Support WBURTracing Hanukkah's U.S. Roots ... To Cincinnati?Play04:00Download AudioNPR StaffDecember 01, 2010 ShareRabbi Joshua Metzger, his wife Brocha, and their children Menachem Mendel and Sarah Perel stand by a menorah on the first night of Hanukkah in 2005, which fell on Christmas Day. (AP)