Flourishing Seals Frustrate Cape Cod Fishermen

Children watch gray seals swim among the docked boats at Chatham's fish pier. (Curt Nickisch/WBUR)

Children watch gray seals swim among the docked boats at Chatham’s fish pier. (Curt Nickisch/WBUR)

CHATHAM, Mass. — At Chatham Harbor on Cape Cod, fishermen are unloading their trawlers with the catch of the day. The fishing pier is popular with tourists, but not just for ogling the grungy fishermen at work.

Gray seals pop their heads out of the water. They dip and dive and swim around the docked boats, waiting, like dogs around a dinner table, for fish to fall off.

Commercial fisherman Sam Fuller says the seals cost the gillnetting boat he works on thousands of dollars in lost catch and destroyed nets. (Curt Nickisch/WBUR)

Commercial fisherman Sam Fuller says the seals cost the gillnetting boat he works on thousands of dollars in lost catch and destroyed nets. (Curt Nickisch/WBUR)

“When I was a kid you’d be like, ‘Oh! There’s a seal.’ And it was cool to see one,” fisherman Sam Fuller says. “Now they’re like, everywhere.”

Fuller now sees them as a nuisance. He says they’ve learned to follow his boat like a chuck wagon, waiting for crew members to pull up a net.

“All the fish are in it,” Fuller says. “The seals just sit there and eat the fish out of the net as it’s coming up onto the boat.”

The seals’ sharp teeth also tear the nets. Fuller says those cost hundreds of dollars each to replace.

But federal law bars him and other fishermen from shooing the gray seals away, much less shooting them. Same goes for residents angry that their pricey beachfront property is now a favorite sunbathing spot for 300-pound pinnipeds. Chatham dock worker Ron Eppler thinks at least commercial fishermen should be able to do something.

“You know, if you own a ranch in Montana, and you’ve got a coyote problem, you’re allowed to protect your livestock,” Eppler says. “But these guys aren’t allowed to get near them because they’re cute.”

Actually, the seals are protected because they were almost wiped out.

Signs at Chatham's fish pier warn tourists it's illegal to harass seals. (Curt Nickisch/WBUR)

Signs at Chatham’s fish pier warn tourists it’s illegal to harass seals. (Curt Nickisch/WBUR)

Early New Englanders hunted seals for their furs, and to keep them from eating cod. Massachusetts paid bounties on seals, $5 per nose. But 40 years ago, the federal government outlawed killing and harassing seals. The Marine Mammal Protection Act helped gray seals and harbor seals recolonize New England waters. And they’re not only the ocean animal to return.

Last week a family boating off of Monomoy Island shot this home video of a great white shark devouring a seal carcass. Last month, a swimmer was mauled by a great white off of a beach in Truro.

“If you asked me in 2005: ‘Why don’t we know more about the great white shark?,’ I would have looked at you and said, ‘Because I can’t find it,’” says state shark biologist Greg Skomal.

Skomal says the predator is now back in Massachusetts waters, because the prey is back. And some people don’t mind at all.

In Chatham, Beachcomber Tours employee Dylan Preston says seal watching boats have been selling out this summer.

“This is the busiest it’s been,” Preston says. “I mean sometimes we’ll have seven to eight tours going out a day, which is pretty crazy. A good year, definitely.”

A tourist pays for a seal watching tour at the Chatham business Beachcomber Tours. (Curt Nickisch/WBUR)

A tourist pays for a seal watching tour at the Chatham business Beachcomber Tours. (Curt Nickisch/WBUR)

All those tourists are witnessing a marine ecosystem that’s still finding a renewed balance. Stephanie Wood, a biologist for the Northeast Fisheries Science Center at Woods Hole, says the seal population has tripled over the last dozen years, but eventually will level off.

“There’s only so much food and space,” Wood says. “But again, I don’t think we have any specific idea of when seals in Massachusetts are going to reach capacity.”

Back at the Chatham pier, fishing boat captain John Our is pessimistic about controlling the seals.

“It would take an act of Congress,” Our says. “And there’s not a congressman in his right mind that’s gonna be the first one out that says, ‘Let’s go harvest seals.’ ”

An aerial survey last year counted 15,000 of them in Massachusetts waters. To Our, it’s like he’s competing with 15,000 fishermen that don’t have limits.

Please follow our community rules when engaging in comment discussion on wbur.org.
  • Dave Seaman

    Again: Global Warming.

    • Diver Dawg

      Nothing to do with global warming. We need more sharks. 

  • Cmscott123

    Too funee…..No seal hunt, few predators, of course they will show up in our back yards…..Maybe now that is an issue in theUSA something might bet done about culling these critters…they are cute and I love them but to many of anything is NOT a good thiing.

    Contrary Mary From St John’s City Nl

  • Jd_wave

    nada to do with global warming.  selas are protected from killing, combined with only large sharks as population check. and large sharks do not breed fast. in canada the cod fishing was banned 20 years ago and never came back, guess what the seal population did in canada? doubled every 7 years and is now close to 400K seals. guess what? grey seals are much bigger than harbor seals, close to 800 pounds. they eat lots of fish. simple math here.

  • Rm2biz

    I think it is San Diego, CA that has thousands of seals all over the docks, have sunk a few pleasure boats by overloading them.  They also have overloaded the floaating docks, as well. If the seals find a way onto your boat, tough luck as they are protected, your boat is not!  Maybe some one will release a couple of Orca’s. They like seals over for dinner!

  • Mrlongleg1962

    Seals mostly eat very small fish and therefore are not a real competition for the fisherman. This has been found by marine biologists. Most of them are feeding very close to the shore, just wtach them on Chatham beach – the big fish don’t come so close to the shore.

    • http://capecodfisherman.net/ Cape_Cod_19

       10,000 seals eating 10 pounds of fish/day = 100,000 pounds.  Yep you’re right, no problem there…..wow.

      • MrLongleg

        Seriously, might be even more. But the species of fish they are mostly eating is not on the fishermen’s target list. Just compare this to whales, they eat tons every day and most of them eat only Plankton, so no problem for the fishermen, because humans don’ eat plankton. Of course seals will also eat bigger fish when they catch one. But this is difficult and troublesome for them.

        • http://capecodfisherman.net/ Cape_Cod_19

           Wrong…seals eat flounder, cod, striped bass, tautog, sea bass, fluke and bluefish.  Whales eat san d eels, lots and lots of sand eels.  Do your homework…I live here.  An 500 pound seal has no problem catching or eating a big fish.

Most Popular