funeral at St. Patrick Church was a very private affair. Dozens of police officers from Somerville, Cambridge and Arlington stood at attention before the funeral, which Gov. Deval Patrick also attended.
After the hearse carrying Collier’s coffin drove away, his colleagues from the MIT police force made a somber parade march down the street.
It was a cold and raw day, but a few bystanders stood outside during the service, and afterward. As the police officers marched past, Mary Ellen Monahan walked down the street, tears streaming from her eyes.
“To be that young and to be a real man and to just put your life on the line for people you don’t know,” she said. “That man doesn’t know me. And he dies for us to be able to live like us, for us to walk down the street, for us to be free and now he’s dead and he’s just a baby and he didn’t get to have the life I have.”
Many in Stoneham seem traumatized by last week’s events. Mary Susan Blout says the attack was merciless to the community.
“It’s just amazing how many people were injured that day from this town,” she said. “Obviously the Dorchester effect was a whole family but other than that I don’t know any town that had so many people from it that were directly affected. Three people lost limbs, two were burned, and now this poor guy, it’s unbelievable.”
Locals describe this Boston suburb of 23,000 as a close-knit town; it seems like everyone knows someone whose life was affected by the bombings and their aftermath. Two of the injured, brothers JP and Paul Norden, were regulars at a restaurant in bordering Wakefield, the Dockside.
The restaurant held fundraisers for the victims last week, and “Boston Strong” T-shirts are still on sale. Bartender Melanie Hartrey says she’s known the brothers and family for a decade.
“I hear they are doing well,” she said. “I believe they had surgeries yesterday but I believe they are doing well. We just saw some pictures on facebook and they look like they are in good spirits. I know they are more worried about each other and being in different hospitals, and worried about their mom, than anything else.
Town officials are planning a “Stoneham Strong” fundraiser at the high school football field this Friday.
This post was reported by Fred Bever and updated at 5:15 p.m.
A separate memorial service at MIT’s Briggs Field is planned for noon Wednesday. That service, which Vice President Joe Biden is expected to attend, is open to law enforcement and members of the MIT community with MIT IDs only. (More information on who is invited here.) MIT has also cancelled classes Wednesday.
The city of Cambridge has announced multiple road closures around the event, including the closure of Memorial Drive midnight Wednesday between Massachusetts Avenue and the Boston University Bridge. The Massachusetts Avenue Bridge will close at 7 a.m. Wednesday. (See the city of Cambridge website for more details on road closures.)
The Associated Press reports:
Public health officials are now saying that 264 people sought treatment at Boston area hospitals for injuries sustained in the Boston Marathon bombings.
Authorities had been saying that about 180 people were injured, but that was just victims brought to the hospital in the immediate aftermath of the April 15 explosions. Three people were killed and at least 14 people lost all or part of a limb.
The Boston Public Health Commission says some people delayed seeking treatment, for example, people who had ringing in their ears from the blasts they thought might go away, but persisted for several days. Other people sought delayed treatment for minor shrapnel wounds. Twenty-seven different hospitals treated the injured.
The commission said as of Tuesday, 51 people were still hospitalized.
This post was updated at 3 p.m.
The memorial that grew organically on Boylston Street is following the bombings is just one of the powerful things that have brought people together in response to last week’s attacks.
The Rev. Liz Walker, a longtime Boston TV news anchor who is now pastor of the Roxbury Presbyterian Church, says she is struck by the community that has emerged in response to the attack:
The city of Boston says, in a press release:
The Federal Bureau of Investigation presented Mayor Menino with a commemorative American flag that has flown at half-staff over the Boston Marathon Finish line in a ceremony that turned Boylston Street back over to the City of Boston.
This will enable the City to commence its five phase plan for re-opening the street.
The city details its five-point plan here.
The Middlesex County district attorney’s office says it will investigate if any links turn up between a suspected Marathon bomber and an unsolved 2011 slaying.
The Associated Press details:
Marathon bombing suspect Tamerlan Tsarnaev, who was pronounced dead early Friday after a shootout with police, was a friend of one of three men found dead in an apartment in Waltham on Sept. 12, 2011, with their necks slit and their bodies reportedly covered with marijuana.
Tsarnaev’s friend, Brendan Mess, was also a boxer.
At 2:50 p.m. — one week to the minute after two explosions rocked the Boston Marathon — people in Boston and other cities observed a moment of silence for the attack’s victims.
Per State House News Service reporter Matthew Murphy, Gov. Deval Patrick led the moment on the State House steps. “God bless the people of Massachusetts,” he said after it was over. “Boston Strong.”
Added The Boston Globe’s Andrew Ryan, elsewhere in the city:
The bell tolled at Faneuil Hall, hundreds stood silent on cobblestones, some prayed, some held hands, some cried
— Andrew Ryan (@GlobeAndrewRyan) April 22, 2013
WBUR’s Curt Nickisch captured this photo at the Back Bay station near Copley Square this morning:
“The MBTA is pleased to play a role in spreading the message that Boston is a city united,” MBTA General Manager Beverly Scott said in a statement. “I am so proud of the way Transit Police and MBTA personnel conducted themselves throughout the ordeal.”
Surviving Boston Marathon bombing suspect Dzhokhar Tsarnaev has been charged with using and conspiring to use a weapon of mass destruction.
The charge carries a possible death sentence. In a press release, the U.S. Department of Justice details:
In a criminal complaint unsealed today in U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts, Tsarnaev is specifically charged with one count of using and conspiring to use a weapon of mass destruction (namely, an improvised explosive device or IED) against persons and property within the United States resulting in death, and one count of malicious destruction of property by means of an explosive device resulting in death. The statutory charges authorize a penalty, upon conviction, of death or imprisonment for life or any term of years.
Tsarnaev, 19, is in serious condition at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston. He made his initial court appearance today from his hospital room.
“Although our investigation is ongoing, today’s charges bring a successful end to a tragic week for the city of Boston, and for our country,” U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder said in the release.
Added Boston Police Commissioner Ed Davis: “The arrest of Tsarnaev and today’s charges should send a clear message to those who look to do us harm, the entire law enforcement community will go after you, find you and bring you to justice.”
Update at 2:30 p.m.: We’re combing through the complaint (see it in full below). A few details from it:
— Per WBUR’s Lisa Tobin, FBI Special Agent Daniel Genck (the complaint’s author) has this chilling description of Marathon Monday:
Bomber Two remained in the same spot for approximately four minutes … Approximately 30 seconds before the first explosion, he lifts his phone to his ear as if he is speaking on his cell phone, and keeps it there for approximately 18 seconds. A few seconds after he finishes the call, the large crowd of people around him can be seen reacting to the first explosion. Virtually every head turns to the east (towards the finish line) and stares in that direction in bewilderment and alarm. Bomber Two, virtually alone among the individuals in front of the restaurant, appears calm. He glances to the east and then calmly but rapidly begins moving to the west, away from the direction of the finish line. He walks away without his knapsack, having left it on the ground where he had been standing. Approximately 10 seconds later, an explosion occurs in the location where Bomber Two had placed his knapsack.
— When he was found in the boat in a Watertown backyard, Tsarnaev had “apparent gunshot wounds to the head, neck, legs, and hand.”
— The FBI found the following items in his University of Massachusetts Dartmouth dorm room: “a large pyrotechnic, a black jacket and a white hat of the same general appearance as those worn by Bomber Two at the Boston Marathon on April 15,2013, and BBs.”
Update at 2:40 p.m.: More details:
— From the testimony of the victim of late Thursday night’s carjacking in Cambridge:
The victim stated that while he was sitting in his car on a road in Cambridge, a man approached and tapped on his passenger-side window. When the victim rolled down the window, the man reached in, opened the door, and entered the victim’s vehicle. The man pointed a firearm at the victim and stated, “Did you hear about the Boston explosion?” and “I did that.” The man removed the magazine from his gun and showed the victim
that it had a bullet in it, and then re-inserted the magazine. The man then stated, “I am serious.”
— “A preliminary examination of the explosive devices that were discovered at the scene of the shootout in Watertown [early Friday] and in the abandoned vehicle has revealed similarities to the explosives used at the Boston Marathon. The remnants of at least one of the exploded IEDs at the scene of the shootout indicate that a low-grade explosive had been contained in a pressure cooker. The pressure cooker was of the same brand as the ones used in the Marathon explosions.”
Update at 7 p.m.: Here’s WBUR’s David’s Boeri on the charges:
Here’s the criminal complaint (via Scribd):
More: Here’s the transcript of Tsarnaev’s bedside court hearing (via Scribd):
BREAKING: White House says surviving suspect in Boston bombings will not be tried as an enemy combatant.
— The Associated Press (@AP) April 22, 2013
That means Dzhokhar Tsarnaev will be tried in federal court, as opposed to as an enemy combatant in a military tribunal.
The Associated Press adds:
Tsarnaev is a naturalized U.S. citizen. [White House spokesman Jay] Carney says that under U.S. law U.S. citizens cannot be tried in military commissions.
The White House, via Carney, also defended the FBI’s 2011 inquiry into Tsarnaev’s older brother, Tamerlan Tsarnaev.
The AP details:
The Russian FSB intelligence security service told the FBI in early 2011 about information that Tsarnaev was a follower of radical Islam. The FBI says it conducted interviews and provided the results in the summer of 2011. The bureau says it also checked U.S. government databases and other information to look into his telephone communications, possible use of radical online sites, personal associations, and travel and education history.
This post was updated at 1:40 p.m.
Krystle Campbell, 29, who was killed in the Marathon bombings, was laid to rest in Medford today.
On a bright but brisk morning, two black limousines with open backs, and filled with springtime flowers, pulled up beside the red-brick St. Joseph Church. Soon they were followed by a motorcycle escort that led Campbell’s friends and family to her funeral.
A few minutes later, firefighters provided an honor guard and saluted as pallbearers carried Campbell’s coffin inside. Hundreds had cued up to attend the service, and hundreds more watched from across the street.
Steven Stefarie said he’s angry.
“It’s a damn shame,” he said. “My heart. I cried and cried and cried; I haven’t that much since my sister died, I couldn’t believe it, the tragedies and senselessness. I’m amazed. The scum of the earth that would hurt people like that… and for what?”
The church was packed, and many were not able to get in. But they lingered a while, in solidarity with the hometown woman and her family. Nedina Talukdar and two friends who went to the same high school as Campbell were there. Talukdar said it’s a close-knit community.
“I think we just wanted to come out and show our support,” she said. “Krystle’s a Medford girl, we’re all from Medford, and we just feel a certain sense of pride in our city ”
Many who knew Campbell speak about her outgoing nature, her big blue eyes. Gail Robinson, whose daughter was close with Campbell, says the freckled, exuberant young woman would have appreciated the turnout.
“To see thousands of people out here, oh my God it would be just like Krystle,” she said. “I mean I don’t want to see her gone, but this is just surreal.”
And like so many whose lives have been touched by the Marathon attack and aftermath, Robinson says she’s having trouble making sense of it all.
“It really seems unfair, I couldn’t believe it,” she said. “I’m like, thousands of people there and I am saying, ‘Why, why did she have to be standing there?’ ”
The service was officiated by Boston Cardinal Sean O’Malley, and attendees included Gov. Deval Patrick, interim U.S. Sen. Mo Cowan and Lt. Gov. Timothy Murray.
There had been rumors that a fringe group might try to stage a protest at the event, but that did not materialize.
Campbell was buried at Oak Grove cemetery in Medford.
This was reported by Fred Bever and was updated at 5:45 p.m.
With Boston Marathon bombings suspect Dzhokhar Tsarnaev in a hospital bed, attention has turned to the legal case against him.
Among the questions: Who will defend Tsarnaev? What are the implications of the investigators’ decision not to read the suspect his Miranda rights? Will prosecutors seek the death penalty?
WBUR Morning Edition host Bob Oakes asked WBUR reporter David Boeri these questions and more.
On who will represent Tsarnaev:
[Federal public defender] Miriam Conrad said she expects to be appointed to the case, but the protocol is she won’t be appointed until the government files charges in the case. It’s not clear when that’s going to happen. And that’s because, as U.S. Attorney Carmen Ortiz said on Friday night, Mr. Tsarnaev is not going to be given his Miranda rights or charged until after they finish questioning him about whether there are more bombs, whether there are more bomb-making conspirators who were with them last week and whether there were any imminent threats.
On the key legal concerns for investigators:
Well, the first concern is over Miranda rights, and what Ortiz [called] a public safety exemption in cases of national security and potential charges involving acts of terrorism. Contrary to what people see in television police procedurals, police are not required to read a subject his Miranda rights — tell him that anything he says can be used against him, that he has a right to remain silent, a right to be represented by a lawyer. You know, reading the rights is critical only if the government wants to [use] the suspect’s statements against him… in a criminal case. And two years ago, an FBI memo told its agents to ask… any and all questions prompted by immediate safety concerns, without advising the arrestee of his Miranda rights.
On how long the public safety exemption can hold up, with dwindling concern about further attacks:
As time goes on without any further incident — and investigators in this case say they’ve been increasingly convinced that the two acted alone — then the argument of a public safety exemption loses its power.
On the likely forum for a case — state court, federal court, or a military tribunal:
Suffolk County and Middlesex County could both file charges… But importantly here, Massachusetts doesn’t have the death penalty, so it’s far more likely it’s going to end up in federal court, where they have a range of terrorism charges, including the use of weapons of mass destruction — and of course that carries the death penalty.
So, the final possibility — and it’s being pushed by Senators John McCain and Lindsey Graham is to treat… Tsarnaev as an enemy combatant. Yet, that seems a stretch because he’s an American citizen, he’s committed the alleged crimes here on American soil and as one lawyer said, he’s no more an enemy combatant than Timothy McVeigh, who blew up the federal building in Oklahoma.
Listen to David Boeri’s full conversation with Bob Oakes:
From NPR’s Morning Edition:
NPR’s Dina Temple-Raston added on Morning Edition that some of the video evidence, investigators say, shows Dzhokhar slipping a backpack off his shoulder, placing it on the ground, making a phone call and walking away. The second of the two explosions, she said, appeared to happen “right where that backpack had been.
The Associated Press reports:
The city’s police commissioner said the two suspects had such a large cache of weapons that they were probably planning other attacks.
After the two brothers engaged in a gun battle with police early Friday, authorities surveying the scene of the shootout found it was loaded with unexploded homemade bombs. They also found more than 250 rounds of ammunition.
Police Commissioner Ed Davis said the stockpile was “as dangerous as it gets in urban policing.”
“We have reason to believe, based upon the evidence that was found at that scene — the explosions, the explosive ordnance that was unexploded and the firepower that they had — that they were going to attack other individuals. That’s my belief at this point.” Davis told CBS’s “Face the Nation.”
On “Fox News Sunday,” he said authorities cannot be positive there aren’t more explosives that haven’t been found. But the people of Boston are safe, he insisted.
The move is part of a plan to reopen the area in phases.
On Sunday, a public interfaith memorial service was held on Boylston and Berkeley, near the marathon finish line:
The Associated Press reports:
Cambridge Police Commissioner Robert Haas tells The Associated Press in an interview Sunday that neither Tamerlan Tsarnaev nor his brother Dzhokhar had permission to carry firearms.
He says it’s unclear whether either ever applied and the applications aren’t considered public records.
But he says the 19-year-old Dzhokhar would have been denied a permit because of his age. Only people 21 or older are allowed gun licenses in Massachusetts.
Updated at 4:38 p.m.: Below are live updates from the press conference held at the Boston Fire Department on Boylston Street. See the city’s press release for more details about the reopening plan.
Updated at 4:16 p.m.: Boston Police Commissioner Davis: “We are satisfied there are no more explosive devices on Boylston Street.”
Updated at 4:12 p.m.: BPHC also offers a counseling hotline: 617-534-5050. Counselors will be available tonight until 6 p.m. and Monday through Friday, 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Updated at 4:11 p.m.: Dr. Barbara Ferrer of the Boston Public Health Commission says the BPHC has set up a special line for victims and immediate family members: 617-343-1373
Updated at 4:07 p.m.: Rene Fielding of Boston Emergency Management explained the five-phase plan:
- Phase 1: Biohazard and environmental testing
- Phase 2: Structural assessment and utility restotration (applies buildings directly in the blast area)
- Phase 3: Debris removal
- Phase 4: Limited reentry for business owners for internal building inspections
- Phase 5: Full public access and deployment of mobile City Gall on Dartmouth Street at St. James
Original post: Mayor Thomas Menino said there would be a the five-phase Copley Square re-entry plan, including environmental testing, building assessment and debris removal.
During a press conference at Mount Auburn hospital, Chief Paul MacMillan of the MBTA Transit Police said transit officer Richard Donohue opened his eyes, was able to move his legs and feet, and squeezed his wife’s hand on command.
Donohue was shot during the gunfire exchanged with the Tsarnaev brothers in Watertown early Friday morning.
Dr. David Millar of Mt. Auburn Hopsital said Donohue was in stable but critical condition.
“It’s early to say exactly what his status is going to be like in the next few days. We remain cautiously optimistic,” Millar said.
Donohue’s brother Edward offered hopeful words. “We will persevere and we will fight because we know no other way to live but free,” he said.
From a press release from One Fund Boston, the organization set up by the mayor and governor to help those affected by the marathon bombings:
Mayor Thomas M. Menino, Governor Deval L. Patrick, and One Fund Boston are calling upon Boston and all communities across the Commonwealth to join together in a Moment of Silence Monday afternoon, exactly one week following the Boston Marathon bombings.
The minute of silence will take place at 2:50 p.m. to honor the victims of the attacks and their families. It will be followed by the ringing of bells throughout Boston and the Commonwealth.
Mayor Menino and Governor Patrick are humbled by the support shown by the public and the business community, and they continue to encourage everyone to visit onefundboston.org to make a donation to help the victims of this tragedy.
Participants in New York Road Runners race at Central Park this morning wore “I run for Boston” signs on their backs twitter.com/ryansongalia/s…
— Ryan Songalia (@ryansongalia) April 21, 2013
The Associated Press reports:
Thousands of New Yorkers have shown their support for the victims of the Boston Marathon bombings in a four-mile run in Central Park.
Sunday’s Run for the Parks was already planned before the attacks Monday that killed three and injured scores.
Organizers sold “I Run for Boston” T-shirts with proceeds going to the One Fund Boston, the official fund for those affected by the bombing.
Dzhokhar Tsarnaev remains in serious condition at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, said the FBI.
In the meantime, interrogators are waiting to question him. CNN reports:
Authorities have not publicly detailed the injuries sustained by the teen, but an official who has been briefed said Tsarnaev has been “intubated and sedated.” The official also spoke on condition of anonymity.
Read the full story: Interrogators Wait To Question Bombing Suspect
Updated at 11:35 a.m.
The campus will reopen today at 12:00 p.m.
During the manhunt on Friday, UMass Dartmouth was evacuated.
One of our reporters visited the campus and spoke with a number of Dzhokhar Tsarnaev’s friends and classmates. Read/listen to what they had to say about him.
The Associated Press reports:
A defiant, festive mood prevailed at the London Marathon on Sunday as thousands of runners offered tributes to those killed and injured in Boston a week earlier. The race began after a moment of silence for the Boston victims, and many wore black armbands as a sign of solidarity. Police said they planned to add 40 percent more officers and extra surveillance as a precautionary measure.
The Associated Press reports:
At least 250 people gathered Saturday night in Watertown for a candlelight vigil for the victims of the Boston attacks. Attendees recited the Pledge of Allegiance and sang the national anthem, and some children released balloons into the air.
Updated at 6:06 p.m. with links and newer copy.
The Associated Press reports:
Massachusetts Gov. Deval Patrick said Saturday afternoon that Tsarnaev was in serious but stable condition and was probably unable to communicate. Tsarnaev was at Boston’s Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, where 11 victims of the bombing were still being treated.
“I, and I think all of the law enforcement officials, are hoping for a host of reasons the suspect survives,” the governor said after a ceremony at Fenway Park to honor the victims and survivors of the attack. “We have a million questions, and those questions need to be answered.”
Read the fully story: Boston Bomb Suspect Hospitalized Under Heavy Guard
The Associated Press reports:
The Obama administration has a range of legal options in the Boston Marathon bombings, and they could include seeking the death penalty against the 19-year-old suspect in the case.
The administration has indicated it intends to move quickly to build a criminal case against Dzhokhar Tsarnaev. But investigators plan to first question him without informing him of his legal rights to remain silent and have an attorney present.
Several Republican lawmakers on Saturday criticized the administration’s approach because it would afford Tsarnaev more rights than he deserves. The federal public defender for Massachusetts called for the quick appointment of a lawyer to represent Tsarnaev because of serious issues involving his interrogation in the absence of a lawyer.
Read the full story: Prosecutors Move Quickly To Build Marathon Case
Also, listen to our interview with Brad Bailey, Boston attorney who specializes in defending people accused of federal offenses, including terrorism:
And are you wondering about the interrogation itself? WBUR spoke with Glenn Carl, a former CIA interrogator about what to expect:
Watertown Police Chief Edward Deveau spoke with CNN on Saturday, sharing a vivid account of Friday’s early morning shooutout with the two bombing suspects and Friday night’s final capture of Dzhokhar Tsarnaev:
Just some of the ways Dzhokhar Tsarnaev’s friends described him:
“He was wicked nice. We would go hang out with him and watch soccer on TV. He was so normal.”
“I really liked this kid. He was nice. He was cool.”
“He was the outgoing kid, you know?”
Photos taken from State Police Air Wing on Watertown manhunt.Media, please credit MSP for pics. twitter.com/MassStatePolic…
— MASS STATE POLICE (@MassStatePolice) April 20, 2013
Air Wing views from Watertown manhunt. 5 total pics released.No further info available tonight on pictures twitter.com/MassStatePolic…
— MASS STATE POLICE (@MassStatePolice) April 20, 2013
Photos from State Police Air Wing on Watertown manhunt.Please credit MSP for pics.Unk which police agency in picture twitter.com/MassStatePolic…
— MASS STATE POLICE (@MassStatePolice) April 20, 2013
“Our home whites are a little different today. We are so proud to play for our city,” the Red Sox posted on Instagram, accompanying this photo.
And that’s not all:
The special Boston home white jerseys worn today will be auctioned off to benefit The One Fund Boston. #BostonStrong
— Boston Red Sox (@RedSox) April 20, 2013
The One Fund Boston was set up be Gov. Deval Patrick and Mayor Thomas Menino to raise funds for those affected by the marathon bombings.
The Red Sox play the Kansas City Royals sat 1:10 p.m. Saturday and Sunday at 1:35 p.m. and 7 p.m. — fans are asked to arrive early:
Tickets for last night’s game good for admission to tomorrow night’s 7:00 p.m. game.Fans asked to arrive a little earlier than usual.
— Boston Red Sox (@RedSox) April 20, 2013
Update at 11:33 a.m.: South Station was evacuated as Boston Police responded to a bomb threat. But the situation has now been cleared and the station reopened.
South station all clearReopened.
— MBTA Transit Police (@MBTATransitPD) April 20, 2013
BPD bomb squad responding to bomb threat at South Station.
— Boston Police Dept. (@Boston_Police) April 20, 2013
The following audio clip is from Friday’s late night press conference, during which Massachusetts U.S. Attorney Carmen Ortiz answered questions about Miranda rights being read to the suspect and pursuing the death penalty:
Male reporter: Reports tonight are that there was no Miranda warning given, that they were claiming the public safety exemption. Can we get an explanation for that?
Ortiz: There is a public safety exemption in cases of national security and potential charges involving acts of terrorism — and so government has that opportunity. Right now, though, I believe that the suspect has been taken to a hospital, so we’ll start with there.
Female reporter: Will you seek the federal death penalty?
Ortiz: You know, what I indicated earlier is that this is still an active, ongoing investigation. We’re going to be reviewing all of the evidence before that kind of a decision is made in terms of whether or not to seek the death penalty. You review all of the evidence and it’s a very thoughtful, long process that is engaged. And it’s the attorney general of the Department of Justice that makes the final decision.
A statement from the family of 8-year-old Martin Richard, who died in the Boston Marathon bombings:
Our family wishes to salute the thousands of officers and agents from the Boston, Cambridge and Watertown Police & Fire Departments, Massachusetts State Police, FBI, ATF, and other police departments and agencies who worked and collaborated around the clock to bring the perpetrators of Monday’s attack to justice. We also thank the citizens and businesses that shared images and footage with investigators in hopes of advancing the investigation.
It worked, and tonight, our community is once again safe from these two men.
None of this will bring our beloved Martin back, or reverse the injuries these men inflicted on our family and nearly two hundred others. We continue to pray for healing and for comfort on the long road that lies ahead for every victim and their loved ones.
Tonight, our family applauds the entire law enforcement community for a job well done, and trust that our justice system will now do its job.
“Tonight our nation is in debt to the people of Boston and of Massachusetts,” President Obama said in a statement from the White House following the capture of the marathon bombing’s Suspect 2.
He added: “We owe a tremendous debt of gratitude to all our law enforcement professionals.”
Obama mentioned the unanswered questions that have arisen since Monday, including why the two suspects allegedly committed the bombing and, if so, whether they had any associations.
“One thing we do know is that whatever hateful agenda drove these men to such heinous acts will not — cannot — prevail,” he said.
“All in all it’s been a tough week, but we’ve seen the character of our country once more.”
Watch the entire statement here.
A Watertown resident, outside on Franklin Street after authorities lifted the “stay indoors” order, saw blood on a boat in a backyard, lifted its tarp and found the suspect. He then called police.
According to Boston Police Commissioner Ed Davis, that’s how the manhunt for Dzhokar Tsarnaev ended tonight.
Davis revealed the detail in a media briefing after the capture of the at-large suspect. Authorities said the boat was not in their established search perimeter in Watertown, though they don’t believe the suspect went directly to the boat after he fled an exchange of gunfire he had with police in the early hours of the morning.
(Update at 10:35 p.m.: Authorities also mentioned that a helicopter using infrared technology picked up a heat signature of the suspect in the boat. It’s not immediately clear whether the resident’s call or the imaging came first.)
Some other details from the news conference:
— Davis said area citizens can be confident that there’s no further threat.
— He said a negotiator tried to talk with Tsarnaev, but the suspect was non-communicative. He’s in serious condition, Davis said, at an area hospital.
— Slain MIT Police Officer Sean Collier, he said, was “assassinated in his cruiser.”
— Davis said authorities always prefer to take suspects in custody in order to seek to obtain information from them.
Earlier in the briefing, officials including Gov. Deval Patrick, Boston Mayor Thomas Menino and State Police Col. Timothy Alben expressed thanks to law enforcement officers and the public for their efforts and patience during the manhunt.
“We’re exhausted folks,” Alben said, “but we have a victory here tonight.”
After a violent, nearly 24-hour manhunt that effectively locked down Greater Boston, Dzhokar Tsarnaev, Suspect 2 from the Boston Marathon bombings, is in police custody.
The final standoff occurred in the backyard of a residence on Franklin Street in Watertown. According to WBUR’s Fred Thys, the 19-year-old suspect was bloodied when taken into custody and is on his way to an area hospital.
Confirmation of custody was preceded by cheers that could be heard in the neighborhood in Watertown. Boston Police tweeted: “CAPTURED!!! The hunt is over. The search is done. The terror is over. And justice has won. Suspect in custody.” Boston Mayor Thomas Menino, who hopped on the scanner to thank police after Tsarnaev’s capture, tweeted: “We got him.”
BPD soon followed up with another tweet: “In our time of rejoicing, let us not forget the families of Martin Richard, Lingzi Lu, Krystle Campbell and Officer Sean Collier.”
Those are the three fatalities of the marathon bombings and the MIT officer who was fatally shot late last night, beginning the nearly 24-hour manhunt.
Authorities have scheduled a 9:30 p.m. news conference.
Update 8:43 p.m.: Cheering heard moments ago as we interviewed WBUR reporter Bruce Gellerman in Watertown.
Update 8:41 p.m.: WBUR’s David Boeri reports a source tells him a police helicopter with an infrared camera detected movement in the boat and that law enforcement are communicating with the suspect to come out alive.
Update 8:26 p.m.: Associated Press is now also reporting the bombing suspect is in a boat being stored behind a home in Watertown:
BREAKING: Law enforcement official: Bombing suspect in boat stored in Watertown, Mass., neighborhood.
— The Associated Press (@AP) April 20, 2013
Update 7:45 p.m.: This just in from NPR:
An FBI source tells NPR’s Dina Temple-Raston that police have located the suspect.
She tells us:
“Officers are proceeding with caution as an official fears the suspect may have booby-trapped the scene.
“FBI is waiting for a tactical team and bomb technician.
“FBI is behaving as if the suspect is still alive.”
More From Boston Police:
Police operations in the Franklin Street Watertown area. Residents shelter in place.
— Boston Police Dept. (@Boston_Police) April 19, 2013
Update 7:12 p.m.: More from AP:
BREAKING: Gunshots heard in Watertown, Mass.; emergency and military vehicles drive through town.
— The Associated Press (@AP) April 19, 2013
Update 7:01 p.m.:
.@curtnickisch says shots fired. Very limited information. Very rapid law enforcement response.
— Meghna Chakrabarti (@MeghnaWBUR) April 19, 2013
A BU School of Communications graduate magazine called “The Comment” ran a 2010 photo essay of now-deceased Boston Marathon bombing suspect Tamerlan Tsarnaev, called “Will Box For Passport” (Page 10 of the PDF).
“Tamerlan Tsarnaev is a boxer from Chechnya who currently trains at the Wai Kru Mixed Martial Arts Center in Boston, Massachusetts. Tsarnaev enters national Golden Gloves competitions in hopes that he might be selected for the next U.S. Olympic team and become a naturalized American.”
More from The Boston Globe.
In the chaos of a large and violent firefight Thursday night in Watertown, Massachusetts State Police say they were unable to establish a perimeter and marathon bombing suspect Dzhokhar Tsarnaev fled on foot and remains at large.
State Police Col. Timothy Alben said during a press briefing that because all of the suspect’s ties are to Massachusetts, he believes Tsarnaev is still in the state. Despite this, officials have lifted a shelter-in-place order.
“We feel it is prudent to be able to say to people that you can get back out as long as you stay vigilant,” Gov. Deval Patrick said during the briefing.
MBTA subway, trolley and bus service has also been restored. The MBTA says ferry, commuter rail and The Ride service will resume Saturday.
“We cannot continue to lock down an entire city or an entire state” while we look for the suspect, Col. Alben said. “We are redoubling our efforts and are as committed as we were [Friday] morning to apprehending him.”
State Police say they will provide extra patrols throughout the town of Watertown through at least Monday.
Our live updates from the briefing are below:
Update 6:22 p.m.: Officials say this was the last briefing of the night barring any major developments.
Update 6:20 p.m.:
In describing how suspect got away last night, Alben says he abandoned a car, fled on foot, but doesn’t know where suspect went after that.
— WBUR (@WBUR) April 19, 2013
Update 6:18 p.m.: “We cannot continue to lock down an entire city or an entire state” while we look for him, Col. Alben says. “We are redoubling our efforts and are as committed as we were this morning to apprehending him.”
Update 6:15 p.m.: Col. Alben says all of the suspect’s ties are to Massachusetts and he believes he is still in the state.
Update 6:14 p.m.: Gov. Patrick: “We feel it is prudent to be able to say to people that you can get back out as long as you stay vigilant.”
Update 6:12 p.m.:
Mayor Menino thanks citizens for cooperation and thanks the business community; “together we’re going to get through this crisis,” he says
— WBUR (@WBUR) April 19, 2013
Update 6:10 p.m.: Col. Alben reminds residents that if they believe they see the suspect not to take action on their own and to immediately call police.
Update 6:08 p.m.: Gov. Patrick says shelter-in-place request has been lifted, but asks public to remain vigilant. MBTA service to resume immediately.
Update 6:05 p.m.: Mass State Police Col. Alben says the second suspect has not been apprehended. Officials are drawing back tactical teams, with State Police providing extra patrols throughout Watertown through at least Monday.
The Massachusetts State Police are releasing more details on evidence they recovered at the scene in Watertown.
According to a statement from State Police spokesman David Procopio, evidence includes “homemade explosives, including pipe bombs and another pressure cooker, as well as more than 200 spent rounds.”
The statement goes on to say the crime scene on Norfolk Street in Cambridge is now clear, and that the planned, controlled detonation that police had told the public to expect did not happen.
“We thought a car there might have an explosive but it did not,” the statement said. “Not commenting on what, if anything, found there.”
State Police say they have established that the bombing suspects were not the ones who robbed a convenience store in Cambridge, as had earlier been reported.
A statement from State Police spokesperson Dave Procopio says “the bombers did purchase gas at a gas station in Cambridge later in the chain of events and we recovered images of them there.”
OFFICIAL: Tonight’s Red Sox game at Fenway Park scheduled for 7:10pm has been postponed to support efforts of law enforcement officers.
— Boston Red Sox (@RedSox) April 19, 2013
Tonight’s Bruins/Penguins game has been postponed and tentatively rescheduled for 4/20 at 12:30 p.m. bbru.in/104vv8v ^BB
— Boston Bruins (@NHLBruins) April 19, 2013
From WBUR’s Lisa Tobin:
When Adhi Moro heard that his longtime friends, Dzhokhar and Tamerlan Tsarnaev, were the suspects in the Boston Marathon bombings, he headed to Watertown to speak with the hordes of reporters desperate to understand who these brothers were and why they might have committed such heinous acts.
WBUR’s Carey Goldberg has translated more reports from Russia’s Izvestia newspaper:
An Izvestia correspondent managed to ask Anzor Tsarnaev the father of Tamerlan and Dzhokhar, the Boston terrorism suspects, a few questions.
The father of the Tsarnaev brothers, who has been living for several years in Dagestan, is sure that his sons are not involved in the bloody events that occurred a few days ago in Boston in the USA. The older son, Tamerlan, in his words, is happily married — he was raising a daughter with his American wife. And the younger, Dzhokhar, is an excellent student and the pride of the family. Anzor Tsarnaev, having lost one son, is afraid the special forces will kill the second as well.
-My children were simply set up. They killed one — how could they? They’re special forces. They should just have arrested him. Now I’m afraid for the second. I’m always in touch with them. Yes, I live far, but I know what my kids are doing.
When did you last speak with your sons?
-With Tamerlan. right after the terrorist act in Boston. As soon as I saw it on TV, the horror that happened there, I immediately called the older’s phone number, and asked: Were you there? Are you okay? He answered: Papa, don’t worry. We didn’t go there. All are alive and healthy.
When did you last see your son?
About a year ago. But we phoned each other all the time. They told me about themselves, I know what my kids are up to. The oldest is a boxer, four-time champion of America according to one version. Everyone in the USA knows him, he’s famous. Tamerlan is also a musician, plays jazz piano. He once wanted to be a pro boxer, but we talked him out of it, saying it would be constant traumas, why do you need this? And then he got married, and his daughter was born, and now she’s 3-1/2. And he himself changed his mind about becoming a professional.
Did he work somewhere?
-No, he studied in an acting school and took care of the child. His wife worked. In some social institution — I forget what it’s called — taking care of invalids. My son had absolutely no free time. Every hour was full.
And Dzhokhar? When did you speak with him?
-Three days ago. I called and asked him how things were and told him that he needed to come here for school vacation. He agreed, asked me to get him a visa. He was only a child the last time he was here, since we left he hasn’t returned even once. I didn’t speak with him long. He was rushing to school.
He went to school in Cambridge?
-Yes, yes, my youngest was the pride of the family. He only ever got A’s, dreamed of becoming a great doctor. He got a grant for his studies, as the most talented. He never participated in any radical groups, he hates chatterboxes. Of course, he had problems with money. But I helped him, sent him a little, and he worked. When his time was free from his studies, he worked as a lifeguard in a pool. He didn’t have time for nonsense. And also, he couldn’t go against the will of Tamerlan, and his older brother would not let him get involved in such things.
Why did you yourself leave the USA?
-I returned to the motherland to die. I had a brain hematoma. I was sure that this was the end. But here I managed to wiggle out of it, right from the grave. And my sons remained there.
Did they become US citizens?
-No, they’re both citizens of Russia. Tamerlan’s wife is American, but he’s a Russian. Dzhokhar too. I’m afraid for my second son. I’m afraid that he’ll be killed too. But I know he’s guilty of nothing.
Police tweeted that they have the green Honda Civic, and that earlier statements that suspects were in CRV before last night’s car jacking were incorrect:
Media reporting we are looking for a Honda Civic reg 116GC7, please note that we have that car. We are not looking for it. BOLO recalled
— MASS STATE POLICE (@MassStatePolice) April 19, 2013
Media–earlier reports, statements that suspects were in Honda CRV before carjacking were incorrect. They were in the Honda Civic.
— MASS STATE POLICE (@MassStatePolice) April 19, 2013
We apologize for the confusion. Wrong model of Honda. Suspects were in Civic, not CRV. Sorry, it has been a fast-moving day.
— MASS STATE POLICE (@MassStatePolice) April 19, 2013
In violent series of events overnight that began with a robbery, the fatal shooting of a MIT police officer and a stolen car chase, police officers traced Boston marathon bombing suspects from Cambridge to Watertown, amid reports of further gunfire and explosions. During the chase, one suspect was killed, according to police, and a second remains at large.
Here’s a timeline of how things developed overnight on social media: http://www.wbur.org/2013/04/19/timeline-manhunt-for-boston-marathon-bombing-suspects and a summary of events from NPR: http://www.wbur.org/npr/177923309/a-timeline-of-the-boston-manhunt
Events started to unfold last night at 10:20 p.m., when reports of a robbery at a convenience store near MIT came in. Approximately 10 minutes later, MIT police officer Sean Collier, 26, was found shot in his vehicle. He was later pronounced dead at MGH.
Read the rest of the timeline of how events unfolded overnight here.
“Sean was one of these guys who really looked at police work as a calling,” said MIT Police Chief John DiFava of Sean Collier, 26, who was fatally shot last night. “He was born to be a police officer.”
WBUR’s Fred Thys captured this photo of the black bunting going up outside the MIT Police headquarters:
Collier’s family released this statement:
We are heartbroken by the loss of our wonderful and caring son and brother, Sean Collier. Our only solace is that Sean died bravely doing what he committed his life to – serving and protecting others. We are thankful for the outpouring of support and condolences offered by so many people. We are grieving his loss and ask that the media respect our privacy at this time.
MEMA’s Kurt Schwartz just told those still at work are not expected to stay there:
Shelter in place remains for affected area, but it does not prevent employees from returning home.
— MEMA (@MassEMA) April 19, 2013
Schwartz reminded residents that MBTA service remains suspended, but cab service is up and running.
WBUR’s Sacha Pfeiffer reports:
Fifteen police officers were taken to the emergency room at St. Elizabeth’s Hospital in Brighton early Friday morning for “injuries sustained in last night’s police activity” related to the marathon bombing investigation, according to the hospital.
Hospital spokesman Chris Murphy describes their wounds as primarily “musculoskeletal,” such as “abrasions, bruises, strains, sprains and fall injuries.”
All the officers were treated and the majority have been discharged, although some of them are still being evaluated and treated in the emergency department, according to Murphy. He says the hospital expects all the officers to be discharged by the end of the day Friday.
Murphy did not know exactly how the officers were wounded, but said “my understanding is they were injured in activity related to the apprehension and chase of the suspects in the marathon bombing.” He did not know which police departments the officers were affiliated with and said official confirmation of the officers’ exact activities at the time of their injuries should be confirmed by “somebody with the police department.”
WBUR contacted several local police departments for more information on the numbers and received the following information:
- Boston Police Department: no information available
- Belmont Police Department: no officers injured
- Waltham Police Department: no officers believed injured
We are waiting for more information from Cambridge, Newton and Watertown.
More from WBUR’s Carey Goldberg:
Business Insider has posted an Instagram statement from Chechen leader Ramzan Kadyrov. Like the uncle of the accused Tsarnaev brothers, he seems to be saying, “Don’t blame Chechnya.” Unlike the uncle, he also points the finger at America. Full translation of the statement here.
The uncle of Boston Marathon bombing suspect today urged his nephew to turn himself in:
The Associated Press reports:
Ruslan Tsarni of Montgomery Village, Md., said that 19-year-old Dzhozkar Tsarnaev should turn himself in to police and ask for forgiveness.
He says the family is ashamed. He says he loves the U.S. and respects this country.
WBUR’s Carey Goldberg — a former L.A. Times Moscow correspondent — has translated reports from a major Russian newspaper, here’s a sampling:
From the major Russian newspaper Izvestia: Izvestia has learned that the suspect in the Boston terrorist acts, Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, did come to America from Makhachala. But up until age seven he lived in Kirghizia and you can only call him Russian with a big stretch — in Dagestan, Tsarnaev lived only a year. Tsarnaev hid from the police, but he was noticed in a Boston house, and the SWAT teams have already surrounded it and are preparing to storm it.
Editor’s note: We’ve removed the live stream from this post. Listen to our live coverage here.
Highlights from the 12:30 p.m. press briefing:
Update 12:37 p.m.: State Police say they have covered 60 to 70 percent of the neighborhood they are searching in Watertown, but no one has been apprehended yet.
Police also warned that a controlled explosion will happen — “out of an abundance of caution” — on Norfolk Street in Cambridge this afternoon, the street where the suspect lived.
Update 12:36 p.m.: Mayor Menino: “We are a city that is not going to let a terrorist win … We’re going to get through this, we’re going to be a stronger city.”
Update 12:35 p.m.: Gov. Patrick reiterating warning to stay inside and not to open your door unless a uniformed police officer is on the other side.
From WBUR’s CommonHealth:
Dr. Beresin, director of the Massachusetts General Hospital Center for Mental Health and Media and his colleague Steven Schlozman, MD, assistant professor of psychiatry at Harvard Medical School and a staff child psychiatrist at Massachusetts General Hospital offer some more timely advice. This piece is for edgy parents at home with their kids in lockdown mode today (basically all of us) as police undertake a massive manhunt to apprehend the Boston Marathon bomber.
–To the extent that you can, turn off the TV, computers and radio. Of course, you’ll also need to hear about the events as they unfold, so when you check in on the news, be sure your kids, particularly the young ones are not within ear or eyeshot
–Contact relatives, neighbors and friends to be sure they are safe and to let them know that you are OK. Contact matters now. The traumatic effects that follow are often caused by lack of communication.
This afternoon, the BPD issued a statement saying they were seeking a gray 1999 Honda CRV, which was quickly recovered in Boston:
UPDATE: Vehicle (MA Plate: 316-ES9) found unoccupied. Car being processed for evidence by authorities. twitter.com/Boston_Police/…
— Boston Police Dept. (@Boston_Police) April 19, 2013
The Associated Press reports that State Police believe the suspects spent the night in the CRV and used it hijack a Mercedes before leading police on a chase to Watertown:
[Police] say one brother drove away in the CRV, and the other one drove away in the Mercedes.
Police say one then ditched the CRV and reunited with his brother in the Mercedes. Authorities say both suspects were in the Mercedes when they encountered police and hurled explosives at officers.
The Associated Press reports:
The Boston Marathon bombing suspect who was killed overnight had studied accounting as a part-time community college student.
Bunker Hill Community College officials say that 26-year-old Tamerlan Tsarnaev was a student there for three semesters: fall 2006, spring 2007 and fall 2008.
Spokeswoman Patricia Brady said Friday they had little information on Tsarnaev other than that he studied accounting at the Boston school.
The list of communities that officials are asking to stay inside includes:
- All of Boston
Somerville is not on the state list, but is also asking residents to stay inside.
Robin Young, host of WBUR’s Here & Now, realized during Friday morning’s manhunt that the sought-after suspect, Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, was a close friend of her nephew and had once visited her home when the boys were in high school. Full story here. More on Robin Young’s Twitter feed.
My beloved nephew on right, djohar tsarnaev on left, happy cambridge Rindge and Latin grads.heartbreaking twitter.com/hereandnowrobi…
— Robin Young (@hereandnowrobin) April 19, 2013
At least one website has suspended its live stream of Boston Police scanners. The Boston Police Department has made several of these requests, due to concern that the locations of officers will be compromised as the manhunt continues. Earlier, the BPD tweeted:
#MediaAlert: WARNING: Do Not Compromise Officer Safety by Broadcasting Tactical Positions of Homes Being Searched.
— Boston Police Dept. (@Boston_Police) April 19, 2013
In a chaotic, violent overnight that began with a robbery, the fatal shooting of a MIT police officer and a stolen car chase, police officers traced Boston marathon bombing suspects from Cambridge to Watertown, amid reports of further gunfire and explosions. Here’s one of the first early tweets from the night:
Cambridge armed robbery of a 7-11 store area of 32 Vassar St suspect fled shot 6 rounds possibly an MIT officer shot transported to mgh.
— Mike Spinazola (@FireSafeCorp) April 19, 2013
WBUR’s Nate Goldman produced this timeline of the events.
In this video sent to WBUR from a listener, police move down a Watertown street during the manhunt for the second suspect in the Boston Marathon bombings. The video was taken overlooking the intersection of Mount Auburn Street and School Street:
Authorities have issued this poster with the at-large suspect, Dzhokhar A. Tsarnaev, 19, of Cambridge:
Boston University just sent this message to students and staff:
The University is closed and classes are cancelled today. Please stay inside and avoid windows. Be attentive to news developments. BU police will be patrolling the campus and monitoring the situation. Updates will follow as information becomes available. Please monitor BU Today at bu.edu/today
We’re getting this live blog back up and running. We’ve been covering the developments overnight here, and will continue to update both that post and this live blog.
The latest updates come from the Associated Press, with two tweets on potential details on the alleged bombers:
AP sources: Boston bomb suspects from Russia region near Chechnya, lived in US at least 1 year.
Surviving Boston bomb suspect identified as Dzhokhar A. Tsarnaev, 19, of Cambridge, Mass.
WBUR has not confirmed the AP details.
Because it began with the fatal shooting of an MIT officer, the post was not started in this blog, but massive developments in this evolving story: “Boston Police: 1 Suspect Dead, ‘White Hat Suspect At Large’ “
Residents in and around Watertown should stay in their residences. Do NOT answer door unless it is an identified police officer.
— MASS STATE POLICE (@MassStatePolice) April 19, 2013
Update at 5:30 a.m.: More:
#CommunityAdvisory: Businesses in area of 480 Arsenal St in Watertown closed til furher notice. Employees instructed to remain home.
— Boston Police Dept. (@Boston_Police) April 19, 2013
The FBI has released photos and a video of “Suspect 1″ and “Suspect 2,” who are sought in connection with the deadly Boston Marathon bombing.
The photos, which came from surveillance cameras near the explosion sites, show Suspect 1 (wearing a dark baseball cap) and Suspect 2 (wearing a white baseball cap backward).
According to the FBI’s Richard DesLauriers, Suspect 2, with the white hat, is seen setting down a backpack at a blast site.
In a media briefing, DesLauriers made the point that the photos just released by the FBI are the only ones the public should currently rely on.
The suspects are considered armed and extremely dangerous, DesLauriers said. “Do not take any action on your own,” he said.
The FBI also has a new website for tips: bostonmarathontips.fbi.gov
Scroll down this post for all the photos and the video.
At 6:15 p.m., we rewrote this post and added all the images and the video. We also changed the post’s original timestamp so it would appear atop this blog. The briefing began at 5 p.m., but the post was published earlier in the afternoon, in anticipation of the briefing.
Gov. Deval Patrick has filed a bill with the Legislature that would:
— create a $5 million reserve fund to cover state response costs associated with the marathon bombing,
— and add $1.5 million to the Massachusetts National Guard’s budget.
Several hundred guardsmen were called up and sent to Boston after the attack.
The reserve funds would be available on request by the Patrick administration.
The House and Senate are expected to pass the legislation today.
Update at 7:11 p.m.: It’s down to six now, according to the AP.
The Associated Press reports:
Boston hospitals reported seven people in critical condition on Thursday, down from 14 on Wednesday.
A 5-year-old boy being treated at Boston Medical Center is one of the patients taken off the critical list.
According to WBUR’s Martha Bebinger, a total of 188 people have been treated at 14 hospitals after the marathon bombings. Most were released by Thursday.
She also reports that there have been 13 confirmed amputations.
Immediately after the interfaith memorial service for victims, President Obama, Gov. Patrick and Mayor Menino met with marathon volunteers in the Cathedral High School gym.
According to Politico, Obama told volunteers, “All of you displayed the very best of the American spirit; you displayed grit, you displayed courage. When we see that kind of spirit, …there’s something about that that’s infectious… You’ve inspired an entire country. You’ve inspired the entire world.”
Next, President Obama will go to Mass General Hospital where he plans to meet with victims and families.
“Your resolve is the greatest rebuke to whoever committed this heinous act,” President Obama (see his remarks) said to a packed Cathedral of the Holy Cross during an interfaith “Heal Our City” service, held in the aftermath of Monday’s Boston Marathon bombing.
Obama said he was in Boston on behalf of the American people “with a simple message: Every one of us has been touched by this attack on your beloved city,” he said. “Every one of us stands with you. After all, it is our beloved city, too. Boston may be your hometown, but we claim it, too.”
The president touted Boston’s stature in history and academia and stressed his own ties to the city, citing his time as a Harvard Law School student. “There is a piece of Boston in me,” he said.
Obama remembered each of the three victims killed in the twin blasts, and, to the wounded, pledged: “We will all be with you as you learn to stand and walk and run again. Of that, I have no doubt. You will run again.”
“A bomb can’t beat us,” Obama said toward closing. “We will keep going … we will finish the race.”
The president followed Gov. Deval Patrick and Boston Mayor Thomas Menino in an interfaith service (see the program) that featured reflections from several members of Boston’s faith community. The Boston Children’s Chorus and cellist Yo-Yo Ma also performed.
Patrick (see his remarks) said the Scripture he follows taught him to always give thanks — something he said that wasn’t easy for him on Monday.
But after time, he said he realized there was plenty to be thankful for: first responders, civilians who assisted victims, volunteers.
Citing Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., Patrick said: “In a dark hour, so many of you showed so many of us that darkness cannot drive out darkness; as Dr. King said, ‘Only light can do that.’ ”
A resolute Menino, who stood to speak despite a broken leg, said: “Since the clock struck that fateful hour, love has covered this resilient city.”
This post was updated after the service. See below for our live-blogged updates:
Update 12:40 p.m.: NPR’s Ari Shapiro tweets that moments after the ceremony President Obama met with marathon volunteers:
Now in Cathedral High School gym, across the street from the service, full of marathon volunteers. Obama walks in to cheers.
— Ari Shapiro (@arishapiro) April 18, 2013
Update 12:30 p.m.: The ceremony ended with a closing blessing from Cardinal O’Malley.
Update 12:22 p.m.: In quoting, Dick Hoyt, who has pushed his disabled son in 31 Boston Marathons, Obama says, “We can’t let something like this stop us.”
“And that’s what you’ve taught us Boston, that’s what you’ve reminded us. To push on, to persevere. To not grow weary, to not get faint. Even when it hurts, even when our heart aches, we summon the strength that maybe we didn’t even know we had. And we carry on, we finish the race.”
Update 12:18 p.m.: President Obama: “Yes, we will find you. And yes, you will face justice … But more than that, our fidelity to our way of life, to our free and open society, will only grow stronger. For God has not given us a spirit of fear and timidity, but of power, love and self-discipline.”
Update 12:15 p.m.: Speaking to the victims, President Obama said, “As you begin this long journey of recovery, your city is with you, your commonwealth is with you, your country is with you. We will all be with you as you learn to stand and walk and run again. Of that, I have no doubt: You will run again. Because that is what Boston is made of.”
Update 12:12 p.m.: Referring to his time in law school, Obama said, “There’s a piece of Boston in me.”
“Like you, Michelle and I have walked these streets. Like you, we know these neighborhoods. Like you, in this moment of grief, we join you in saying, ‘Boston, you are my home.’ ”
Update 12:08 p.m.: President Obama said he’s in Boston today on behalf of the American people “with a simple message”:
“Every one of us has been touched by this attack on your beloved city. Every one of us stands with you. After all, it is our beloved city, too. Boston may be your hometown, but we claim it, too. It’s one of America’s iconic cities, it’s one of the world’s greats cities.”
Update 12:03 p.m.: Gov. Deval Patrick says the scripture he follows taught him to always give thanks, something he says wasn’t easy for him on Monday.
But after time, he says he realized there was plenty to be thankful for: first responders, civilians who assisted victims, volunteers. His thanks to Boston Mayor Thomas Menino was followed by applause by those gathered in the church.
“In a dark hour, so many of you showed so many of us that darkness cannot drive out darkness, as Dr. King said, only light can do that.”
“Let us not lose touch with our civic faith,” Gov. Patrick said. “Massachusetts invented America.”
Update 11:53 a.m.: After the musical selection by Yo-Yo Ma, Gov. Deval Patrick will speak, followed by President Obama.
Update 11:52 a.m.: Boston Cardinal Sean O’Malley says Monday’s act of violence is a “stark reminder of the darkness that can lurk in the human heart.”
“But the generous and courageous response of so many assures us there resides in peoples’ hearts a goodness that is incredibly selfless.”
He added that in the face of such tragedy, we must ask ourselves: What kind of community do we want to be?
Update 11:44 a.m.: Bishop John Borders III, of the Morning Star Baptist Church in Mattapan, reads from Matthew 5:1-12.
He added: “The Massachusetts license plate says, ‘The Spirit of America.’ And I pray the world right now, today, at this moment, will look at us and see the true spirit of America.”
Update 11:36 a.m.: In his reflection, Rev. Roberto Miranda, of the Congregacion Leon De Juda in Roxbury, emphasized that “in the end, goodness will always prevail … Weeping may stay for the night, but joy comes in the morning.”
Update 11:30 a.m.: Nasser Wedaddy, chair of the New England Interfaith Council and director of the American Islamic Council, says, “What happened on Monday has shocked and horrified us, but has also brought us together.”
Nasser Wedaddy, American Islamic Congress, once experienced a car bomb in Damascus: whoever saves a life it is as if he saved all mankind
— Frederic Thys (@fredthys) April 18, 2013
Update 11:24 a.m.: Rabbi Ronne Friedman, of Temple Israel, offers his words not only to those affected by the Boston Marathon bombing, but also by today’s fire and explosion at a fertilizer plant in Texas.
“Our arms are wide enough to hold you in hearts as well,” he said.
Update 11:20 a.m.: The Rev. Nancy Taylor, senior minister of the Old South Church, located just a block from where the bombs went off, remembers what she saw that day: people running towards the scene to help victims.
“A person’s hate will not make of us hater,” she said.
Update 11:15 a.m. Menino, who has been in a wheelchair and cast since he underwent surgery last week to repair a fracture in his leg, stood up at the podium to deliver his address.
“Even with the smell of smoke in the air, blood on the streets and tears in our eyes, we triumphed over that hateful act Monday afternoon,” he said. “It’s a glorious thing, the love and the strength that covers our city. It will push us forward.”
Update 11:10 a.m.: Boston Mayor Thomas Menino is speaking. He said since Monday, “Love has covered this resilient city. I have never loved it and its people more than I do today.”
He went on to commend those who rushed to help the injured in the seconds after the bombs went off. “[It showed] the courage of our city of work,” Menino said.
Update 10:55 a.m.: President Obama and first lady Michelle Obama have arrived.
Our original post continues:
People are filing into the the Cathedral of the Holy Cross in Boston’s South End, some who lined up before dawn, for the memorial service to honor the victim’s of Monday’s bombings at the finish line of the Boston Marathon.
WBUR’s Jesse Costa snapped this photo outside the Cathedral of the Holy Cross in Boston’s South End this morning:
The Associated Press reports people lined up as early as 5 a.m. to get into the church for an interfaith service to remember the victims of the Boston Marathon bombings, which President Obama and first lady Michele Obama are scheduled to attend.
President Obama has signed an emergency declaration for the state of Massachusetts — a move that frees up federal funding to help with crisis management.
The move will also allow the Department of Homeland Security and Federal Emergency Management Agency to coordinate response and recovery efforts in the wake of Monday’s bombings.
The president and first lady Michelle Obama will be in Boston today for an interfaith service honoring the victims.
Yesterday, several media outlets, including WBUR, reported that authorities had a suspect in custody, but those reports were denied by federal officials.
Investigators are said to be focusing on the image of a man seen on surveillance footage dropping off a bag and then walking away from the site of the second explosion.
Boston City Council President Stephen Murphy, who said he was briefed by Boston police, says the man seen on the footage matches witness descriptions:
The public is invited to tomorrow morning’s “Healing Our City: An Interfaith Service” at the Cathedral of the Holy Cross in Boston, according to a statement from the governor’s office.
The service, the statement says, “is an opportunity for the community to come together in the wake of the tragic events at the Boston Marathon this week.” President Obama will also attend.
The service will begin at 11 a.m., and doors to the service will open at 8 a.m. Tickets are on a first-come, first-serve basis. The statement details:
Guests should be prepared for airport-like security, and are advised to plan accordingly for lines and delays. Guests are asked to bring as few personal items as possible. No bags, sharp objects, liquids or signs will be allowed in the venue. Please access the entrance at Washington Street and Monsignor Reynolds Way from the north and west.
The public is highly encouraged to take public transportation, since both parking and road service in the area will be extremely limited. The Cathedral of the Holy Cross is located at 1400 Washington Street in Boston.
As of 3 p.m., the Boston Police Department reopened more streets surrounding the crime scene:
Belvidere Street and Dalton Street will be opened to the public. This will allow access to the hotels in the area. Also, Boylston Street will be opened between Massachusetts Avenue and Hereford. Hereford will also be open. Clarendon Street will continue to be open across Boylston but no turns will be allowed on to Boylston.
Here’s a map of the update closures:
Update at 7:52 p.m.: The FBI adds in a statement: “At this time, Thursday’s press briefing has not been scheduled.”
So we’ll conclude this post for the evening.
Update at 7:30 p.m.: A quick update:
FBI has cancelled the 8pm briefing tonight.
— Boston Police Dept. (@Boston_Police) April 17, 2013
Update at 7:25 p.m. The FBI will make a brief statement at 8 p.m., Boston Police says. We’ll detail it here once it happens.
Update at 7:15 p.m.: Still no official word on a briefing tonight.
Relatedly, the AP has spoken with Boston City Council President Stephen Murphy, who said investigators have a department-store surveillance-camera image of a man dropping off a bag at the scene of the one of the blasts.
Update at 6:30: We’ve been told by authorities that they expect to hold the postponed briefing this evening, but no set time has been given. While we wait, our latest posts:
Update at 4:30 p.m.: A briefing by federal authorities, scheduled for 5 p.m., has been postponed. According to a statement from the U.S. attorney’s office, it “has been postponed in light of today’s events at the Moakley Courthouse.”
There’s no word on when the briefing will be held.
Update at 4:05 p.m.: An editor’s note:
Editor’s note: This afternoon, multiple news organizations, including WBUR, reported that a suspect in the Boston bombing investigation had been taken into custody and arrested. On WBUR’s air, we reported that sources had told WBUR a suspect had been arrested. Within the hour, several of the news organizations retracted their initial reports, and the Boston Police Department, U.S. attorney’s office and the FBI all issued statements saying no one was arrested or in custody.
Update at 3:29 p.m.: On our air, WBUR’s David Boeri, from outside the evacuated Boston courthouse: “On a confusing day, this is still more confusing.”
Update at 3:21 p.m.: Following the U.S. attorney’s office, the FBI releases this statement:
Contrary to widespread reporting, no arrest has been made in connection with the Boston Marathon attack. Over the past day and a half, there have been a number of press reports based on information from unofficial sources that has been inaccurate. Since these stories often have unintended consequences, we ask the media, particularly at this early stage of the investigation, to exercise caution and attempt to verify information through appropriate official channels before reporting.
Update at 3:12 p.m.: Boston federal courthouse is being evacuated:
Homeland security agent confirms evacuation is because of a received bomb threat
— Joe Spurr (@joespurr) April 17, 2013
Update at 2:45 p.m.: WBUR’s Tom Melville just spoke with a spokeswoman for U.S. Attorney Carmen Ortiz, who told him: “No arrest, no one in custody.”
Update at 2:37 p.m.: Boston Police tweets:
Despite reports to the contrary there has not been an arrest in the Marathon attack.
— Boston Police Dept. (@Boston_Police) April 17, 2013
Update at 2:28 p.m.: NPR News reports no arrests yet.
Update at 2:22 p.m.: WBUR’s David Boeri is in Boston federal court and is awaiting developments there. Listen to WBUR-FM special coverage here.
Update at 2:12 p.m.: It’s worth noting that while several outlets, including the AP, are saying an arrest has been made, other outlets, including NBC and CBS, are not confirming an arrest has been made.
Update at 2:05 p.m.: The Associated Press says the suspect is now in custody.
Update at 1:58 p.m.: The AP has a full story now: “Official: Arrest Imminent In Marathon Bombing”
Update at 1:42 p.m.: The Associated Press reports:
BREAKING: Law enforcement official: Arrest imminent in Boston Marathon bombing, suspect to be brought to court.
— The Associated Press (@AP) April 17, 2013
The Boston Globe breaks:
An official briefed on the Boston Marathon bombing investigation said today that authorities have an image of a suspect carrying, and perhaps dropping, a black bag at the second bombing scene on Boylston Street, outside of the Forum restaurant.
The Globe adds: “Investigators are ‘very close’ in the investigation, said the official, who declined to be named.”
Similarly, CNN is reporting authorities believe they have identified a suspect in the marathon bombings.
WBUR’s David Boeri is seeking confirmation, and we’ll update when we have independent information.
The Associated Press’ latest on the investigation:
Authorities investigating the deadly bombings at the Boston Marathon have recovered a piece of circuit board that they believe was part of one of the explosive devices, and also found the lid of a pressure cooker that apparently was catapulted onto the roof of a nearby building, an official said Wednesday.
The full report is here.
NPR’s Alix Spiegel spoke with Jeff Greenberg, a psychologist at the University of Arizona who studies how people consciously and unconsciously respond to events that force them to face their own mortality.
“The thoughts of our mortality tend to linger outside of our conscious attention but still affect us,” Greenberg says.
Spiegel’s report goes on:
The idea of our own death, Greenberg says, is incredibly challenging, and often our response follows a kind of predictable psychological script. There’s the horror we feel as we watch the event unfold, but with it, there’s a quiet assessment: How vulnerable are we?
That happens, Greenberg says, “generally in sort of a biased way to try to deny your vulnerability.”
What Greenberg says is really interesting is how events like these affect us “after they’ve left the front page and our conscious minds.”
There were a number of vigils held throughout Boston last night, including at the Arlington Street Church, just blocks from the Boston Marathon finish line where two bombs exploded Monday afternoon.
Dominick Reuter captured this photo and more from the vigil last night.
As we reported earlier, hundreds gathered on the Boston Common for a separate vigil, and at Garvey Playground in Dorchester last night, hundreds more came together to remember 8-year-old Martin Richard, who was one of the three victims killed in the blast.
MSP reports that Prudential Exit from Mass Pike EB (Exit 22)is now open.The ramp to Copley remains closed.
— MASS STATE POLICE (@MassStatePolice) April 17, 2013
At least 54 people remain hospitalized this morning, with at least 12 still in critical condition.
Dr. Peter Burke, head of Boston Medical Center’s trauma unit, said during a news conference this morning that most bombing injuries were to the lower extremities. He added that doctors there have performed seven amputation on five patients.
“Well you have to be honest with patients about that,” Burke said. “It’s a very difficult thing for both the patients especially, and their families and the care givers. ”
MGH is still treating 12 patients, eight of which are in critical condition. Beth Israel is still treating 13, Children’s, 3 and Tufts, 7.
Setting a decades-old rivalry aside, the New York Yankees paid tribute to the victims of the Boston Marathon bombings last night by playing “Sweet Caroline” at Yankee Stadium.
Update 1:30 p.m.: Boston University has confirmed the identify of the victim killed in the Boston Marathon bombings as Lingzi Lu, a graduate student in mathematics and statistics.
Our original post continues:
The Associated Press reports:
The Shenyang Evening News said on its official Twitter-like microblog account that the victim’s name is [Lingzi Lu.] An editor at the newspaper said that Lu’s father confirmed his daughter’s death when reporters visited the family home. The editor declined to give his name because he was not authorized to speak to foreign media.
The Chinese Foreign Ministry and Consulate General in New York are not releasing the victim’s name at the request of the family. But on Tuesday, Boston media quoted a Chinese Consulate General official as saying a Chinese national was missing in the wake of Monday’s bombings.
Gov. Deval Patrick told WBUR’s Bob Oakes this morning that we should all “settle down and settle in for a long, painstaking investigation” and take comfort knowing “every conceivable resource at the federal, state and local level has been applied” to the investigation.
Patrick also said he believes next year’s Boston Marathon will be “bigger and better” than ever.
“And the one after that and the one after that, for the next 117 years, will be its own living memorial to the resilience of this community and that civic ritual,” Patrick said.
Listen to our entire conversation with the governor below:
WBUR’s Asma Khalid reports hundreds gathered on Boston Common last night to mourn victims of the blast:
Young and old came to show their respects to the city. Some, such as Lizzie Lee from Washington, were from out of state. Lee ran the Boston Marathon for the first time this year, but she never finished. She was about two minutes from the end when the explosions erupted. She says she’ll run again next year.
“We cannot live in fear, and we’ll show them, right? That’s what, we have to show,” Lee said.
Khalid said the message that echoed time and again last night was one of hope.
At Garvey Playground in Dorchester last night, hundreds more also gathered to remember 8-year-old Martin Richard, who was one of the three victims killed in the blast.
More photos from last night on Boston Common can be found here.
WBUR’s Martha Bebinger reported on our air this morning that operating tables across the city have become an extension of the search for evidence that might lead to a suspect in the bombings:
Every fragment that comes out of a patient’s body is preserved.
“We’re working very closely with investigators and we’re handing them whatever evidence we can find,” said George Velmahos, chief of trauma surgery at Mass General Hospital.
Ripped shoes and torn clothes are also collected in case they hold clues about the explosion.
“Anytime a trauma patient comes in where it could be related to a crime or possible accident that is under investigation, all that is always saved,” said Tracey Dechert, a trauma surgeon at Boston Medical Center.
Of the more than 180 people injured in the two blasts, according to The Boston Globe 70 people remained in the hospital overnight Tuesday, with 24 in critical condition. Eleven people have had limbs amputated.
The FBI is working to reconstruct the two devices used in the Boston Marathon blast Monday, using evidence found at the scene. Authorities say the timed bombs were made using pressure cookers filled with explosives, nails and other shrapnel.
Officials continue to appeal to the public for photos, videos or any clues that could help solve the bombings. Yesterday, officials said witnesses may have seen the bomber carrying a heavy nylon bag. By midday Tuesday, more than 2,000 tips had been received by the FBI. (If you have tips, photos or video you can call 1-800-CALL-FBI or email firstname.lastname@example.org)
Two photos from a FBI and Department of Homeland Security bulletin show 1) the remains of a pressure cooker that investigators say was part of one of the bombs that exploded during the marathon and 2) what the FBI says is a black backpack that contained one of the bombs:
WBUR’s David Boeri reports that at this point, it does not appear that authorities have any suspects. Richard DesLauriers, the FBI agent in charge of the investigation, said yesterday that the “range of suspects and motives remains wide open.”
We’re ending the updates for the night; we’ll pick back up in the morning.
Today, the investigation into the bombing progressed, we learned more about the three fatalities, and Boston continued to cope with the tragedy. You can scroll down through this page for those updates and stories, or read the AP recap.
The Associated Press reports:
The Chinese Consulate in New York says a Chinese national is the third person killed in the Boston marathon blasts.
An official at the consulate’s press section, who was not authorized to give his name, said that one Chinese student was injured and another died in the blast.
The official said a work group from the consulate was in Boston to investigate the situation and assist relatives of the victims.
The official Chinese news agency Xinhua reported that relatives have requested that the deceased not be identified.
As we reported earlier, Boston University says the third fatality has been identified as a BU graduate student, but the name has not been released, pending permission from the family.
WBUR has not independently confirmed whether BU and the consulate are referring to the same person.
WBUR arts reporter Andrea Shea reports today:
BOSTON — Many Boston arts organizations cancelled events yesterday in the wake of the horrific explosions, including the Boston Symphony Orchestra. But today, doors reopened, and some places, like the Museum of Fine Arts, offered free admission.
Christine Truffant, of Everett, found comfort at the MFA, which she said counteracted the brutality on display yesterday.
“In some deep way it rips at the heart and soul of a city that was doing something that was so much fun,” Truffant said in the MFA’s lobby.
“The museum is always a refuge and a solace for people,” said MFA director Malcolm Rogers, “and what better thing could we do?”
Rogers said he took cues from his peers when deciding to waive admission fees for the day.
“Last night I received several messages from museum directors in other cities saying how important the museum was in times of trouble in their community,” he said.
Rogers calls the gesture a fulfillment of responsibility, and said he’s gratified to have seen blue and yellow jackets of marathon runners in the galleries today.
“In times of dark deed we present the very best things that human minds, imaginations, hands, can create — really the eternal positive that a museum presents.”
Other arts institutions are doing their part to help Boston carry on, including:
The Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum is offering free admission tomorrow. The Coolidge Corner Theatre in Brookline is taking Red Cross donations for victims of the explosion at the box office. And Thursday night the BSO is dedicating its concert to the victims and their families.
In All Things Considered, WBUR’s Sacha Pfeiffer spoke with Stephen Flynn, co-director of the George J. Kostas Research Institute for Homeland Security at Northeastern University, about the nature of terror threats today and what the Boston Marathon is likely to look and feel like next year.
Just now, Boston University reveals:
One of the victims killed by blasts at the Boston Marathon on Monday has been identified as a Boston University graduate student. The student’s name has not been released, pending permission to do so from the family.
BU adds “the student was one of three friends who watched the race near the finish line.”
Many prayer services, vigils, and other demonstrations are being organized around the Boston area over the next few days. Here is a sampling:
- Our Lady Comforter of the Afflicted Parish, Waltham, Ma. 920 Trapelo Road, Rosary and prayer, 5 – 6 p.m.
- The Paulist Center, 5 Park St. 5:15 p.m. and 6:15 p.m., Interfaith Candlelight Services.
- Marsh Plaza, 5:30 p.m. Rev. Robert Hill, Dean of Marsh Chapel, will open the ceremony, and Brother Larry Whitney, the University chaplain for community life, will give the closing prayer.
- First Parish Dorchester, 6 p.m. 10 Parish St. Dorchester, Ma.
- Holy Cross Cathedral, 1400 Washington St., 6 p.m. Mass in Blessed Sacrament Chapel.
- Boston Common, near Park St. 6 – 8 p.m. Vigil
- St. Ann’s Church, 243 Neponset Ave., 7:30 p.m. Mass.
- Arlington Street Church, Arlington and Boylston St., 8 p.m. Candlelight Vigil.
Masses and prayer services from the Archdiocese of Boston
Boston.com: Reflection Services
Boston Magazine: Boston Vigils
In addition, on Friday, April 19, 2013, Boston College students are organizing a walk fo to finish the “last 5″ of the marathon from St. Ignatius to the finish line. More information here.
Richard DesLauriers, the FBI’s special agent in charge of Boston, said blast evidence — including shards of black nylon, BBs, nails and what may have been a pressure cooker device — is under analysis.
DesLauriers added that by noon today, the agency had received about 2,000 tips from the public. And again he asked for the public’s assistance, including from those who may have seen someone carrying what officials are postulating was a heavy, black nylon bag.
Some other details from the just-completed briefing:
— Authorities are not ready to identify the third fatality from the bombing, pending notification of next-of-kin.
— The governor and the city of Boston have announced the creation of OneFundBoston.org to collect resources to help victims and their families.
— Gov. Deval Patrick announced on Thursday morning there will be an interfaith service at the South End’s Cathedral of the Holy Cross, and President Obama will attend it.
— Patrick added: “This is a painful and tragic lesson but we will learn from this. Next year’s marathon will be even bigger and better.”
This post was updated after the news conference.